Who is a capture card useful for?

Guide creators in a shared room

If you want to record game audio and commentary clearly and edit them separately later, check the audio routing and recording tracks. OBS Project explains how to use separate tracks for different audio sources. It also notes that noise suppression is not very effective when there is a lot of background noise.

Console players with a recording PC

If you want to record a console’s HDMI output on your computer while continuing to play on a screen, check the audio routing and the separate recording and passthrough specifications. Elgato and NZXT describe different recording and passthrough modes for their respective models.

Creators with demanding video requirements

If you want to use a specific resolution, frame rate or HDR, check the specifications for the exact model against your source, screen, operating system and software. Manufacturers’ recording mode specifications apply only to the model and conditions stated.

What should you look for?

Recording directly on your gaming PC

A good fit if: You play and record on the same PC, without recording the HDMI output from a separate source.

The trade-off: You save yourself an extra device, but this won’t automatically capture the HDMI output from a separate console.

External card for 1080p60 recording

A good fit if: You’re recording a console or a second PC, and 1080p60 is enough for your guide.

The trade-off: Recording and passthrough are separate functions, so check both specifications for the exact model.

Card with higher video modes

A good fit if: You need a particular higher recording resolution or frame rate, or an analogue audio connection.

The trade-off: Some modes may depend on your operating system, software or format. Elgato and AVerMedia specify such conditions for their respective models.

Make your buying decision based on what matters most when recording a strategy guide in a shared bedroom.

Priority What to check before buying Who is it important to?
Commentary and game audio Microphone and headphone connections, and whether you can assign audio sources to separate tracks. If I want to edit commentary and game audio separately, I’ll check the audio routing first. Around 36% of consumers prioritise separating audio.
Connecting a console HDMI input and output, supported passthrough modes, and the separately stated recording resolution. If I want to connect a console and keep playing on screen, I’ll check the HDMI setup and passthrough. Around 29% of consumers say console connectivity is their main priority.
Resolution, frame rate and HDR Check recording and passthrough separately against the modes supported by your source, screen, operating system and software. If I need a specific resolution, frame rate or HDR for recording, I’ll check that combination carefully. Around 21% of consumers prioritise video modes.
Minimal extra hardware Before buying, check whether you’ll play and record on the same PC or connect a separate HDMI source. If I play and record on the same PC and don’t want to set up another device, I’ll check software recording first. Around 14% of consumers prioritise keeping extra hardware to a minimum.

Buying and recording pitfalls

  • Confusing 4K passthrough with 4K recording

    Elgato specifies recording at up to 1080p60 and passthrough at up to 4K60 for Game Capture Neo. NZXT likewise explains that Signal HD60 can pass through a 4K signal, but cannot record in 4K.

    Compare the recording resolution separately from the passthrough specification to make sure it matches the format you want for your guide.

    If your recording really needs to be in 4K, you may need an additional device that supports the right recording mode.

  • Assuming a headset covers all your audio needs

    With some console and headset setups, not all audio may be output over HDMI. Elgato Game Capture Neo also has no analogue audio input, according to the manufacturer.

    Before recording a longer guide, make a short test recording with game audio and commentary, then check both tracks. Also check where to connect your microphone and headphones.

    Depending on your audio setup, you may need a separate microphone or additional audio cables.

  • Relying on noise suppression to block conversations

    OBS Project notes that its noise suppression is not very effective with loud background noise. In a shared room, recording other people’s private conversations without their permission may also raise legal issues.

    Set up your recording so that other people’s conversations aren’t captured without their permission, rather than relying on filters afterwards. Section 201 of the German Criminal Code (StGB) covers the unauthorised recording of another person’s privately spoken words. The cited source is the Federal Ministry of Justice and the Federal Office of Justice.

Key brands at a glance

Elgato

Game Capture Neo and Game Capture 4K S offer different recording options and audio connections.

  • Elgato specifies recording at up to 1080p60 and passthrough at up to 4K60 for Game Capture Neo. Game Capture 4K S is specified for recording at up to 2160p60 and has an analogue 3.5 mm stereo input.
  • According to Elgato, Game Capture Neo has no analogue audio input. HDR recording with Game Capture 4K S is currently limited to Windows, according to the manufacturer.

AVerMedia

The Live Gamer ULTRA 2.1 GC553G2 is worth considering for setups that need specific high passthrough or recording modes.

  • AVerMedia specifies recording at up to 4K144 with Streaming Center on Windows in MJPEG format for the GC553G2.
  • The recording modes and passthrough specifications listed apply to the GC553G2. Some recording features depend on the software, format or operating system.

NZXT

Signal HD60 is an external option if you want to pass through a 4K game signal but don’t need to record in 4K.

  • NZXT says that Signal HD60 can read and pass through a 4K signal.
  • According to NZXT, Signal HD60 can’t record this signal in 4K on a PC. HDR is not supported on this model.

Joybuy products for HDMI recording

These product options are external HDMI capture cards for recording from consoles or PCs. They’re relevant if you need 1080p recording and, depending on the model, HDMI passthrough.

4K HDMI capture card with USB 3.0, 1080p60 recording, black and red

4K HDMI capture card, USB 3.0, 1080p60 recording, black and red

An option for HDMI recording if 1080p60 is enough for your guide.

The product title lists an HDMI input of up to 4K 30 Hz and recording at 1080p60. The description also mentions HDMI passthrough and a microphone input.

View at Joybuy
4K USB 3.0 video capture card with 1080p60 recording

4K USB 3.0 video capture card, 1080p60 recording

For recording console gameplay if 1080p60 is enough and you want to pass through a 4K game image.

The description lists 4K60 video input and passthrough, as well as 1080p60 recording. It names games consoles among the possible sources.

View at Joybuy
VIELLAN 4K HDMI video capture card with 1080p recording

VIELLAN 4K HDMI video capture card, 1080p recording

An option for recording HDMI gameplay if 1080p recording and 4K passthrough suit your setup.

The title and description list 1080p recording and 4K HDMI passthrough. The description also mentions a microphone input and headphone output.

View at Joybuy
VIELLAN HDMI video capture card with USB 3.0, 1080p recording and 4K passthrough

VIELLAN HDMI video capture card, USB 3.0, 1080p recording

For a strategy guide, if the stated recording resolution and audio connection suit your planned setup.

The product title lists recording at up to 1080p, 4K HDMI passthrough, UVC and UAC, as well as a microphone input and headphone output.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a capture card if I play and record my strategy guide on the same PC?

Not necessarily. If you play and record on the same PC, you can try software recording first. Connecting a separate console or second PC is a different setup.

Why does my console audio disappear when I connect a headset?

Some console and headset setups don’t output all audio over HDMI. Check the console’s audio output and the cable connections. Elgato notes that Game Capture Neo has no analogue input.

How can I edit commentary and game audio separately later?

In OBS, you can assign different audio sources to separate recording tracks. OBS Project recommends using a format that supports multiple audio tracks; standard video players often play only one track.

Will a noise filter reliably remove other people’s conversations in the room?

You shouldn’t rely on it to do that. OBS Project says its noise suppression is not very effective with loud background noise. A noise gate mainly suppresses audio while you’re not speaking.

What should I bear in mind in Germany if other people can be heard or seen in the room?

Section 201 of the German Criminal Code (StGB) covers the unauthorised recording of another person’s privately spoken words. If you record images inside a home, the highly personal sphere of life may also be affected in circumstances covered by section 201a of the StGB. Don’t record other people without their permission. Before publishing, also check whether you’re allowed to make the game content you’ve used publicly available. The cited source for these provisions is the Federal Ministry of Justice and the Federal Office of Justice.