Which solution is right for you?

Co-op hosts with separate video sources

If you want to show gameplay and another HDMI source at the same time, you’ll need inputs that can be captured separately. A dual-input PCIe card could be suitable, provided your Windows desktop has the right slot. AVerMedia lists two HDMI inputs for the Live Gamer DUO GC570D.

Hosts sharing a single console feed

If you’re all using the same game feed, one HDMI input may be enough to capture the picture. You’ll still need to mix the game audio, your co-players’ voices and your microphone correctly in your streaming software. OBS Project warns that capturing the same audio source twice can cause an echo.

Hosts with a high-refresh-rate gaming monitor

If you want to keep a high refresh rate while gaming, assess pass-through separately from recording. Elgato lists pass-through up to 2160p144 for the 4K X; available recording modes also depend on the input signal and software you use.

What to look for when buying

First, count how many independent HDMI feeds you need. Then compare the audio routing, monitor output and connections on your streaming computer with your specific setup.

What you need What to check before buying Who should pay particular attention
Number of independent video sources Count the HDMI feeds you need and check the recording formats and connection diagram for each input. If you want gameplay and another source to appear separately in your stream, pay particular attention to the number of capturable inputs. Around 33% of consumers rank separate video sources among their most important buying considerations.
Game audio and voices Plan where party chat and your microphone will be routed, then check the mix with a test recording. If you want game audio, your co-players and your commentary microphone to be clearly audible together, check the audio sources and look for any duplication in OBS. Around 27% of consumers prioritise voices and game audio.
Monitor and recording Compare your preferred pass-through mode separately with the recording format supported by the specific model. If you want to keep a particular monitor mode while gaming, check it separately from the recording quality. Around 20% of consumers prioritise pass-through to their monitor.
Computer connection Check the operating system, PCIe slot or USB speed. If you’re using several USB sources, check how they’re distributed across controllers, too. If you want to install a card in a desktop or use several USB sources, first check the connections and available controllers on your streaming computer. Around 20% of consumers prioritise the computer connection.

Common buying and setup mistakes

  • Confusing two HDMI sockets with two inputs

    An HDMI socket may be a pass-through output rather than a second capturable input. The AVerMedia Live Gamer DUO GC570D is explicitly listed with two inputs and one pass-through output.

    Check the connection diagram and supported recording formats for each individual input.

    Depending on your setup, you may need an additional capture device or a different card.

  • Assuming the highest pass-through figure is the streaming resolution

    Pass-through and recording may support different formats. AVerMedia lists a maximum recording resolution of 1080p60 per input for the GC570D; pass-through is via Output 1.

    Compare recording and monitor output separately, and check the signal modes supported by the specific model.

  • Counting only available sockets when using two USB video sources

    Several capture devices may share the bandwidth of a USB controller. Elgato recommends using separate root hubs or host controllers when running two of the USB 3.0 devices mentioned at the same time.

    Check how your USB controllers are assigned and test both sources at the same time.

    Depending on your computer, you may need a different host controller or connection setup.

  • Expecting the HDMI feed to include everyone’s party chat automatically

    Capturing the picture and mixing the audio are separate tasks. NZXT describes audio routing in a two-PC setup as a particular setup challenge.

    Plan the signal path for game audio, chat and your microphone, then test it with a recording before you stream.

    Depending on your audio routing, you may need extra cables or audio hardware.

Brands and their relevant models

AVerMedia

The Live Gamer DUO GC570D is an internal PCIe option for separate HDMI sources; the Live Gamer 4K GC573 is a different card designed for a single gaming input.

  • AVerMedia lists two HDMI inputs for the GC570D: HDMI 2.0 and HDMI 1.4. The manufacturer specifies a maximum recording resolution of 1080p60 per input.
  • Pass-through is via Output 1. You’ll need a suitable Windows desktop with the right PCIe slot for this card.

Elgato

The external 4K S and 4K X models are both options for capturing a single HDMI game feed, but they support different pass-through modes.

  • According to Elgato, the 4K S supports HDMI 2.0 pass-through up to 2160p60; for the 4K X, the manufacturer lists HDMI 2.1 and pass-through up to 2160p144.
  • Each model has one HDMI input. According to the manufacturer, HDR recording on the 4K X is currently limited to Windows; check recording formats separately from pass-through.

