Who would benefit from a capture card?

Comparing PC games without extra equipment

If you’re playing and recording on the same PC, first try recording the game directly with OBS. The OBS Project describes using a Game Capture source for this. If your laptop has multiple GPUs, setup may require a few extra steps.

Recording console games at a compact desk

If you want to record console gameplay and commentary on a laptop while playing on a separate monitor, plan your HDMI and USB connections and audio route together. The OBS Project describes a capture card as one way to record console footage in OBS.

Comparing games with higher resolution requirements

If your finished video needs to show more than Full HD, or your monitor needs to retain a particular high-resolution gaming mode, compare recording and passthrough separately. Elgato lists different recording formats for its models, so check the specifications of the specific card you’re considering.

What should you look for when buying?

Buying criterion What to check Who will find this particularly important?
Do you need a capture card? Check whether the game is running on the PC you’re recording on, or whether it’s coming from a console or second PC. For PC games, try recording directly with OBS first. If I’m playing and recording on the same PC, I’d rather not connect another device if direct recording is enough for my comparison. Around 27% of consumers put the need for extra equipment first.
Monitor gaming mode Compare the resolution and frame rate you need with the HDMI passthrough of the specific card. AVerMedia lists 4K60 passthrough with 1080p60 recording for the GC311G2; Hauppauge specifies a maximum of 1080p60 for both recording and passthrough on the HD PVR 60. If my monitor is connected to the card while I’m playing, I want the pass-through image to match the gaming mode I need. Around 27% of consumers prioritise their monitor’s mode.
Recording format Check the specific model’s combination of recording resolution, frame rate, HDR and operating system. Elgato lists up to 2160p30 for the HD60 X and up to 2160p60 for the 4K S. According to Elgato, HDR recording on the 4K S is currently limited to Windows. If I want to retain fine image detail in the finished comparison clip, the format saved matters to me, not just a 4K signal at the input or on the monitor. Around 20% of consumers prioritise the recording format.
Space and connections Check which USB connection you need, which HDMI cables you have and what’s included with the specific version. An internal PCIe card requires a compatible slot in a desktop PC. If desk space is limited, I want to know in advance whether an external box and its cables will fit, or whether I have a suitable desktop PC for an internal card. Around 13% of consumers prioritise space and connectivity.
Game audio and commentary Make a short test recording with the picture, game audio and your voice. Elgato notes that, when a Nintendo Switch is docked, connecting headphones can interrupt game audio output over HDMI. If I want game audio and commentary together in the comparison, I want to test the whole audio route before making a longer recording. Around 13% of consumers prioritise recording both audio sources together.

Avoid common buying mistakes

  • Assuming “4K” means 4K recording

    A card may pass a 4K signal through to your screen while recording in a different format. Passthrough and recording therefore tell you different things about the finished video file.

    Check the HDMI input, recording format and passthrough separately for the specific model. First decide which format your comparison video actually needs.

  • Focusing only on image resolution

    USB connection, operating system compatibility and what’s included vary by model and version. For example, Elgato says the Game Capture Neo does not come with an HDMI cable.

    Before buying, check the USB port you need, software compatibility and the contents of the exact version on offer.

    If your setup needs a particular HDMI cable that you don’t have, you may need to budget for one separately.

  • Checking picture and sound only after a long recording

    Seeing the game on screen doesn’t guarantee that game audio or commentary will be captured. When a Nintendo Switch is docked, connecting headphones can interrupt HDMI audio output. Elgato also notes that its devices cannot display or record HDCP-protected signals.

    Before comparing games, make a short test recording with the picture, game audio and your voice. Don’t assume that protected content can be recorded.

Key brands at a glance

Elgato

The external models listed cover a range of recording formats. Elgato specifies 1080p60 for the Game Capture Neo and up to 2160p60 for the 4K S.

  • According to Elgato, the HD60 X supports recording at up to 2160p30, while the 4K S supports up to 2160p60.
  • According to Elgato, HDR recording on the 4K S is currently limited to Windows. The Game Capture Neo does not include an HDMI cable.

