Which solution is right for you?

Console speedrunners using a gaming monitor

If you want to show your console gameplay while playing on your own screen, check the HDMI signal path, passthrough and recording format separately. Elgato documents these signal paths for its capture cards.

Speedrunners with an older console

First, check the console’s actual video output: component video is not the same as HDMI capture. Hauppauge documents a component video input for the HD PVR 2 Gaming Edition.

Speedrunners without a recording PC in the room

If you want to save your run locally without leaving a computer running to record it, you’ll need a specifically supported stand-alone mode. Hauppauge lists this mode for the HD PVR Pro 60.

Which buying criteria matter?

First, work out whether the game is running on your recording PC or coming from an external device. Then consider the display and recording modes you need, and how you want to monitor game audio and commentary.

What you need What to look for when buying Who is this especially important for?
Capture the game source Check whether the game is running on the recording PC or another device is outputting the picture. For an external source, check that its output, the card’s input and the PC connection are compatible. If the game is running on the same PC, I want to know whether OBS already covers recording before connecting extra hardware unnecessarily. This is the main concern for around 33% of consumers.
Play on your own screen Check that passthrough supports the resolution and frame rate you use, then compare it separately with the recording format. If I want to play on my own monitor during a run, the card needs to preserve the display mode I want. Suitable monitor passthrough is the top concern for around 27% of consumers.
Record game audio and commentary Check how game audio, your microphone and, if applicable, your headset connect, and how to set them up as audio sources in the software. For a presentation with game audio and spoken commentary, I want to control both sources and test them before the run. This is the top concern for around 20% of consumers.
Connect an older console Check the exact video output, the device’s input and the supported recording frame rate. If my older console outputs component video rather than a compatible HDMI signal, I need a signal path that supports it. Connecting older sources is the top priority for around 13% of consumers.
Record without a PC running Look for a specifically stated stand-alone mode, then check the supported memory card, power supply and recording format. If I want to save my run without leaving my recording computer switched on, a stand-alone recording function is essential. This is the main concern for around 7% of consumers.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming “4K60” means 4K60 recording

    Passthrough and the recording file may use different formats. AVerMedia lists 4K60 passthrough but 1080p60 recording for the StreamLine MINI+ GC311G2. ASUS also gives separate figures for the CU4K30.

    Compare the input, passthrough to your screen and recording against the resolution and frame rate you actually need.

  • Checking only the shape of the USB connector

    The connection standard and operating mode can determine the recording limit. ASUS lists different recording formats for the CU4K30 depending on the USB connection; Elgato specifies USB 3.2 Gen 2 for the 4K X.

    Check the requirements of the exact model against the ports on your recording computer.

  • Relying only on the software preview during a time-critical run

    On cards with an HDMI output, the picture passed through to your gaming monitor follows a different signal path from the preview on your recording computer. You can’t infer a universal latency figure from this.

    If you play on a separate monitor, check the mode you want using passthrough and test the complete setup before your presentation.

  • Assuming any capture card can record without a PC

    Recording without a computer running is a specific feature; it isn’t automatically available just because you connect a capture card.

    Check the exact model for stand-alone mode, supported storage and power requirements. For stand-alone use of the HD PVR Pro 60, Hauppauge specifies an SD card and a USB power supply rated at 5 V and 1 A, which is not included.

Relevant brands and documented models

Elgato

The documented 4K S and 4K X models offer different HDMI and recording formats for consoles or a second PC.

  • Elgato specifies HDMI 2.0 and recording up to 2160p60 for the 4K S; the 4K X is listed with HDMI 2.1 and USB 3.2 Gen 2.
  • According to the specifications consulted, HDR recording is limited to Windows. These details apply to these models and are not an independent performance comparison.

AVerMedia

The StreamLine MINI+ GC311G2 is documented for an HDMI signal that can pass through a higher-resolution game picture than the recording file.

  • AVerMedia lists 4K60 HDR passthrough and 1080p60 recording for this model.
  • For this model, the passthrough specification does not mean that it records in 4K.

ASUS

The TUF Gaming Capture Box-CU4K30 is an external HDMI option with documented headset and gamepad audio connections.

