Who might need a capture card?

Mod presenters using a single PC

If your game and recording are running on the same PC, first try Game Capture or Window Capture in OBS and check whether it captures game audio and microphone audio as you’d like. The OBS Project Sources Guide explains how to add sources in OBS; according to OBS Project, separate application audio sources are available on certain versions of Windows.

Presenters using an external game source

If your video comes from a console or a second PC, you’ll need a suitable HDMI connection to your recording PC. Whether you also need HDMI passthrough to a gameplay monitor depends on your setup; the manufacturer specifications for the AVerMedia GC311 and GC311G2 differ in this respect.

Studio presenters using a camera

For an HDMI camera, distinguish between a camera capture adapter and a gameplay capture card with monitor output. Elgato describes the Cam Link 4K as a camera adapter; check that your camera outputs a suitable, unencrypted HDMI signal.

What should you look for when buying?

First, work out whether you actually need to capture an external HDMI signal. Then compare the recording format and monitor output separately, and finally check whether an additional camera input will work with your setup.

What matters What to check before buying Who is this important to?
Do you need a capture card? Test Game Capture or Window Capture in OBS, along with game and microphone audio, in your own setup. If my modded game is running on my recording PC, I want to know before buying whether OBS can capture the video and audio directly; around 36% of consumers put direct capture first.
HDMI passthrough Check the recording resolution and passthrough resolution separately; compare the model code, source and monitor connections. If I’m using a console or a second PC, I want to record the game and see it on my monitor at a suitable resolution; around 29% of consumers prioritise monitor output for an external HDMI game source.
Recording format Check the combination of resolution, frame rate, software, operating system and host interface. If fine mod details or fast movement matter for my presentation, I look at the recording format that’s actually supported; around 21% of consumers prioritise high resolution or frame rate.
HDMI camera Check the camera output, supported formats and the signal path needed to connect it to your recording PC. For my home studio, I want to add an HDMI camera as an extra video source without mistakenly assuming it has an output for a gameplay monitor; around 14% of consumers prioritise camera connectivity.

These figures are a rough guide to the buying priorities listed above, not market shares. For specific models, always check the manufacturer’s specifications in relation to the software and operating system you’ll be using.

Common misconceptions

  • ‘4K passthrough’ means ‘4K recording’

    These are separate signal paths. AVerMedia specifies 4K60 passthrough for the GC311G2, but recording at 1080p60. Check both figures separately.

    Compare the recording resolution and frame rate with the output to your monitor, rather than relying on the 4K figure alone.

  • You always need a capture card, even with a single PC

    OBS offers Game Capture and Window Capture. If your modded game is running on your recording PC, try capturing it in software to see whether that works for your setup.

    Set up your video and audio in OBS first. Otherwise, an extra card could mean unnecessary hardware and more time spent getting everything working.

  • Models with similar names have the same limitations

    The AVerMedia GC311 and GC311G2 have different passthrough specifications. AVerMedia also states that the GC553G2’s 4K144 recording specification requires Streaming Center on Windows.

    Check the full model code, as well as the operating system, recording software and host connection. This will help you confirm that the advertised combination suits your setup.

  • A camera adapter is a substitute for a gameplay card with passthrough

    Elgato describes the Cam Link 4K as an HDMI-to-USB camera adapter; an HDMI output for a gameplay monitor isn’t among its listed connections.

    Plan the connections for your game source, camera, recording PC and monitor separately. If you need to connect a gameplay monitor via HDMI, check that you have a suitable passthrough signal path.

Key brands to consider

Elgato

When comparing options, consider camera adapters and external cards that support different recording formats.

  • Elgato specifies recording at up to 2160p60 for the 4K S, and a USB 3.2 Gen 2 interface for the 4K X.
  • According to Elgato, HDR recording on the 4K S is currently limited to Windows; the 4K X requires USB 3.2 Gen 2 for its specified interface.

AVerMedia

The models mentioned range from Full HD recording to signal paths for more demanding HDMI setups.

