Joybuy Insights

Buying shoes online: how to compare models, materials and fit properly

Buying shoes online can save time, but without careful checking it can quickly lead to the wrong purchase. Product images often show only the appearance, while fit, sole profile and material care are crucial in everyday use. Three common pitfalls are particularly likely to cause problems:

  • Unclear sizing: An EU size can vary depending on the brand, last and model. A familiar size is therefore not a reliable guide.
  • Overstated comfort claims: Terms such as “lightweight”, “breathable” or “cushioned” say little unless the material, sole construction and intended use are described in more detail.
  • Choosing the wrong shoe for the purpose: A flat trainer is not automatically suitable for long runs. Conversely, a running shoe may look impractical in the office or with more formal clothing.

If you want to buy shoes online, you should first define your own requirements and then compare the technical details with the size chart.

Criteria to check before buying

1. Compare foot length rather than relying on the standard size

It is best to measure both feet in the evening, as foot length can vary slightly throughout the day. Place your foot on a sheet of paper and measure from the longest toe to the heel. Then use the foot length in centimetres or millimetres, if the retailer provides this information.

For example, the adidas Samba OG size chart covers EU 36 to EU 48, with corresponding foot lengths from 22 to 31 cm. For PELLIOT models, the chart ranges from 245 to 275 mm. These measurements are more useful than making a general comparison between UK, US and EU sizes.

Also consider the shape of your feet:

  • Narrow feet often require a narrower last or a slim-fit version.
  • If you have wider feet, there should be enough room around the toes.
  • For unisex shoes, the specific foot-length measurement is more important than whether the shoes are categorised as women’s or men’s footwear.

2. Check the upper material, lining and care requirements

The material affects comfort, ventilation and care. A trainer with a suede or nubuck upper may need different cleaning than a model made from synthetic materials and textile.

According to the product information, the adidas Samba OG has a suede upper, a synthetic leather lining, a synthetic insole and a rubber sole. Cleaning with a soft, damp cloth is recommended. Machine washing is not intended. For rainy days or consistently wet paths, a different choice of material may therefore be more practical.

Lightweight sports shoes and running shoes often use mesh or woven textiles. This construction can support air circulation, but it is more prone to dirt and abrasion. Check whether hand washing, mild soap and air drying are recommended.

3. Choose a sole and tread suited to the surface

The outsole should match the surface you intend to use the shoes on:

  • Trainers and comfortable everyday shoes: Flat rubber or compound soles are common for city pavements and leisure use.
  • Running shoes: Look at the midsole, flexibility and tread designed for asphalt or surfaced paths.
  • Trail running shoes: A more pronounced tread and abrasion-resistant materials can be useful on loose, wet or uneven paths.
  • Slip-resistant shoes: The product description should clearly state the sole material and tread design. “Slip-resistant” is not a substitute for checking the specific surface.
  • Clogs: EVA models are often lightweight and easy to care for, but they may deform differently in warm conditions than traditional leather or textile shoes.

Our selection by intended use

Suitable for: Budget-conscious beginners
PUXI Cheese Clogs Ivory White Size 42-43 Unisex Minimalist Fashion

PUXI Cheese Clogs Ivory White Size 42-43 Unisex Minimalist Fashion

Why this product suits this profile: The one-piece EVA construction is designed for easy cleaning and straightforward use indoors and outdoors. Sizing is based on the recommended foot length.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The product details specify the material, sole thickness and foot lengths. This makes it easier to assess the fit accurately than relying on the size label alone.

Main benefit & strengths

One-piece EVA construction, ventilation openings and a profiled outsole according to the product description.

Suitable for: Quality-focused buyers
adidas Samba OG Cloud White Core Black Clear Granite Men

adidas Samba OG Cloud White / Core Black / Clear Granite Men

Why this product suits this profile: This flat trainer combines a classic design with suede, a synthetic leather lining and a rubber sole. It is suitable for city wear, leisure and pairing with casual or smart-casual outfits.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The size chart includes specific foot lengths. The care instructions also make it clear that the upper is not suitable for machine washing.

Main benefit & strengths

Suede upper, natural rubber cupsole and sizes from EU 36 to EU 48 according to the product information.

Suitable for: Specific uses & frequent wear
PELLIOT Men's Road Running Shoes Lightweight and Cushioned Green Khaki

PELLIOT Men's Road Running Shoes Lightweight and Cushioned – Ultimate Comfort for Long-Distance Running, Green Khaki (EU 43)

Why this product suits this profile: Mesh and woven fabric, an EVA midsole and a profiled ROCKYTEC outsole are designed for running on roads, surfaced paths and varied terrain.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The description specifies the upper, midsole, outsole and options for different foot shapes. This makes it easier to compare the shoes with your route and foot width.

Main benefit & strengths

Sandwich mesh, highly elastic EVA midsole and ROCKYTEC rubber outsole according to the manufacturer’s information.

Looking for more options?

We have put together a complete, regularly updated list of products that fully meet these strict selection criteria and the safety regulations applicable in the EU.

How to categorise other models sensibly

A Nike Dunk Low is functionally closer to a casual trainer than a running shoe. Synthetic leather, textile and a rubber sole can be suitable for everyday and leisure use; however, for regular long-distance running, you should specifically look for running shoes with a suitable midsole and appropriate roll-through.

When choosing clogs, it is worth looking at their weight, ventilation openings and how securely they hold the foot. For wet floors or work areas, information about slip resistance should be clear and verifiable. A profiled sole alone does not guarantee secure grip on every surface.

FAQs about buying shoes online

How do I measure my shoe size for an online order?

Measure both feet barefoot or wearing the socks you intend to wear later. The longer foot is the one that matters. Compare the result with the product-specific size chart rather than just your usual EU size.

How long do trainers and running shoes last?

Their lifespan depends on use, the surface, body weight, care and storage. With running shoes, worn tread, visible cracks or a noticeably changed midsole can indicate wear. With trainers, pay particular attention to the stitching, lining and outsole.

Are lightweight sports shoes automatically suitable for long distances?

No. Low weight describes only one part of a shoe’s construction. Also check the fit, stability, midsole, outsole and intended route. Different models may be suitable for asphalt, woodland paths and technical terrain.