Who should consider a capture card?

Console players with a dedicated monitor

If you want to keep playing on your gaming monitor while recording a guide, the HDMI input, monitor output and picture mode you want must all be compatible. Elgato and AVerMedia list the supported recording and passthrough modes for their models separately.

Guide creators who want a sharp picture

If on-screen text and maps need to stay readable in a particular format, check the recording resolution and frame rate separately from the monitor signal. Elgato and AVerMedia also specify requirements for certain HDR and high-resolution modes, including the operating system and recording software.

Creators explaining gameplay with multiple sources

If you’re combining gameplay, spoken instructions or a second HDMI video source, plan your video and audio routes before you buy. The OBS Project describes video capture sources for external devices, while AVerMedia lists two HDMI inputs on its internal GC570D.

What should you look for when choosing one?

First, check whether OBS can capture your PC game directly. If you’re using a console or a second PC, recording format and passthrough are the next key things to consider.

Buying priority What to check Who is it most important to?
Playing on a monitor Check the HDMI input and output, along with the supported passthrough resolution and frame rate for the exact model. If I want to keep playing on my gaming monitor while recording, it needs to retain its picture mode. That’s why around 29% of consumers put monitor signal compatibility first.
Recording format Check the recording resolution and frame rate; also check HDR and any operating system and software requirements separately. To keep maps and on-screen text readable, I need the format I want in the saved file, not just in the input signal. Around 23% of consumers would prioritise the quality of the file.
Commentary and game audio Make sure the HDMI audio, microphone connection and any additional audio inputs work with your recording software. When I’m talking through a guide, I want to record my explanation along with the game audio, so I plan the audio routes in advance. For around 18% of consumers, audio routing comes first.
Two HDMI video sources Check the number and version of the inputs and, for an internal card, make sure you have a suitable PCIe slot. If I want to include gameplay and a second HDMI source at the same time, I need a suitable signal route. Around 12% of consumers would consider multi-source recording first.
Do you really need a capture card? Before looking for a product, check whether OBS can already capture the game directly on the same PC. If my game and recording are both on my PC, I want to test whether OBS will do the job without an extra HDMI device. Around 18% of consumers would first check whether they need additional hardware.

Avoid common buying mistakes

  • Assuming “4K” in the title means it records 4K files

    The input, passthrough to the monitor and recording on the PC are three different specifications. A device may pass through a 4K signal but still only record a Full HD file.

    Check all three signal routes for the exact model and choose based on the resolution you need for your finished guide.

  • Assuming similar model names mean the same specifications

    According to AVerMedia, the GC311’s passthrough is limited to 1080p60, while the GC311G2 supports 4K60 passthrough and records at 1080p60.

    Check the exact model number and the monitor frame rate you want against the manufacturer’s specifications. Don’t assume one model has the same features as another just because their names are similar.

  • Leaving audio, accessories and the recording PC until after you’ve chosen a card

    For the Hauppauge HD PVR Pro 60, the manufacturer specifies a suitable SD card and an additional 5 V/1 A USB power supply for stand-alone use; the power supply is not included.

    Map out your video and audio routes, then check the connections, software requirements and what’s included before you buy. Allow time for a short test recording.

    Depending on how you record, you may need an SD card, a power supply or extra cables. Check what you already have in your setup.

Key brands at a glance

Elgato

External HDMI models for different recording formats, including the HD60 X and Game Capture 4K S.

  • Elgato specifies recording at up to 2160p60 for the 4K S and up to 2160p30 for the HD60 X.
  • Check passthrough and recording separately. According to Elgato, HDR recording on the models mentioned is currently only available on Windows.

AVerMedia

The range spans Full HD cards and the internal GC570D, which has two HDMI inputs.

  • According to AVerMedia, the GC311 records at 1080p60 and is also limited to 1080p60 passthrough. The GC311G2 records at 1080p60 and, according to the manufacturer, passes through 4K60.
  • The GC553G2’s advertised 4K144 recording requires Windows, Streaming Center and MJPEG. The GC570D requires a PCIe x4 Gen 2 slot.

