Which option is right for you?

Console streamers short on space

If you want to see your HDMI game feed on your own monitor while streaming through a computer, an external card is one way to do it without installing anything inside your PC. Check the connection type, cables and passthrough support for your gaming monitor.

Players with demanding monitors

If your gaming monitor needs a particular resolution, frame rate or HDR playback, check passthrough separately from capture quality. The supported signal modes vary by model.

Hosts using multiple audio sources

If you’re hosting the session, plan for game audio, your microphone and, if needed, party chat. Check how the audio sources are added in OBS so that the same source isn’t accidentally captured twice.

What should you consider when choosing?

External HDMI-to-USB capture card

Best suited if: you want to connect an HDMI console or a second PC to a streaming computer without installing anything internally.

Trade-off: the device and HDMI/USB cables take up space; the USB connection, passthrough and capture capabilities must all suit the specific model.

Internal PCIe capture card

Best suited if: you have a desktop PC with a compatible spare slot and would rather keep the connections inside the computer.

Trade-off: this isn’t a standard USB connection for a laptop; the AVerMedia GC573 requires PCI-Express Gen 2 x4.

No additional capture card

Best suited if: your game and OBS run on the same capable Windows PC, and OBS Game Capture is enough for your stream.

Trade-off: this option doesn’t provide an HDMI input for an external console; test the picture and sound in a recording before you go live.

For a charity stream at a small desk, the most important consideration for consumers will vary depending on the capture setup they choose.

Priority What to check before buying Who is it important to?
Connections and space Check for a suitable HDMI and USB connection or PCIe slot, as well as the cable routing you’ll need. If my desk is small, I want to connect my source, capture card, computer and monitor without an unnecessarily complicated cable run. Around 33% of consumers say connections and space are their top priority.
Game picture on the monitor Check supported passthrough resolution and frame rate as a combination; only factor in HDR or VRR if you actually need them. If I want to play using my required monitor mode while streaming, I compare passthrough independently of capture. Around 27% of consumers put the monitor signal first.
Game and voice audio Plan for game audio, your microphone and, if needed, party chat, then check the mix in an OBS test recording. If I’m hosting the session, my voice and the game or chat audio I need should come through on the stream without any source being captured twice. Around 20% of consumers give audio routing top priority.
Capture picture quality Compare capture resolution and frame rate separately from the HDMI input and passthrough; check the operating system and software requirements for HDR. If the captured picture is crucial for my stream or recording, I check the actual capture mode rather than relying on a 4K claim. Around 20% of consumers say capture quality is their main concern.

Avoid common misconceptions

  • “4K” doesn’t automatically mean 4K capture

    The Elgato Game Capture Neo offers 4K60 passthrough but captures at up to 1080p60. The monitor signal and the picture sent to your stream or recording follow separate signal paths.

    Check the specific model’s capture and passthrough specifications separately.

  • The GC311 and GC311G2 are the same model

    According to the manufacturer, the AVerMedia GC311 is limited to 1080p60 passthrough. The GC311G2 is a different model and supports 4K60 passthrough, according to the manufacturer.

    Check the full model number and the monitor mode you need before buying.

  • A picture test is all you need for a working stream

    OBS handles video and audio sources separately. If the same audio source is captured in multiple places, you may hear an echo.

    Test game audio, commentary and, if needed, party chat together in a short recording. Depending on your party chat setup, you may need additional audio components.

  • An internal PCIe card fits a standard USB port

    According to the manufacturer, the AVerMedia GC573 requires PCI-Express Gen 2 x4, so it isn’t designed for a standard laptop USB setup.

    Before choosing, check that your streaming computer has a suitable spare slot. If not, an external option is likely to be a better fit.

Key brands at a glance

Elgato

The Game Capture Neo and Game Capture 4K S differ in the capture and passthrough modes they offer, according to the manufacturer.

  • Elgato says the Game Capture Neo captures at up to 1080p60 and passes through up to 2160p60. For the Game Capture 4K S, the manufacturer lists capture at up to 2160p60.
  • According to Elgato, HDR capture on the Game Capture 4K S is currently limited to Windows and a maximum of 1080p60. Elgato Germany says the HD60 X is no longer available.