NZXT

The Signal 4K30 is an external option for capturing a console or second PC feed. NZXT’s guide also covers a two-PC setup.

  • The NZXT manual specifies one HDMI input, an optional HDMI pass-through output and a USB 3.2 Gen 1 connection.
  • NZXT itself describes audio routing in a two-PC setup as a particular setup challenge. Plan your audio sources and signal path separately.

Razer

The Ripsaw X could be suitable as a camera source if you want to connect an HDMI camera to your streaming software.

  • Razer describes the Ripsaw X as a camera capture device that supports OBS.
  • Its focus on cameras doesn’t confirm that the device is suitable for passing through a game feed. Check the connections on the specific model.

Capture cards for one shared HDMI game feed

This selection is for external USB capture cards used with one shared HDMI game feed. It isn’t a substitute for a solution with several independently capturable HDMI inputs.

4K USB 3.0 capture card with 5 ports

4K USB 3.0 capture card with 5 ports

For one shared HDMI game feed if you’re looking for an external USB capture card.

According to the product description: 4K/60 Hz input and pass-through, plus 1080p/60 Hz recording.

USB 3.0 and five ports are listed.

View at Joybuy
4K HDMI capture card with microphone input

4K HDMI capture card with microphone input

For capturing one shared game feed if you want to use a separate microphone input.

According to the product description: HDMI input up to 4K 30 Hz and recording at 1080p 60 Hz.

USB 3.0, HDMI pass-through, a microphone input and a headphone output are listed; compatibility with PCs and laptops is also stated.

View at Joybuy
4K USB 3.0 capture card with audio recording and 5 ports

4K USB 3.0 capture card with audio recording and 5 ports

For one shared HDMI game feed in a USB-based streaming setup.

According to the product description: 4K/60 Hz input and pass-through, plus 1080p/60 Hz recording.

USB 3.0, audio recording and five ports are listed.

View at Joybuy
VIELLAN 4K HDMI video capture card with microphone and headphone connections

VIELLAN 4K HDMI video capture card

For one shared HDMI game feed if a microphone input and headphone output are useful for your setup.

According to the product description: 4K HDMI input and pass-through, plus 1080p recording.

USB 3.0, a microphone connection and a headphone connection are listed.

View at Joybuy
VIELLAN HDMI video capture card with UVC/UAC and microphone input

VIELLAN HDMI video capture card with UVC/UAC

For one shared HDMI game feed if a microphone input and headphone output suit your audio setup.

According to the product description: recording up to 1080p and 4K HDMI pass-through.

USB 3.0, UVC/UAC, a microphone input and a headphone output are listed.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do I automatically need two capture cards for two players?

No, not if you’re both using the same HDMI game feed. For two independent HDMI feeds, you’ll need inputs that can be captured separately; AVerMedia lists two HDMI inputs for the Live Gamer DUO GC570D.

How can I check that game audio and voices are coming through properly in my stream?

Set up the audio sources you need in OBS, then make a test recording with the game, your co-players and your microphone before going live. OBS Project warns that capturing the same audio device globally and as an additional scene source can cause an echo; you can check levels and monitoring in the audio mixer.

Why isn’t my capture card showing a PS5 picture?

First, check the connection and supported signal. Sony explains that you can disable HDCP in the PS5 settings when using an external HDMI capture device; AVerMedia states that the GC570D cannot display, record or stream HDCP-protected signals. This doesn’t give you permission to stream protected content or someone else’s work without the necessary rights.

What happens if a product develops a fault after purchase in Germany?

According to information from the European Union, purchases from a trader are generally covered by a legal guarantee of at least two years from the date you receive the goods. This is separate from any additional manufacturer’s guarantee; if there’s a fault, the seller should be your first point of contact.

Can I simply stream my co-players and game content publicly?

Not just because a capture card can record the signal. The Rhineland-Palatinate State Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information explains the importance of consent or another legal basis when processing images in which people can be recognised. You should also check the relevant usage rights for any works you publish; what’s required depends on the content and circumstances.