Who might need a capture card for a co-op stream?

Console co-op gamers

You want to play on a separate monitor while controlling the game audio and team chat in your stream. Check passthrough and recording format separately, and plan how the voices will reach your stream. Manufacturers such as Elgato and AVerMedia offer different video modes depending on the model.

Streaming with two PCs

Your game runs on a different computer from OBS. Choose an HDMI input that suits your source and check how audio from both computers will reach OBS. OBS Project describes separate ways to capture video and audio.

Co-op streaming on one PC

Your game and stream run on the same PC. Try Game Capture and check your audio sources in OBS first; you don’t automatically need an extra HDMI capture card for this setup. OBS Project notes that Game Capture doesn’t work with every game.

What should you look for when buying a capture card?

First check whether your game and OBS run on the same PC. If you’re using an external HDMI source, consider the audio setup, monitor passthrough and recording format next.

The percentages show the most important buying priority for each respondent planning a co-op stream with an HDMI game source.

Priority What to check before buying Who it matters to most
Game and team chat audio Plan how each voice will reach OBS; check your headset, controller and chat connections, then listen back to a test recording. If I want to control game audio, microphone and team chat separately, getting the full audio setup right is my top priority. Around 29% of consumers would make game and chat audio their most important buying priority.
Monitor picture Match the resolution, frame rate and, where applicable, HDR or VRR capabilities of the card, source and monitor. If you want to keep your preferred picture mode on your monitor while gaming, pay particular attention to passthrough. Around 29% of consumers would put their monitor mode first.
Recording format Check the recording resolution and frame rate separately from passthrough. Also check HDR requirements and the USB connection. If recorded picture quality is my top priority, the recording mode actually supported is what matters. Around 24% of consumers would prioritise the recording format.
Connections and setup Compare the USB port, system requirements, HDMI connections and included cables with your setup. If you want to plan a setup that works with the connections you already have, check the port and what’s included carefully. Around 18% of consumers would make setup and connections their top priority.

Common misconceptions when buying

  • “4K” doesn’t automatically mean 4K recording

    Passthrough and recording can support different video modes. Elgato lists up to 2160p60 passthrough for the Game Capture Neo, but recording is limited to 1080p60. Hauppauge also lists these separately for the HD PVR Pro 60.

    Compare recording and monitor output as separate specifications.

  • HDMI game audio automatically includes team chat

    Chat, microphone and game audio can come from different sources. OBS Project describes separate audio sources, while AVerMedia lists an integrated party chat feature for the GC553G2. You can’t assume that other models have the same feature.

    Map the audio route from your headset and controller to OBS, then listen to a test recording with everyone speaking.

  • You can check the box contents and USB requirements after buying

    The formats you can use may depend on the USB connection. Elgato states that an HDMI cable is not included with the Game Capture Neo.

    Before ordering, check your PC port, the model’s requirements and what’s included. If you need an HDMI cable for the Game Capture Neo, make sure to buy one separately.

Brands to help you compare your options

Elgato

The Game Capture Neo, 4K S and 4K X ranges differ in recording format, passthrough and connection type. The specifications below apply to the individual models, rather than being a general assessment of the brand.

  • The Game Capture Neo supports up to 2160p60 passthrough and up to 1080p60 recording.
  • The 4K S supports recording and passthrough up to 2160p60.
  • Elgato currently lists HDR recording on the 4K S only on Windows, at up to 1080p60. The 4K X uses USB 3.2 Gen 2, so check that your PC has a suitable connection.

AVerMedia

The Live Gamer MINI GC311 is designed for Full HD passthrough, while the Live Gamer ULTRA 2.1 GC553G2 offers different video modes and a party chat feature.

  • AVerMedia describes the GC553G2 as having an integrated chat feature.
  • According to the manufacturer, some of the GC553G2’s advertised recording features depend on Streaming Center and Windows. These specifications don’t automatically apply to the GC311.

Hauppauge

According to the manufacturer, the HD PVR Pro 60 combines 4K60 passthrough with recording limited to 1080p60, as well as an integrated audio mixer.

  • The separate audio mixer may be useful when planning audio for a co-op stream.
  • On this model, 4K60 passthrough doesn’t mean 4K60 recording.

Joybuy products for HDMI game sources

The products below are external HDMI capture cards for consoles or a second PC feeding the stream, with a monitor connection. The listed variants support recording at up to 1080p; compare this with the stream format you want to use.

4K video capture card with USB 3.0 and five ports

4K video capture card, USB 3.0, 5 ports

For a separate HDMI game source connected to a monitor and streaming PC.

4K/60 Hz input and pass-through; recording up to 1080p/60 Hz. USB 3.0; listed as compatible with Windows, macOS and Linux.

View at Joybuy
4K video capture card with loop-through and five ports

4K video capture card with loop-through, 5 ports

For a setup that sends the HDMI signal to both a monitor and a recording device.

4K/60 Hz input and loop-through; recording up to 1080p/60 Hz. USB 3.0; listed as compatible with Windows, macOS and Linux.

View at Joybuy
4K HDMI capture card with USB 3.0, microphone input and headphone output

4K HDMI capture card, USB 3.0

For an HDMI game source with a separate monitor, plus microphone and headphone connections.

HDMI input up to 4K/30 Hz; recording up to 1080p/60 Hz. Microphone input and headphone output are listed.

View at Joybuy
VIELLAN 4K HDMI capture card with USB 3.0

VIELLAN 4K HDMI capture card, USB 3.0

For a console or other HDMI source with monitor passthrough and Full HD recording.

4K passthrough and 1080p recording are listed. USB 3.0, microphone input and headphone output; compatible sources include PS4, Xbox and Nintendo Switch.

View at Joybuy
VIELLAN HDMI capture card with USB 3.0, UVC and UAC

VIELLAN HDMI capture card, USB 3.0

For an HDMI game setup with passthrough and separate microphone and headphone connections.

Recording up to 1080p and 4K HDMI passthrough are listed. Supports UVC and UAC; the product title states that no driver installation is needed.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions about capture cards for co-op streams

How do I add a capture card in OBS?

Add it as a Video Capture Device and select a supported resolution and frame rate combination. OBS Project notes that an unsupported mode can result in a blank picture. Then check your audio sources separately.

What should I check with the audio before my first co-op stream?

Record and listen back to a test with game audio, your microphone and the chat channels you’ll actually use. OBS Project warns that capturing the same audio source globally and in a scene at the same time can cause an echo.

Why might my capture card show a black screen with a PlayStation 5?

On Elgato devices, HDCP may prevent capture when it’s enabled. For recording PS5 gameplay, Elgato explains how to turn it off under Settings → System → HDMI. This does not make copy-protected content available for recording.

What rights apply when buying a capture card online?

For a qualifying distance purchase from a business seller, you generally have 14 days from delivery to cancel, subject to statutory exceptions. EU consumer information also states that qualifying purchases of goods are covered by a legal guarantee of at least two years. This is separate from a voluntary manufacturer’s warranty.

Can I simply stream the voices and camera images of the people I’m playing with?

Not in every case: under certain conditions, § 201 StGB protects non-publicly spoken words from unauthorised recording, while § 22 KunstUrhG governs consent for distributing or publicly displaying images of people. Talk to everyone involved about the planned audio and video stream before you go live. The legal position depends on the circumstances.