What should you look for when buying?
First, assess how delicate the bindings are, then measure the largest magazine when fully open. After that, test image quality, OCR and your shared file-handling process using sample pages.
| Priority |
What to look for when buying |
Who this matters most to |
| Protecting originals |
Assess the condition and opening angle of the magazines; test the cradle and capture process without forcing them flat. |
When I’m working with a brittle magazine, I don’t want to put unnecessary pressure on its binding or pages. Around 36% of consumers prioritise handling originals carefully when buying. |
| Small print and OCR |
Compare sample pages with small print, a deep gutter, columns and illustrations, checking both the image and OCR output. |
If I want to find items in the archive later, both the page image and the recognised text need to be usable. Around 29% of consumers prioritise files that are clear and searchable. |
| Capturing full pages |
Measure the largest magazine, including the margins you want to capture. CZUR and VIISAN list A3 for the ET24 Pro and K21; VIISAN lists A2 for the S21. |
If my magazines are larger, I want to capture as much of the page as possible in a single image. Around 21% of consumers prioritise having a capture area that fits their needs. |
| A shared workflow |
Test the operating system, installation permissions, capture controls, file naming and storage with several users. |
When several people are working on the archive, I need a clear process for setup, page order and export. Around 14% of consumers prioritise a well-coordinated shared scanning workflow. |
Brands to consider
The details below relate to the product ranges mentioned and are no substitute for testing with your own magazines and studio computers.
CZUR
According to CZUR, the ET range includes overhead scanners for bound materials; the ET24 Pro is designed for book scanning in the A3 range.
- CZUR describes curve correction and OCR features for the range.
- Test the results with your own magazine and check that the software version is compatible with your studio computer.
VIISAN
According to VIISAN, the K21 is designed for materials up to an A3 capture area, while the S21 can capture larger materials up to A2.
- VIISAN lists book correction and OCR for both models.
- The S21’s resolution of up to 600 dpi is software-interpolated output; the K21 and S21 are not the same in terms of format or features.
Ricoh ScanSnap
Ricoh describes the ScanSnap SV600 as an overhead scanner for bound and delicate materials.
- Ricoh lists page detection, timed capture and book image correction.
- These features don’t guarantee flawless results with every historical magazine, so test your sample pages.
Plustek
The OpticBook 4800 is a book-edge flatbed scanner for individual pages that can be placed safely on the platen.
- Plustek lists a 2 mm book edge, OCR and a capture area of approximately A4 size.
- The original needs to sit safely on the platen, so this device is not a one-size-fits-all replacement for careful overhead scanning.
IRIS
According to IRIS, the IRIScan Desk 6 Pro combines overhead A3 capture with searchable and editable export formats.
- The listed export formats may be useful for a research archive.
- IRIS describes an online installer and the camera permissions required. Check the setup process for your shared computer, and test both the image and OCR with your own materials.
Suitable products at Joybuy
Related products will be available soon.
Frequently asked questions
How should we get started with brittle or tightly bound magazines?
First, check whether the magazine can be handled and opened without causing damage. The Library of Congress cites damaged bindings and restricted opening angles as reasons for a conservation assessment; the U.S. National Archives recommends suitable supports and book scanners for bound materials. This guidance is about protecting collections and is not a blanket legal requirement to buy particular equipment.
Is a searchable PDF enough for an archive?
Not without checking the page image and the recognised text. The Zeitschriftendatenbank distinguishes digital page images as a basic level from OCR full text generated in addition. Before scanning a batch, decide which level you need and check both using sample pages.
What should we check before setting up on a shared computer?
Check the operating system, installation permissions, camera permissions and where the files will be stored. For the Desk 6 Pro, IRIS lists an online installer and camera permissions, as well as additional access permissions on macOS; CZUR publishes separate software versions for the ET24 Pro.
What work will the studio need to do after buying?
Allow time for condition checks, turning pages, checking that everything has been captured and, where necessary, correcting OCR. The Zeitschriftendatenbank describes digitising originals as time-consuming. Before the team starts the project, also check software access and support for the specific model variant.
Can we scan entire old magazines and share the files around the studio?
There is no blanket answer. Section 53 of the German Copyright Act (UrhG) distinguishes, among other things, between private copies and certain archival purposes; at the same time, copies must not be distributed or used for public communication. The permissions or exceptions that apply to a particular magazine and intended use depend on the rights, the material and how it will be used. The age of the magazine alone does not settle the question. Source: Federal Ministry of Justice and Federal Office of Justice, Gesetze im Internet.