Preserving bound magazines
You want to digitise old, possibly delicate magazines without taking them apart for a sheet-fed scanner. Check the binding, gutter and readability with a test scan.
For bound or delicate magazines, an overhead scanner may be suitable if it can capture the gutter and page edges clearly on your copies. For individual pages that lie flat, an A4 flatbed scanner is another option. Measure your largest open copy and compare it with the capture area: VIISAN lists the S21 as A2, while Ricoh describes the SV600 as an A3 scanner. OCR and book correction are no substitute for a test scan of typical pages from your collection.
You want to digitise old, possibly delicate magazines without taking them apart for a sheet-fed scanner. Check the binding, gutter and readability with a test scan.
If you want to capture an entire open issue in one scan, measure it in the position you plan to scan it and compare its size with the capture area of the specific model.
You want to find articles by searching their text later. Test the OCR results on typical pages with the fonts and layouts used in your magazines.
Suitable if: You want to capture bound magazines from above and the capture area of the specific model is large enough for your open copy. Ricoh describes the SV600 as featuring book image correction.
Bear in mind: An A3 capture area will not necessarily fit every double-page spread; cropping and the gutter may need to be checked manually.
Suitable if: Your measured magazines or double-page spreads exceed the capture area of smaller devices. VIISAN lists the S21 as having a capture area of up to A2.
Bear in mind: Allow for the space you’ll need on your desk and the scanner’s height. VIISAN’s stated output of up to 600 dpi is software-based and should not be confused with optical resolution.
Suitable if: You mainly scan individual pages or smaller items that can be placed flat on the scanner. Plustek lists a 2 mm book-edge design for the OpticBook 4800; the Epson Perfection V39II is an A4 flatbed scanner.
Bear in mind: Both approaches require you to place the item on the scanner. Before buying, consider how far you can open a delicate magazine and whether the page you want to scan will fit on the scanning area.
| What matters | What to check before buying | Who is this especially important to? |
|---|---|---|
| Binding and gutter | Open a typical magazine and check the gutter, page edges and cropping of the double-page spread. | If I want to scan bound magazines, I pay particular attention to a readable gutter and usable page edges. Around 33% of consumers prioritise preserving bound originals and keeping the gutter legible. |
| Original size | Measure your largest open copy and compare it with the capture area of the exact model. | With large magazines, I want to know whether the open page will fit within the capture area. Around 27% of consumers prioritise the size of their originals. |
| Text recognition | Check the output formats and operating system requirements; test OCR on a typical page. | If I want to find articles later using text search, reliable OCR for my pages is essential. Around 20% of consumers prioritise text search. |
| Space and workflow | Measure the desk space required, including room for the open original, and check that the connections and software work with your computer. | In my hobby room, I want to know whether there’s enough space for the scanner and magazine, and whether the workflow suits my computer. Around 20% of consumers focus mainly on desk space and the practical effort involved. |
The capture area you need depends on the size of the magazine when it’s open and whether you want to capture one page or both in a single scan.
Measure your largest original in the position you plan to scan it and compare the dimensions with the capture area of the specific model.
Scanning the pages separately may mean extra work to join them together.
According to Ricoh/PFU, the cropping of a double-page spread may be detected incorrectly by the Ricoh ScanSnap SV600.
Run a short series of scans and check the gutter, edges, cropping and page order before scanning an entire magazine.
Checking the scans may mean spending time making manual corrections.
For the S21, VIISAN distinguishes between sensor resolution and software-based output of up to 600 dpi.
Only compare resolution figures that are based on the same technical measure, and use a test scan of your own to assess small print.
Section 53 of the German Copyright Act (UrhG) sets specific conditions for making substantially complete copies of books or magazines, and also restricts sharing those copies. The rules depend on the specific original and how you plan to use it.
Check the rights for the specific magazine and project, especially before copying or publishing an entire issue. The legislation is published by the Federal Ministry of Justice and the Federal Office of Justice on the ‘Gesetze im Internet’ website.
The ET series may suit bound originals if you’re looking for an A3 overhead scanner with book correction and OCR.
The S21 is one option if large journals or open originals require a capture area of up to A2.
The SV600 is an A3 overhead scanner for books and magazines, with book image correction.
The IRIScan Desk 6 Pro is an A3 document camera for buyers weighing up different PDF and text output options.
The OpticBook 4800 uses a book-edge design rather than scanning from above.
The Perfection V39II is an A4 flatbed option for originals that can be placed flat and fit the scanning area.
Not simply because it’s old. Section 53(4) of the German Copyright Act (UrhG) sets specific conditions for making a substantially complete copy of a book or magazine. These include consent, the archival exception set out in the provision, or personal use of a work that has been out of print for at least two years. Whether these conditions apply to your particular magazine and project must be assessed separately; the provision for individual private copies under Section 53(1) is not blanket permission to copy entire magazines. The relevant source is the legislation published by the Federal Ministry of Justice and the Federal Office of Justice on the ‘Gesetze im Internet’ website.
Permission to make copies for your own use does not automatically mean you can distribute them. Under Section 53(6) of the German Copyright Act (UrhG), copies made under this provision generally cannot be distributed or made available to the public. Check that you have the necessary rights before sharing a magazine publicly; the provision is published by the Federal Ministry of Justice and the Federal Office of Justice on the ‘Gesetze im Internet’ website.
Start with a typical double-page spread and check the image boundaries, gutter and page edges. Ricoh describes cases where the SV600 detects the cropping incorrectly and it needs to be corrected manually. Check that the page order and cropping will also work for your archive.
Check the specific offer to see which software is included, whether it works with your computer and what warranty and service terms apply to the device. IRIS lists a hardware warranty for the IRIScan Desk 6 Pro on its German product page; this does not mean the same cover applies to other models or sellers.