  • ASUS lists 4K60 passthrough for the CU4K30.
  • ASUS specifies maximum recording of 2160p30 over USB 3.2 Gen 1 and 720p30 over USB 2.0.

Hauppauge

The HD PVR 2 Gaming Edition and HD PVR Pro 60 cater for different special cases: component video, and recording to an SD card without a PC running.

  • Hauppauge documents a component video input for the HD PVR 2 and a stand-alone mode for the HD PVR Pro 60.
  • The models are not interchangeable. Hauppauge specifies that an additional power supply is needed for the Pro 60’s stand-alone mode.

NZXT

According to the manufacturer’s manual, the Signal HD60 is an external HDMI capture card with an optional HDMI output to your gaming monitor.

  • The manual describes passthrough via the HDMI output.
  • For connecting to a computer, the manual specifies a compatible USB 3.2 Gen 1 port; this does not provide a general latency comparison.

Capture cards for HDMI consoles

This Joybuy selection includes HDMI capture cards with passthrough to a screen and Full HD recording. Check that the modes listed suit your console, monitor and recording computer.

HDMI capture card with 4K60 passthrough and 1080p60 recording

HDMI capture card with 4K60 passthrough and 1080p60 recording

For an HDMI games console, when you want to pass the picture through to your screen and record in Full HD.

Specifications list 4K60 input and loop-through, along with 1080p60 recording. The description mentions games consoles and Windows, macOS and Linux.

View at Joybuy
4K HDMI capture card with 4K30 input and 1080p60 recording

4K HDMI capture card with 4K30 input and 1080p60 recording

For a setup with an HDMI game source and a separate screen, if 1080p60 is sufficient for your recording.

The title specifies HDMI input up to 4K30 and recording at 1080p60. The description mentions passthrough to a second screen, as well as a microphone input and headphone output.

View at Joybuy
USB 3.0 video capture card with 4K60 passthrough and 1080p60 recording

USB 3.0 video capture card with 4K60 passthrough

For console gaming when you want to pass the game picture through to a monitor and save the recording in Full HD.

Specifications list 4K60 input and passthrough, along with 1080p60 recording. The description mentions Windows, macOS and Linux.

View at Joybuy
VIELLAN 4K HDMI video capture card USB 3.0 with 1080p recording

VIELLAN 4K HDMI Video Capture Card USB 3.0

For an HDMI game source and a separate gaming monitor, if recording at up to 1080p is sufficient.

The title specifies USB 3.0 and 1080p recording; 4K is listed for HDMI passthrough. The description mentions consoles and Windows, Mac and Linux.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a capture card if the game is running on my recording PC?

Not necessarily: OBS Studio describes a game capture source for games running on your computer. Try this first. For footage from an external console, OBS Studio instead describes using a video capture device or another suitable connection method.

How do I connect an HDMI console, capture card and gaming monitor?

For a model with passthrough, connect the console to the HDMI input, the card’s HDMI output to the monitor, and the card to the recording computer via USB. Add the device there as a video capture source, and check the connections and cables for your specific model. Elgato describes this setup for the 4K X.

What should I check if the picture or sound is missing during my presentation?

First, check that the input signal is supported and that the audio sources are set up correctly in the software. Elgato explains that connecting a PS5 to the 4K X may produce a black screen if HDCP is enabled. Then check the audio sources and levels in OBS using a test recording.

What extra requirements might there be, and what applies to online purchases in Germany?

Depending on your setup, you may need extra cables, a storage device or a power supply. For stand-alone mode on the HD PVR Pro 60, Hauppauge specifically lists a USB power supply rated at 5 V and 1 A, which is not included. According to the Verbraucherzentrale, online purchases generally come with a 14-day right to cancel. The statutory guarantee against the seller is separate from a voluntary warranty.

Does buying a capture card automatically give me permission to stream any game and music publicly?

No. Buying the device does not automatically give you permission to use other people’s content. The Copyright Act covers exploitation rights such as public performance. According to the Federal Ministry of Justice and the Federal Office of Justice, this does not give a blanket answer as to whether permission or an exception applies to a particular game, piece of music or type of presentation. Check that you have the rights to use the content as you intend.