Hauppauge

According to Hauppauge, the HD PVR Pro 60 supports USB recording on a PC and stand-alone recording to an SD card.

  • Stand-alone mode lets you record to an SD card without running a recording PC.
  • According to the German manufacturer’s website, a 4K input is downscaled to 1080p60 for recording. Stand-alone mode also requires a 5 V/1 A USB power supply, which is not included.

NZXT

The Signal HD60 is an external option if Full HD recording is enough and you want to pass a 4K signal through to your monitor.

  • NZXT says the Signal HD60 can process and pass through a 4K signal.
  • According to NZXT, recording on a PC isn’t in 4K. The manufacturer also says HDR is not a feature of the Signal HD60.

Joybuy products for Full HD recording

The Joybuy products below are HDMI capture cards for recording from a console or second PC when a Full HD file is all you need. Check the recording format and passthrough separately for each model.

4K USB 3.0 video capture card with 5 ports

4K USB 3.0 video capture card, 5 ports

For recording from a console or second PC when a Full HD file is enough and you want to pass the signal through to your monitor.

Recording: 1080p/60; input and passthrough: 4K/60; connection: USB 3.0.

The 4K input and passthrough specification does not mean it records 4K files.

Joybuy
4K video capture card with 5 ports

4K video capture card, 5 ports

For recording from a console or second PC when 1080p60 is enough for your finished file.

Recording: 1080p/60; input and passthrough: 4K/60; recording over USB 3.0.

4K60 passthrough is not the same as 4K recording.

Joybuy
4K HDMI capture card with USB 3.0

4K HDMI capture card, USB 3.0

For gaming recordings when a 1080p60 file is enough and a microphone input suits your planned audio setup.

Input: up to 4K/30 Hz; recording: 1080p/60; connection: USB 3.0.

The specified 4K input is limited to 30 Hz; recording is not in 4K.

Joybuy
4K USB 3.0 video capture card with 5 ports

4K USB 3.0 video capture card, 5 ports

For recording gameplay from a console or second PC when 1080p60 is enough for your finished guide.

Recording: 1080p/60; input and passthrough: 4K/60; USB 3.0.

Windows, macOS and Linux are listed as supported systems. Passing through a 4K signal does not produce a 4K file.

Joybuy
VIELLAN 4K HDMI video capture card with USB 3.0

VIELLAN 4K HDMI video capture card, USB 3.0

For recording gameplay when a 1080p file is enough and you need 4K passthrough to your monitor.

Recording: 1080p; 4K HDMI passthrough; USB 3.0. Windows, macOS and Linux, as well as OBS, are listed as compatible.

The specified recording resolution is 1080p, not 4K.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How do I connect a console if I want to play on my monitor while recording?

With a capture card that supports passthrough, connect the console signal to the HDMI input, the HDMI output to your monitor, and the card to your recording PC. Add a Video Capture Device source in OBS, then check the picture and sound with a short test recording.

Why is the PS5 picture black when I use a capture card?

For Elgato devices, the manufacturer says that HDCP being enabled may be the cause. To record gameplay, first try connecting the console directly to the display and checking the HDCP setting. This does not make copy-protected films or streaming content available for unrestricted recording.

How can I protect a long guide recording from becoming unusable?

The OBS Project recommends MKV because an unexpected interruption should not corrupt the entire recording. You can then convert the file to MP4 without recording it again. Before a long session, check your storage location and audio tracks, and make a short test recording.

Can I publish recorded gameplay in a strategy guide?

Not simply because a capture card lets you record it. Germany’s Copyright Act covers reproduction and making works publicly available. Whether you can publish a particular guide depends, among other things, on the rights and terms of use for the game, music and other material. It does not provide blanket permission to use any game.

What are your rights in Germany if your capture card is faulty after purchase?

If goods are faulty, you may have statutory consumer rights against the seller; a guarantee is separate and voluntary. The Verbraucherzentrale says that purchased goods are generally covered by a two-year statutory warranty period. The circumstances of each case and the applicable conditions will determine what applies.