AVerMedia

The StreamLine MINI+ GC311G2 is an external option, while the Live Gamer 4K GC573 is an internal desktop card.

  • AVerMedia lists 1080p60 recording and 4K60 passthrough for the GC311G2.
  • According to the manufacturer, the Live Gamer ULTRA 2.1 GC553G2’s 4K144 recording capability requires Streaming Center and the MJPEG format.

Hauppauge

The HD PVR 60 is an HDMI option for recordings where 1080p60 is sufficient.

  • Hauppauge lists dedicated recording software with an audio mixer for this model.
  • According to the manufacturer, recording and passthrough on the HD PVR 60 are limited to a maximum of 1080p60.

NZXT

The external Signal HD60 is described as an HDMI option for console or dual-PC setups.

  • The manual specifies a USB 3.2 Gen 1-compatible connection to the computer and an HDMI connection supplied for the setup described.
  • Before buying, check that the USB connection and cable routing will work with your computer and monitor.

Joybuy products

This selection includes external HDMI capture cards for recording gameplay. Check the recording format and passthrough separately for each model, especially when 4K is mentioned in the product details.

USB 3.0 video capture card with 4K specification

USB 3.0 video capture card, 4K, 5 ports

An external option if you want to record HDMI gameplay on your computer.

Listed in the product name: USB 3.0, 4K and 5 ports. Check the recording format of the version on offer before buying.

View at Joybuy
Video capture and recording card with 4K specification and five ports

Video capture card with 4K specification, 5 ports

An external option for recording gameplay if you want to connect an HDMI game source to your computer.

Listed in the product name: 4K and 5 ports. The stated recording resolution is 1080p/60 Hz; the 4K specification refers to the input and loop-through.

View at Joybuy
HDMI capture card with USB 3.0, 1080p recording and 4K input

HDMI capture card, 1080p60 recording, 4K30 input

An option if you want to record gameplay in 1080p60 and connect an HDMI source.

Listed in the product name: USB 3.0, 1080p60 recording, HDMI input up to 4K30, and compatibility with PC and laptop. According to the title, the input supports up to 4K30.

View at Joybuy
USB 3.0 video capture card with audio recording and 4K specification

USB 3.0 video capture card, audio recording, 5 ports

An external option for recording gameplay over HDMI.

Listed in the product name: USB 3.0, audio recording and 5 ports. Check separately which recording format and audio route are specified for your setup.

View at Joybuy
VIELLAN HDMI capture card with USB 3.0 and 1080p recording

VIELLAN 4K HDMI Video Capture Card USB 3.0

An external option if you want to record console gameplay over HDMI and pass the picture through to a display.

Listed in the product name: USB 3.0, 1080p recording, 4K HDMI passthrough, and compatibility with Windows, macOS and Linux. According to the description, performance may be limited when using a USB 2.0 connection.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How do I connect a console to record with OBS?

For a compatible, unencrypted HDMI source, connect the console to the capture card via HDMI and connect the card to the recording PC via USB. If you want to play on a separate monitor, connect it to the HDMI output of a card designed for this. In OBS, add the card as a video capture device, then check the picture and sound with a short test recording.

Why is there no sound even though I can see the game?

First, check the audio meters and selected devices in OBS. Elgato specifically notes that, when a Nintendo Switch is docked, connecting headphones to the Switch can interrupt game audio output over HDMI. This is one device-specific check to try.

Can I publish a recorded game comparison in Germany?

Making a private recording does not automatically mean you’re allowed to publish it. Section 53 of the German Copyright Act (UrhG) covers reproductions for private use under certain conditions; Section 19a deals separately with making works available to the public. Whether a particular video can be published depends, among other things, on the rights to the games, music and other content it contains, as well as the relevant permissions.

Can a capture card record any HDMI picture from a PlayStation?

No. Elgato explains that its devices cannot display or record HDCP-protected HDMI signals. A setting Elgato describes for recording gameplay does not give you permission to record protected films or streaming content.