  • The manufacturer’s specifications distinguish between the GC311, GC311G2 and GC553G2 for recording and passthrough.
  • According to AVerMedia, the GC553G2’s advertised 4K144 recording requires Streaming Center on Windows; for OBS on Mac, the manufacturer specifies 4K60.

Razer

The Ripsaw X is worth considering as an HDMI-to-USB option for capturing a single source.

  • Razer specifies 4K recording at 30 fps, HDMI 2.0 and USB 3.0 for the Ripsaw X.
  • These specifications don’t confirm passthrough or compatibility with a particular camera or console signal; check your source and the signal path you need.

Capture cards for external HDMI sources

These products are designed for external HDMI sources such as consoles or cameras when you mainly want to record in Full HD on your recording PC. Compare recording format and passthrough separately, and check that the connections suit your source, monitor and computer.

4K video capture card with USB 3.0 and five ports

4K video capture card, USB 3.0, 5 ports

For an external HDMI source, if recording at 1080p with a separate monitor output suits your setup.

The product description specifies 4K/60Hz input and passthrough, plus recording at 1080p/60Hz. It also lists USB 3.0, five ports, and Windows, macOS and Linux.

View at Joybuy
4K video capture card with five ports and loop-through

4K video capture card with 5 ports and loop-through

For HDMI sources such as games consoles or cameras, when you need Full HD recording and a separate output path.

The description specifies 4K/60Hz input and loop-through, plus recording at 1080p/60Hz. USB 3.0 is listed as the connection, with support for Windows, macOS and Linux.

View at Joybuy
HDMI capture card with input up to 4K/30Hz and 1080p/60Hz recording

HDMI capture card, input up to 4K/30Hz

For an HDMI game source, if recording at 1080p/60Hz is enough and you want to connect a second screen via passthrough.

The title specifies an HDMI input of up to 4K/30Hz, USB 3.0 and recording at 1080p/60Hz. The description also lists a microphone input, headphone output and HDMI passthrough.

View at Joybuy
USB 3.0 video capture card with five ports

USB 3.0 video capture card with 5 ports

For an external game or camera source, if 1080p recording and 4K/60Hz passthrough suit your monitor setup.

The description specifies 4K/60Hz input and passthrough, plus recording at 1080p/60Hz. It lists USB 3.0, five ports, and Windows, macOS and Linux.

View at Joybuy
VIELLAN 4K HDMI video capture card with USB 3.0

VIELLAN 4K HDMI video capture card, USB 3.0

For an external HDMI source, if 1080p recording and 4K passthrough meet the needs of your game and monitor.

The description specifies 4K HDMI input and passthrough, along with 1080p recording and USB 3.0. Sources and systems listed include PS4, Xbox, Nintendo Switch, cameras, Windows, macOS and Linux.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How do I set up game video and audio if the mod is running on my recording PC?

First, try Game Capture or Window Capture in OBS, then set up the audio sources you need. According to OBS Project, separate application audio sources are available on certain versions of Windows; capturing the same audio source both globally and in a scene can cause echo.

Why is there no picture from an HDMI source on my capture card?

First, check the signal format and connections. Elgato notes that its capture devices can’t record HDMI signals with active HDCP protection. This doesn’t give you permission to bypass protection measures or record protected content.

Can I publish my mod showcase in Germany?

Not simply because you own a capture card. Section 19a of the German Copyright Act (UrhG) concerns making works publicly accessible; section 23 of the UrhG covers adaptations and other alterations subject to the conditions set out there. Whether you can publish the specific game, mod, music and other content depends on the rights and permissions that apply.

Can I bypass copy protection to make a recording?

Under the conditions set out in section 95a of the UrhG, effective technical measures are protected against unauthorised circumvention. A capture card doesn’t give you permission to bypass protection or publish protected content; use a source that’s permitted and compatible with your presentation.

What should I do if an item bought online is faulty?

Your statutory rights against the seller are separate from any voluntary guarantee. According to the consumer advice centre, if an item is faulty, you should first ask for a remedy – either a repair or a replacement. Keep a record of the specific product description and any promises made about it.