Which book scanner is right for you?

Protectors of bound recipe books

If you want to capture lots of original or delicate books without removing pages or flattening the binding, try out the scanning process and book-page correction on one of your own books. CZUR, VIISAN and IRIS describe these kinds of features for specific product ranges or models.

Archivists of handwritten recipes

For ingredients, quantities and marginal notes, what matters is whether the handwriting remains legible in the saved image and is actually recognised as text. IRIS distinguishes between image and text output; its comparison table states that the A3 scanner described there does not recognise handwriting.

Organisers of a shared collection

If you’re digitising books of different sizes at a shared workstation, factor the capture area, software and file naming into your workflow. You should also consider rights and any personal details before sharing files. The Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information explains how the GDPR applies to associations, too.

What should you look for when choosing one?

First, decide how carefully you need to handle your bound books. Then compare how legible your actual recipes are, the size of the originals and the work involved in checking and filing your scans.

What matters What to check before buying Who should pay particular attention?
Binding and gutter Open a typical book fully and check the gutter, edges and page order in a test scan. If I don’t want to open bound originals too far or position them on glass, I pay particular attention to a contactless process and the results at the gutter. Around 36% of consumers put protecting the binding first.
Handwriting and quantities Test a typical page as an image and as a searchable PDF; compare the recognised words with the original. If small ingredient quantities and handwritten changes need to remain legible, a searchable PDF alone isn’t enough to guide my choice. Around 29% of consumers prioritise the legibility of handwritten entries.
Book sizes Measure the largest book when open, including any inserts, and check all page edges in a test scan. If I’m scanning books of different sizes or pages with notes stuck in, I want to make sure the whole original fits in the image. Around 21% of consumers prioritise support for different sizes.
Shared workflow Check the software for the specific model, export formats and the process from original to organised file. If several people will be scanning and sharing files, a clear filing system and reliable visual checks matter most to me. Around 14% of consumers put a shared scanning and filing workflow first.

Common buying and usage mistakes

  • Assuming OCR means reliable handwriting recognition

    A searchable PDF or OCR feature doesn’t prove that handwritten ingredients and quantities will be recognised. The IRIS comparison table states that the A3 scanner described there does not recognise handwriting.

    Test a typical recipe page separately as an image and as searchable text. Compare recognised entries with the original, and keep legible page images.

    Recognition errors may mean you need to check the text manually, transcribe it or scan the pages again.

  • Comparing only the stated resolution

    VIISAN explicitly describes the S21’s output of up to 600 dpi as software-interpolated. This is not the same as a stated optical resolution.

    Compare test scans of small print, the gutter and marginal notes rather than relying on interpolated output alone as a measure of captured detail.

    Small entries or missing image details may mean extra editing is needed.

  • Assuming book correction guarantees a flawless scan

    Ricoh notes that automatic cropping errors can occur with the ScanSnap SV600; saved images may need to be corrected manually.

    Check a short run of scans for the gutter, outer edges and page order before working through a larger batch.

    Checking the crop and page order can take time.

  • Assuming that being able to scan something means you’re allowed to share it

    Whether content is protected by copyright and how it can be used depends on the material and how you plan to use it. Section 53 of the German Copyright Act (UrhG) places limits on complete copies of books and their distribution.

    Choose your equipment separately from checking which originals and scans the group is actually allowed to use and share. Make sure you have the relevant rights for protected content.

Relevant brands at a glance

CZUR

According to CZUR, the ET range is designed for contactless book scanning with curved-page flattening, which may suit frequent scanning of bound books.

  • CZUR lists book-page correction and scanning up to A3 for the ET range.
  • These manufacturer claims don’t prove that specific handwriting will be legible, or that every model and variant has the same features.

Plustek

The OpticBook 3800L offers an A4 book-edge flatbed scanning process, where you position individual pages.

  • Plustek describes a 6 mm book edge and software for creating searchable files.
  • A stiff binding needs to be positioned carefully on the glass. The manufacturer’s claim about reducing shadows isn’t an independent test on your specific recipe book.

VIISAN

According to VIISAN, the S21 is a contactless overhead scanner for larger bound originals.

  • VIISAN lists curve correction and OCR.
  • The stated output of up to 600 dpi is software-interpolated, not quoted as an optical resolution. Check the image quality of small handwriting using one of your own books.

IRIS

According to the manufacturer, the IRIScan Desk 6 Pro combines A3 book scanning with a range of image and text outputs.

  • IRIS lists options including image PDF and searchable PDF, which you can assess separately for different archiving needs.
  • The IRIS comparison table states that the A3 scanner described there does not recognise handwriting. Check the software and output for the specific model.

Ricoh ScanSnap

The ScanSnap SV600 offers an overhead scanning process with book image correction in ScanSnap Home.

  • Ricoh’s help pages describe correction of saved double-page spreads, provided the stated software requirements are met.
  • Ricoh documents possible errors with automatic cropping, so the results may need to be checked manually.

Suitable products at Joybuy

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Does OCR automatically make handwritten recipes searchable?

No, you can’t assume that from an OCR specification alone. IRIS states that the A3 scanner described does not recognise handwriting. Keep legible page images and test a typical handwritten page before deciding on your archiving process.

How should the group check its first scans?

Scan a typical double-page spread and check the gutter, outer edges, ingredient quantities, page order and saved files. Book image correction doesn’t replace a visual check: Ricoh documents possible automatic cropping errors with the SV600 and explains how to correct them manually.

Can we scan entire recipe books and share the files with the group?

Not simply because a scanner makes it technically possible. The German Patent and Trade Mark Office explains that whether a work qualifies for protection depends on the individual case; Section 53 of the German Copyright Act (UrhG) distinguishes between private copies, copies of substantially complete books and their distribution. Check the relevant rights and permissions before scanning or sharing protected content in full.

What should we bear in mind if books contain names or personal notes?

If scans contain personal information and the group processes or shares it, you should consider data protection. The Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information explains that the GDPR also covers the processing of personal data by associations. Before sharing, decide which entries are needed and who will have access.

What software and service terms should the group check?

For the specific product, check which scanning and OCR software is included, which group computer it runs on and what the warranty terms are. A manufacturer’s warranty is not the same as your statutory rights against the seller; which rights apply also depends on who buys the device.