Which option is right for you?

Photographers who want to keep their distance

You want to photograph live butterflies with space between them and the front of your lens, so you compare the actual working distance and composition rather than just the focal length.

Travellers with lightweight camera gear

You photograph butterflies and other subjects on holiday, and weigh the lens’s weight against the level of detail it can capture.

Photographers working in changing conditions

You want to capture small details on the wings while taking focus, shallow depth of field, wind and the butterfly’s movement into account.

What should you consider when choosing?

First decide what you want in the frame. Then compare the specific lens’s working distance, camera mount and weight.

What matters What to look for Who is it important to?
Distance from the butterfly Check the actual working distance for the composition you want, not just the minimum focusing distance. When I photograph live butterflies, I want enough space in front of the lens. Around 33% of consumers prioritise working distance.
The right mount Check that your camera model and mount match the specific lens version on offer. I want to be sure the mount and lens version are compatible with my camera. Around 27% of consumers prioritise checking the mount.
Travel weight and subjects Compare the weight of the specific version with the magnification you need. If I photograph other holiday subjects as well as butterflies, I want a lens that’s easy to carry. Around 20% of consumers prioritise travelling light and versatility.
Keeping subjects sharp in motion Take shallow depth of field, subject movement and exposure when stopping down into account. In wind or when photographing moving subjects, I want to control focus and exposure carefully. Stabilisation won’t keep the subject still. Around 20% of consumers prioritise keeping moving subjects sharp.

Common mistakes when choosing

  • Confusing minimum focusing distance with working distance

    Minimum focusing distance is measured from the sensor to the subject, so it doesn’t tell you directly how much space there is in front of the lens. For the FE 90 mm, Sony gives an actual working distance of around 13 cm at a minimum focus distance of 28 cm.

    For the composition you have in mind, compare the distance from the front of the lens, not just the distance from the sensor.

  • Assuming “Macro” in the name means 1:1 magnification

    Maximum magnification varies by lens. Canon lists a maximum of 0.5x for the RF 85mm F2 and 1.4x for the RF 100mm F2.8 L.

    First decide whether you want to photograph the whole butterfly or very small details, then compare the maximum magnification.

    You may need a lens with greater magnification to capture very small details.

  • Choosing a lens by name without checking the mount version

    Lenses with similar focal lengths aren’t automatically compatible with the same camera system. For example, Sigma offers its 105mm DG DN for Sony E and L-Mount; Tamron lists Sony E and Nikon Z versions of its 90mm F072.

    Before choosing, check your camera model, its mount and the version on offer.

    Choosing an incompatible version could mean extra hassle with returns or exchanges.

  • Assuming stabilisation or weather protection will solve every problem

    Image stabilisation won’t compensate for a butterfly’s movement. Nor does a weather protection rating guarantee protection in every outdoor situation: Sigma explicitly states that its 105mm isn’t waterproof.

    Plan your exposure for moving subjects and check the protection limits of both your lens and camera body.

    Motion blur or moisture getting inside could spoil your shots or damage your equipment.

Key brands at a glance

Canon

For EOS R cameras, the RF options listed range from a lighter lens for versatile close-ups to a macro lens with greater magnification.

  • Canon lists a maximum magnification of 1.4x for the RF 100mm F2.8 L. At 1.0x magnification, optical image stabilisation provides two stops according to Canon’s test standards.
  • Canon lists the RF 85mm F2 at around 500 g, with a maximum magnification of 0.5x. It therefore doesn’t match the RF 100mm’s maximum magnification.

Nikon

For Nikon Z cameras, there’s a stabilised 105 mm telephoto macro lens and a shorter 50 mm macro lens for close-ups.

  • Nikon lists 1:1 magnification and image stabilisation for the Z MC 105mm.
  • Nikon also lists 1:1 magnification for the Z MC 50mm. At its closest focusing distance, the gap between the lens and subject is around 5 cm.

Sony

The FE 90 mm F2.8 Macro G OSS offers 1:1 magnification for compatible Sony E-mount cameras.

  • Sony lists optical stabilisation for the FE 90 mm and an actual working distance of around 13 cm in the close-up situation described.
  • Sony’s stated minimum focusing distance of 0.28 m is measured from the sensor. It isn’t the same as the distance from the front of the lens to the subject.

Sigma

The 105mm F2.8 DG DN MACRO | Art offers 1:1 magnification, with versions for Sony E and L-Mount.

  • Sigma lists a working distance of 141 mm at 1:1 magnification. Weight varies by mount: 710 g or 715 g.
  • Sigma describes the lens as dust- and splash-resistant, but explicitly states that it isn’t waterproof.

Tamron

The 90mm F/2.8 Di III MACRO VXD is listed as a 1:1 lens for Sony E and Nikon Z.

  • Tamron lists a minimum focusing distance of 0.23 m.
  • Weight varies by mount: 630 g or 640 g. The focusing distance isn’t the clear working distance in front of the lens.

Matching products at Joybuy

Matching products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Is the minimum focusing distance the gap between the butterfly and the front of the lens?

No. It’s measured from the sensor to the subject; the actual working distance determines how much space there is in front of the lens. For its FE 90 mm at a minimum focus distance of 28 cm, Sony gives a working distance of around 13 cm.

Can image stabilisation alone keep a moving butterfly sharp?

No. Stabilisation and holding the camera steady can help with blur caused by camera movement, but the butterfly’s movement can still cause motion blur. If you stop down to increase depth of field, you’ll need to take exposure into account.

What should I check before a trip and after wet weather?

Before you travel, check the specific mount version and how to operate the focus limiter. Don’t assume splash resistance means waterproofing: Sigma explicitly rules out waterproofing for its 105mm; Canon notes that dust or droplets can’t be completely excluded for the RF 100mm.

Can I catch or deliberately disturb a wild butterfly to take a photo?

No. Under Section 39(1) of the BNatSchG, wild animals must not be deliberately disturbed or caught without good reason. The access prohibitions in Section 44 of the BNatSchG also apply to specially protected species.

Who should I contact if a lens bought in Germany is faulty?

The retailer is responsible for your statutory rights; any additional manufacturer’s guarantee is separate. If a product is faulty, the first step is generally to seek a repair or replacement. Online purchases usually come with a 14-day right to cancel; the terms of your specific purchase apply. The Verbraucherzentrale explains the difference between statutory rights and guarantees, as well as the cancellation rules.