If you want to protect old bindings
If you’re digitising brittle or tightly bound magazines, check whether you can position them on a glass surface without applying pressure.
For old, fragile or tightly bound magazines, a contactless overhead scanner is an obvious choice. A flatbed book scanner may also be suitable if the pages are sturdy enough to be placed on the glass one at a time. The key considerations are the size of the open double-page spread, the space needed for the scanner and for using it, and a test scan of the fold, glossy paper and text recognition. Whether you can share scans depends on more than just buying a scanner.
If you’re digitising brittle or tightly bound magazines, check whether you can position them on a glass surface without applying pressure.
If an open magazine is larger than a single A4 page, compare its actual dimensions with the scanning area of the specific model.
If you want to scan lots of pages and find them again later, check the scanning process and whether the text recognition software works well with your magazines.
| Purchasing priority | What to check before buying | Who it matters most to |
|---|---|---|
| Protecting the binding and paper | Check for contactless scanning, the opening angle required and whether you can position the magazine without forcing it open. | If my magazine is fragile or tightly bound, I want to scan it without putting pressure on the binding. Around 31% of consumers are most concerned about protecting the binding. |
| Size of the open original | Measure the largest double-page spread when open and compare it with the scanning area of the specific version of the device. | If the open magazine is larger than a single A4 page, the entire original needs to fit within the scanning area. Around 25% of consumers prioritise the size of the original. |
| Workflow and searchable text | Test several pages, including page turns, and check the text recognition and exported files. | If I’m scanning lots of teaching materials, I want to check the order and readability of the pages and be able to find the text later. Around 25% of consumers prioritise this workflow. |
| Desk space | Measure the device, the open magazine and the space needed to use it together; also check computer and software requirements. | If desk space in the classroom is limited, I need room not only for the device but also to open and turn the pages. Around 19% of consumers are most concerned about limited space. |
The open double-page spread may need more scanning space than the closed cover suggests.
Measure the largest page when the magazine is open, then compare its width and height with the scanning area of the specific model.
If the entire page won’t fit in the scanning area, you may need to take several separate scans or choose a different device.
Software that corrects curved pages doesn’t guarantee that text along the fold of a damaged or badly curved original will remain readable.
Before choosing a scanner, assess a test scan of the fold, glossy paper and small print.
Allow time to check the scans and edit them afterwards if necessary.
An overhead scanner captures originals without contact; with a flatbed scanner, you place each page on the glass individually. Opening and positioning a magazine may not be suitable if its binding is brittle.
Check the condition of the magazine and how far it can safely be opened before choosing a scanner type.
CZUR lists the Aura X Pro as discontinued. A similar name alone doesn’t confirm that a product is the same model or that a particular version is still available.
Check the exact model name and version in the listing before comparing it with an older entry.
The ET series is designed for bound documents and magazines; the ET16 Plus and ET24 Pro are different model variants.
The SV600 is positioned as a contactless overhead scanner for bound and delicate originals.
The S21 is an overhead scanner for larger originals; the manufacturer lists magazines as one of its intended uses.
The IRIScan Desk 7 Pro is a document camera designed for limited desk space and occasional book scanning.
The OpticBook 3800L is a flatbed book scanner for pages placed on the glass individually, rather than contactless scanning of double-page spreads.
Not as a blanket rule. Under certain conditions, Section 60a of the German Copyright Act (UrhG) generally permits the use of up to 15% of a published work to illustrate non-commercial teaching, for the specified group of people. Individual articles from the same specialist or scientific journal are dealt with separately in subsection 2. The German Federal Ministry of Justice and the Federal Office of Justice provide this legislation; whether you can share a complete issue or pass it on in another way cannot be determined solely by how old the magazine is or whether you have bought a scanner.
If scans contain personal data that is processed, you’ll need to check that you have an appropriate legal basis. The Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information explains the basics of data protection law; an educational or archival purpose alone doesn’t remove the need to check. Before saving or sharing the scans, consider their specific content and who they’re intended for.
Position the original within the scanning area and test several pages, including the fold and cover. ScanSnap lists page detection and timed scanning for the SV600. Afterwards, check the page order, any cropped edges and the readability of the exported files.
For the exact device version, check that it works with your computer and operating system, which text recognition software and accessories are included, and what warranty terms apply to the specific offer. Plustek’s regional specifications for the OpticBook 3800L vary, so check which version is on offer before relying on specific features or specifications.