Which recording setup is right for you?

Console gaming with a separate monitor

If you’re explaining controller inputs while playing a console game and want to play on a separate monitor, check HDMI passthrough, the actual recording mode and the audio path. AVerMedia specifies passthrough of up to 2160p60 HDR for the GC311G2, with recording at up to 1080p60. Elgato also lists passthrough of up to 2160p60 and recording at 1080p60 for Game Capture Neo.

Camera view of buttons and hand movements

If your tutorial needs to show which buttons you press, you’ll need a suitable camera source. Elgato describes Cam Link 4K as compatible with a camera that has an unencrypted HDMI output; console passthrough isn’t automatically supported.

Gaming and recording on the same PC

If the game or demonstration programme is running on your recording PC, first try a suitable OBS source. OBS Studio lists a game capture source for Windows, and suitable display or window sources for macOS and Linux.

What should you look for when buying?

First decide whether your tutorial needs to show a PC display, a console signal, a camera view, or several of these sources at once. This determines whether you’ll need software capture, an HDMI input or additional signal paths.

Priority What to check before buying Who is this important for?
The right picture without unnecessary extra hardware Before planning to buy an HDMI card, check whether OBS can capture the game or programme on the same PC. If I want to use as few devices as possible, I’ll first try the right software source. Around 29% of consumers would prioritise getting the right video source without unnecessary extra hardware.
Making controller inputs and hand movements visible Check whether your camera outputs a supported, unencrypted HDMI signal and whether your setup needs a separate video source. If viewers need to see which buttons I press, I’ll need a suitable camera view alongside the gameplay. Around 29% of consumers would put the visibility of inputs and picture details first.
Keep playing on your own monitor Compare the recording and passthrough modes for the same model: AVerMedia lists recording at up to 1080p60 and passthrough of up to 2160p60 HDR for the GC311G2; Elgato lists recording at up to 1080p60 and passthrough of up to 2160p60 for Game Capture Neo. If I want to play on my separate monitor while recording, its signal mode needs to suit my setup. Around 21% of consumers would give particular priority to using a monitor.
Recording game audio and commentary Check the console’s audio output, your recording software’s audio settings and the microphone connection with a short test clip. If I want the game audio and my explanation together in the file, I’ll test both audio sources separately. Around 14% of consumers would prioritise combining game audio with spoken commentary.
Keeping extra devices and cables to a minimum Compare the HDMI and USB connections you’ll need, and check what’s included against your camera, monitor and existing cables. Once I know which video source I’ll use, I want to find out in advance what other devices and cables my setup needs. Around 7% of consumers would give particular consideration to the overall amount of extra equipment required.

Avoid common misconceptions

  • “4K” doesn’t automatically mean 4K recording

    A device can support different modes for its input signal, HDMI passthrough and recording. AVerMedia lists recording at up to 1080p60 for the GC311G2, with passthrough of up to 2160p60 HDR. Elgato likewise lists recording at up to 1080p60 and passthrough of up to 2160p60 for Game Capture Neo.

    For the specific model you’re considering, compare the recording mode you want with your monitor’s passthrough mode.

  • A capture card automatically films your hands too

    A capture card captures an existing video signal; it doesn’t create a separate view of your controller. To show hand movements, you’ll need a suitable camera source that’s available in your recording software.

    Plan every video source before buying and check that your software can use them all at the same time.

  • Audio in your headset is automatically included in the recording

    Hearing game audio in your headset doesn’t prove that it’s also being saved to the video file. Elgato notes that Chat Link doesn’t automatically record your own voice directly.

    Record a short clip with game audio, your headset and spoken commentary, then play back the finished file.

Key brands at a glance

Elgato

The models listed here support different signal paths: Cam Link 4K is designed for a compatible HDMI camera, Game Capture Neo for recording a console with HDMI passthrough, and 4K S for recording at a higher resolution.

  • Elgato lists passthrough of up to 2160p60 and recording at 1080p60 for Game Capture Neo; for 4K S, the manufacturer lists recording at up to 2160p60.
  • Cam Link 4K is described as a camera input via USB, not as a console passthrough device. Manufacturer specifications don’t replace testing the specific combination of devices you plan to use.

