Who might need a capture card?

Console guide with a separate monitor

If you play on a separate HDMI console and want to keep the picture on your monitor while recording, check the required pass-through mode separately from the recording resolution. OBS Project describes a capture device as one way to bring console video into OBS.

Recording at a cramped desk

With an external card between your game source, monitor and recording computer, desk space, cable routing and compatible connections all matter. For example, AVerMedia lists the Live Gamer MINI GC311 as measuring 100 × 57 × 18.8 mm and having a Micro-USB connection.

Guide with spoken commentary

If you want to record game audio and your commentary together, check the audio route with your specific console and headset setup. For the PS5 setup it describes, Elgato notes that connecting headphones to the console or controller stops game audio from being output over HDMI.

What should you look for?

Direct recording on a PC

Best if: Your game and recording software run on the same PC, and you don’t need to connect a separate HDMI source.

Keep in mind: You’ll need another solution to connect a separate console over HDMI. NZXT says you don’t need a capture card to play and record on the same PC.

External card for Full HD

Best if: You play on a separate HDMI console using your own monitor, and recording at up to 1080p60 is enough.

Keep in mind: According to the manufacturer, the AVerMedia Live Gamer MINI GC311 supports up to 1080p60 for pass-through and recording, but doesn’t support 4K or HDR.

Higher-resolution monitor signal

Best if: You want a higher-resolution picture on your monitor, but don’t necessarily need to record at the same resolution.

Keep in mind: Elgato lists up to 4K60 pass-through and up to 4K30 recording for the HD60 X. NZXT says the Signal HD60 can pass through a 4K signal, but can’t record it to a PC in 4K.

Recording at up to 4K60

Best if: You want the finished guide file to be available in up to 4K60, and your computer and signal chain support the mode you need.

Keep in mind: Elgato lists recording at up to 4K60 for the Game Capture 4K S. Its stated HDR recording is currently limited to up to 1080p60 and Windows.

What matters What to check before buying Who is it important to?
Keep playing on your own monitor Check the pass-through mode for the HDMI signal you want, and the recording resolution separately. AVerMedia lists a maximum of 1080p60 for the GC311; Elgato lists up to 4K60 pass-through and up to 4K30 recording for the HD60 X. If I want to keep playing on my monitor while recording, I make sure the pass-through picture is right for my screen. Around 36% of consumers put the monitor signal first.
Space and connections Check the space available, HDMI and USB cable routes, computer connection and box contents. According to AVerMedia, the GC311 measures 100 × 57 × 18.8 mm and uses Micro-USB. When space is limited, I want to fit the device and cables in without losing sight of the connections to my monitor and recording computer. Around 29% of consumers prioritise space and connections.
Game audio and commentary Test the headset and microphone setup with your specific console. Check whether there’s an analogue input and how OBS captures audio. Elgato lists a 3.5 mm stereo input on both the HD60 X and the 4K S. If I want to record game audio and my commentary together, I test the whole audio route, not just the picture. Around 21% of consumers put audio and commentary first.
Recording format Check the resolution, frame rate and, if relevant, HDR for the finished file—not just the pass-through. Elgato’s stated HDR recording for the 4K S is currently limited to up to 1080p60 on Windows. If I need a specific resolution or frame rate for my guide file, I check that exact recording mode against my computer and the rest of the signal chain. Around 14% of consumers prioritise the recording format.

Common selection mistakes

  • Assuming 4K pass-through means 4K recording

    A pass-through specification doesn’t automatically tell you the resolution of the recording file. NZXT lists 4K pass-through for the Signal HD60, but not 4K recording to a PC. Elgato also distinguishes between up to 4K60 pass-through and up to 4K30 recording for the HD60 X.

    Check the specifications for the recording resolution at the frame rate you want to use for your guide.

  • Testing only the picture and overlooking the audio route

    In the PS5 setup described by Elgato, game audio may not come through HDMI if headphones are connected to the console or controller.

    Before making a longer recording, test how your console, headset, microphone and recording software work together. Depending on your headset setup, you may need additional audio equipment.

  • Planning to use a card for direct recording on the same PC

    NZXT says you don’t need a capture card when your game and recording are running on the same PC. This setup doesn’t require extra hardware or connections.

    First, check whether you can capture the game directly in your recording software. Only consider an external card if you want to connect a separate HDMI source.