AVerMedia

The range includes external USB models and the internal PCIe GC573; connection and signal requirements vary by model.

  • According to AVerMedia, the GC311 supports 1080p60 passthrough and capture. The GC311G2 is a different model, with 4K60 passthrough and 1080p60 capture.
  • The GC573 requires PCI-Express Gen 2 x4. According to AVerMedia, the GC553G2’s higher capture modes depend on the software, format and operating system.

NZXT

The external Signal HD60 is another option for connecting an HDMI gaming computer to a separate streaming computer.

  • The NZXT manual lists 4K60 passthrough.
  • For connecting to a computer, the manual specifies a compatible USB 3.2 Gen 1 port. This doesn’t provide a basis for an independent comparison of latency or quality.

Joybuy products for external HDMI setups

This selection features external HDMI capture cards for streaming setups using one computer. For each model, compare its stated capture capabilities with the monitor signal you need.

4K video capture card with 5 ports

4K video capture card with 5 ports

Listed for an external capture setup; check in advance which capture and passthrough modes work with your monitor and stream.

The product title describes a 4K video capture card with 5 ports, but doesn’t specify any capture or passthrough combinations.

Joybuy
4K HDMI capture card with USB 3.0

4K HDMI capture card, USB 3.0

For an HDMI source connected to your streaming computer; also check that it supports the monitor connection you need.

The product title lists an HDMI input of up to 4K 30 Hz and capture at 1080p 60 Hz.

Joybuy
4K USB 3.0 video capture card with 5 ports

4K USB 3.0 video capture card with 5 ports

For an external USB setup; before choosing, compare the capture quality you need with the monitor signal.

The product title lists USB 3.0, 5 ports and audio capture, but doesn’t specify any capture or passthrough modes.

Joybuy
VIELLAN HDMI capture card with 1080p capture and 4K passthrough

VIELLAN HDMI capture card, 1080p capture, 4K passthrough

For connecting an HDMI console to an external streaming setup; check that you have the USB 3.0 connection listed in the title.

The product title lists 1080p capture and 4K HDMI passthrough. Performance may be limited over USB 2.0, according to the product information.

Joybuy
VIELLAN HDMI capture card with microphone and headphone outputs

VIELLAN HDMI capture card, 1080p capture, 4K passthrough

If you want to use the microphone and headphone connections on the capture device, check that they suit your audio setup.

The product title lists USB 3.0, UVC and UAC, as well as a microphone input and headphone output; capture is listed at 1080p, with 4K HDMI passthrough.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a capture card to play a PC game on the same computer?

Not necessarily: OBS offers Game Capture as a source on Windows. An external HDMI console, on the other hand, needs a suitable HDMI capture connection. Test the picture and sound with your chosen setup before the charity stream.

How do I connect a capture card and avoid duplicated audio?

Connect a supported HDMI signal to the card and, if needed, run a cable from its HDMI output to your monitor; connect the computer using the port specified for that model. Add the card as a video source in OBS and check your microphone and game audio in the audio mixer. OBS warns that selecting the same audio source twice can cause an echo, and recommends a short test recording.

Why might I be unable to capture a protected HDMI picture?

According to Elgato, Elgato capture devices can’t capture HDMI signals with HDCP enabled. This means protected films and content from streaming apps can’t be captured as unrestricted signals.

What should I know about music rights for a charity stream in Germany?

A capture card doesn’t give you the rights to use music. According to GEMA, a separate livestream licence is generally required for a music-streaming livestream where payment — including a contribution of any amount — is a condition of access. For streams with free access and entirely voluntary donations, GEMA says its platform agreements generally cover music use; nevertheless, check the rights for the specific music and platform.

Does a manufacturer’s warranty replace your statutory consumer rights?

No. In Germany, claims for faulty goods are statutory claims against the seller; a guarantee is a separate voluntary benefit. The Verbraucherzentrale lists repair or replacement as the first remedies available.