Who is a capture card suitable for?

Playing on a console with a separate display

If you want to see your console gameplay on your monitor while recording it on a computer, check passthrough and recording formats separately. Elgato explains this distinction for its capture cards, too.

A guide with commentary and game audio

If you’re explaining your moves as you play, your voice and the game audio should both be clear in the recording. Check the audio connections and OBS settings. OBS Project also supports multiple audio tracks, which lets you edit them separately later.

Playing a PC game on your recording computer

If the game is running on the same Windows PC, try the OBS ‘Game Capture’ source before buying additional capture hardware. The OBS Project recommends this method for capturing PC games directly.

What should you look for when buying?

For a narrated strategy guide, first decide on your signal path, audio setup and preferred recording format. Then check that the connections and any extra components are right for your needs.

Buying criterion What to check Who it matters most to
Gameplay on your monitor Compare the HDMI inputs and outputs, supported resolution and frame rate, and any HDR or VRR support with the display mode you use. If I want to play on my separate gaming monitor while recording, its display mode needs to work with passthrough. Around 30% of consumers put seeing the game on their monitor first.
Voice and game audio Check the audio connections and console audio output, then listen back to a short OBS test recording. If you plan to edit later, check the audio tracks and recording format, too. When explaining my moves in a guide, I want to be able to balance the commentary and game audio clearly. For around 30% of consumers, recording voice and game audio is the main priority.
Recording details Check the stated recording resolution and frame rate, and make sure the specific mode works with the software you use. If menus or small text need to be legible in the finished guide, I’ll check the actual recording format rather than just the display signal. Around 20% of consumers put recording detail first.
Source and computer Choose your game source and recording software, then check your operating system, the USB mode required or the available PCIe slot for the specific model. If I want to connect a console, capture card and recording computer, all the connections and software need to work together. Compatibility is the main consideration for around 10% of consumers.
Setup and contents Check the HDMI connections you need, the cables you already have, your computer’s ports and what’s included with the specific model. If I want to keep my setup in a separate room as tidy as possible, I’ll want to know in advance which connections and cables I need. Around 10% of consumers prioritise the setup and any extra components they’ll need.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming 4K passthrough means 4K recording

    Passthrough describes the signal sent through to your gaming display; the recording may have a different resolution or frame rate. For the Game Capture Neo, Elgato specifies passthrough of up to 2160p60, but recording of up to 1080p60.

    Check the passthrough specifications for your display and the recording specifications separately for your finished guide.

  • Assuming a USB-C connector provides the USB data mode you need

    Recording modes for the ASUS TUF Gaming Capture Box-CU4K30 vary depending on the connection: ASUS specifies up to 2160p30 via USB 3.2 Gen 1 and up to 720p30 via USB 2.0.

    Check which USB mode your recording computer actually supports, not just the shape of the connector.

  • Assuming that capturing video means all your audio is recorded too

    A capture card that captures HDMI video won’t automatically set up your microphone, game audio or party chat. Headset and controller connections vary by model.

    Before making a longer recording, test the game audio, commentary and, if relevant, party chat in the software you plan to use.

  • Leaving the contents and signal path until after you buy

    The cables included vary by model. Elgato doesn’t list an HDMI cable in the box with the Game Capture Neo, while an HDMI cable is included with the 4K S.

    Plan the connections between your console, capture card and display, then check them against what’s included with the specific model.

Key brands at a glance

Elgato

Options include external Full HD recording, higher external recording modes and fixed desktop installations.

  • Elgato specifies recording of up to 1080p60 for the Game Capture Neo and up to 2160p60 for the 4K S. These figures apply to the models stated.
  • The 4K Pro is an internal card. According to Elgato, an HDMI cable isn’t included with the Game Capture Neo.

AVerMedia

The Live Gamer ULTRA 2.1 GC553G2 is an external HDMI 2.1 option for demanding display modes and audio setups.

  • AVerMedia specifies recording at up to 4K144 in MJPEG format with Streaming Center on Windows, and 4K60 with OBS on macOS. Passthrough is specified at up to 4K144.
  • Recording specifications depend on the software and operating system; the same mode isn’t automatically available in every programme.

ASUS

The TUF Gaming Capture Box-CU4K30 is an external option with connections for a headset and gamepad.

  • ASUS specifies recording at up to 2160p30 via USB 3.2 Gen 1, along with audio inputs for a headset and gamepad.
  • ASUS specifies up to 720p30 via USB 2.0. According to the manufacturer, HDCP-protected signals aren’t supported.

NZXT

The Signal HD is an external HDMI option for recording from a console or a second PC.

  • The NZXT manual describes an HDMI input for the source and an optional HDMI output to a gaming monitor.
  • Before buying, check the recording mode and whether your computer is suitable for this particular model variant.

Suitable products at Joybuy

These external HDMI capture cards are designed for recording console gameplay with passthrough and creating a Full HD guide. Check that their stated connections and audio features suit your setup.

VIELLAN 4K HDMI video capture card

VIELLAN 4K HDMI Video Capture Card

For a console guide with passthrough and Full HD recording; a microphone input and headphone output are specified.

4K HDMI passthrough; recording up to 1080p; USB 3.0; 48 kHz PCM audio. Compatibility is listed for Windows, macOS and Linux.

View at Joybuy
4K HDMI capture card, USB 3.0, black

4K HDMI Capture Card, USB 3.0, Black

For a guide with passthrough and Full HD recording; a microphone input and headphone output are specified.

HDMI input up to 4K at 30 Hz; recording at 1080p and 60 Hz; USB 3.0. Compatibility is listed for PC and Mac.

View at Joybuy
4K USB 3.0 video capture card

4K USB 3.0 Video Capture Card

For recording gameplay with passthrough; the specified recording resolution is 1080p at 60 Hz.

4K input and passthrough at 60 Hz; USB 3.0. Compatibility is listed for Windows, macOS and Linux.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a capture card for a PC game guide?

Not necessarily. If the game is running on the same Windows computer you’re recording on, the OBS Project recommends trying the direct ‘Game Capture’ source first. For the HDMI signal from an external console, OBS describes a capture device as the signal path.

How can I record commentary and game audio clearly?

Set up your capture device and microphone as suitable OBS sources, then listen back to a short test recording. If you want to edit the voice and game audio separately later, the OBS recording guide supports multiple audio tracks and recommends MKV, with the option to remux to MP4 later.

What rights do I need to publish a strategy guide?

A capture card’s recording function doesn’t grant you the right to publish your content. § 19a UrhG concerns making protected works available to the public. For the game in question, its music and any other third-party material, check the applicable usage rights or publisher rules.

What applies if a product develops a fault after purchase in Germany?

For new goods bought from a retailer, you generally have statutory consumer rights against the seller; Verbraucherzentrale distinguishes these from a voluntary guarantee. It states that the statutory warranty period is generally two years from delivery. The remedy available depends on the specific purchase and fault.

Why is the picture black when recording from a PS5?

For its supported PS5 capture devices, Elgato explains that an HDCP-protected HDMI signal can’t be recorded. For gameplay, the manufacturer says to disable ‘Enable HDCP’ in the PS5 system settings before connecting the device. This doesn’t give you permission to record protected films or streaming content.