AVerMedia

GC311G2 and GC311 are different models. AVerMedia describes the GC311G2 as having USB 3.0 Type-C, while the GC311 has Full HD passthrough and Micro-USB.

  • The GC311G2 specifications list passthrough of up to 2160p60 HDR and recording at up to 1080p60.
  • Check the model name, connections and modes carefully, and test the connection with your recording PC.

UGREEN

Model 25854 is described as an HDMI-to-USB capture device for a suitable HDMI source.

  • The manufacturer lists an input of up to 4K30 and recording at 1080p60.
  • An HDMI output for monitor passthrough isn’t listed for this model. The 4K input specification alone therefore doesn’t confirm 4K console passthrough.

Joybuy products for console recording

The Joybuy products below are selected for HDMI console recording, with the option of monitor passthrough. Compare the listed recording and passthrough modes with your specific setup.

4K video capture card with USB 3.0

4K video capture card with USB 3.0

This device may suit an HDMI console setup with monitor passthrough. Check that its listed modes match the recording quality you want.

USB 3.0; 4K/60-Hz input and HDMI passthrough; 1080p/60-Hz recording; five ports.

Joybuy
4K video capture card with loop-through

4K video capture card with loop-through

If you want to record an HDMI picture and send it to a monitor at the same time, compare these specifications with your setup’s requirements.

4K/60-Hz input; 1080p/60-Hz recording; loop-through; USB 3.0; five ports.

Joybuy
HDMI capture card with input up to 4K/30 Hz

HDMI capture card with input up to 4K/30 Hz

For an HDMI gaming source with monitor passthrough, consider the card’s input specification separately from its recording resolution.

USB 3.0; HDMI input up to 4K/30 Hz; recording at 1080p/60 Hz; HDMI passthrough.

Joybuy
USB 3.0 video capture card with audio capture

USB 3.0 video capture card with audio capture

If you want to record an HDMI gaming source and send it to a monitor, also check how your microphone and game audio will be connected.

USB 3.0; 1080p/60-Hz recording; 4K/60-Hz passthrough; audio capture; five ports.

Joybuy
VIELLAN 4K HDMI video capture card

VIELLAN 4K HDMI video capture card

For an HDMI gaming source with a separate monitor, compare the recording and passthrough specifications with the modes you want to use.

USB 3.0; 1080p recording; 4K HDMI passthrough; microphone input and headphone output. According to the product description, performance may be limited when using a USB 2.0 port.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a capture card for a controller tutorial on the same PC?

Not necessarily. For a game running on that PC, first try a suitable OBS game capture source on Windows. OBS Studio lists different display or window sources for macOS and Linux. You’ll also need a suitable camera source to show your hands.

How do I connect an external console and check the audio?

With a device that supports HDMI passthrough, the planned video path runs from the console to the HDMI input, from the HDMI output to the gaming monitor, and via USB to the recording computer. Add the card as a video capture source there, then check the game audio and microphone separately in a short test clip. Depending on your setup, audio from a controller headset may need its own signal path.

Can I fix a black screen by changing HDCP settings?

It depends on the source and content. PlayStation explains that HDCP can be disabled for gameplay on PS4, but is required for Blu-ray, DVD and DRM-protected streaming content. Don’t assume this guidance applies to another console, and remember that being technically able to record something doesn’t mean you have permission to publish it.

What happens in Germany if my newly purchased card develops a fault?

New goods are generally covered by two years of statutory rights against the seller; a voluntary guarantee is separate. The Verbraucherzentrale recommends contacting the seller if a product develops a fault.

Can I publish my recorded tutorial in Germany?

There’s no straightforward answer. Under certain conditions, § 53 UrhG covers individual copies for private use, but that alone doesn’t permit public communication; § 19a UrhG concerns making works available to the public. Before publishing, check the rights for any game, music, videos or other third-party material shown, as well as any applicable exceptions.