Relevant brands and product ranges

AVerMedia

The Live Gamer MINI GC311 is an example of a compact external card for setups where Full HD pass-through and recording are enough.

  • Manufacturer specifications: 100 × 57 × 18.8 mm; HDMI pass-through and recording up to 1080p60.
  • According to the manufacturer, the GC311 doesn’t support 4K, HDR or HDCP-protected signals. These specifications apply to model GC311.

Elgato

The HD60 X and Game Capture 4K S offer different specifications for monitor pass-through and recording formats.

  • Elgato lists up to 4K60 pass-through and up to 4K30 recording for the HD60 X, and recording at up to 4K60 for the Game Capture 4K S.
  • For both models, stated HDR recording is currently limited to up to 1080p60 and Windows. These are manufacturer specifications, not independent test results.

NZXT

The Signal HD60 is an external option for a higher-resolution HDMI picture on your monitor when you don’t need to record in 4K on your PC.

  • NZXT says the Signal HD60 can read and pass through a 4K signal.
  • According to NZXT, the Signal HD60 can’t record this signal in 4K on a computer and doesn’t support HDR. These specifications apply to this model.

Capture cards at Joybuy

These products are designed for external HDMI recording with monitor pass-through, and Full HD recording on some models.

USB 3.0 video capture card with 4K pass-through

USB 3.0 video capture card with 4K pass-through, 5 ports

For an external HDMI source with monitor output and Full HD recording.

USB 3.0; 4K/60Hz input and pass-through; recording at 1080p/60Hz.

View at Joybuy
USB 3.0 video capture card with audio recording and 4K pass-through

USB 3.0 video capture card with audio recording, 5 ports

For an external gaming source with monitor output and Full HD recording.

USB 3.0; 4K/60Hz input and pass-through; recording at 1080p/60Hz; audio recording.

View at Joybuy
VIELLAN HDMI capture card with microphone input and headphone output

VIELLAN HDMI capture card with microphone input and headphone output

For a recording setup where a microphone input and headphone output on the device are useful.

USB 3.0; UVC and UAC; recording up to 1080p; 4K HDMI pass-through; microphone input and headphone output.

View at Joybuy
Video capture and recording card with 4K pass-through

Video capture and recording card, 5 ports

For external HDMI recording with monitor output and Full HD recording.

USB 3.0; 4K/60Hz input and pass-through; recording at 1080p/60Hz.

View at Joybuy
VIELLAN 4K HDMI capture card with 1080p recording

VIELLAN 4K HDMI capture card with 1080p recording

For a 4K HDMI monitor signal while recording in 1080p.

USB 3.0; 4K HDMI pass-through; 1080p recording; according to the product name, compatible with Windows, macOS, Linux, PS4, Xbox and Nintendo Switch.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a capture card to make a gaming guide on my only PC?

Not for this setup alone. NZXT says you don’t need a capture card if your game and recording are running on the same PC. For a separate console, OBS Project describes a capture device as one way to bring the gameplay picture into OBS.

How do I set up a separate HDMI gaming source in OBS?

Connect the gaming source to the HDMI input on a suitable card and, if needed, connect its HDMI output to your monitor. Then connect the card to your recording computer. In OBS, add a Video Capture Device source and select the device. Before recording, check the supported resolution, frame rate and audio route.

Why is the picture or game audio missing from a PS5 recording?

Elgato says its capture devices can’t display or record HDCP-protected HDMI signals. In the PS5 setup described by Elgato, game audio may also be missing over HDMI if headphones are connected to the console or controller. Check the picture and sound with your specific setup; this does not refer to recording protected content.

Which cables and extra equipment should I check before buying?

Check the actual box contents against the HDMI and USB connections in your setup, and make sure your recording computer has the connection you need. If you use a headset, test the entire audio route; depending on your setup, you may need additional audio equipment.

Can I automatically publish a recorded gaming guide in Germany?

No. Owning a capture card doesn’t automatically give you permission to publish gameplay footage. German copyright law covers, among other things, the reproduction and making available to the public of protected works (§§ 16 and 19a UrhG). Whether you can publish a particular guide depends on the material used and the rights that apply to it. The relevant legislation is published by the Federal Ministry of Justice and the Federal Office of Justice.