Which solution is right for you?

Speedrunners using an HDMI console

If you play on a dedicated gaming monitor and want to record the console’s output at the same time, check the passthrough and recording signal paths against the modes supported by your console and monitor. Elgato lists the modes supported by its capture devices, while OBS Project includes capture cards as a possible video source.

Speedrunners using a retro console

For an analogue output, first identify whether your console uses Composite, S-Video or Component. Blackmagic Design lists all three input types for the Intensity Pro 4K. HDMI-only devices can’t capture an analogue signal directly.

Speedrunners who commentate

If you want game audio and your voice to come through together in your stream, set up the audio sources in OBS carefully and listen back to a test recording. OBS Project notes that using the same audio source in multiple settings can cause an echo.

What should you look for when choosing?

Buying priority What to check before you buy Who is it important to?
Gaming monitor Check the HDMI output, passthrough mode and recording resolution separately against your preferred signal path. If you want to react in real time during a speedrun, the signal path to your own monitor matters more than the OBS preview. That’s why around 33 % of consumers put choosing the right gaming monitor first.
Game audio and commentary Check where game audio and your microphone feed into OBS, then listen back to a short recording. If you want to present a run with commentary, you need a controllable audio path for both game sound and speech. Around 27 % of consumers put this priority first.
Analogue retro connection Identify your console’s video output and check it against the inputs on your capture solution. With a retro console that has an analogue output, the right connection determines whether you can capture the signal directly. Around 20 % of consumers prioritise this retro connection.
High refresh rate on your monitor Check the resolution and frame rate for the source, passthrough and recording, as well as the USB connection and software. If your gaming monitor uses a high-refresh-rate mode, make sure the capture chain supports it. Around 13 % of consumers focus on retaining their monitor’s current mode when recording.
PC gaming without extra hardware Before buying, make a test recording with OBS Game Capture using the game you plan to play. If your speedrun and OBS are running on the same PC, you may not need an additional capture card, provided Game Capture works. Around 7 % of consumers first check whether they can avoid extra hardware.

Which buying and set-up mistakes should you avoid?

  • Assuming 4K passthrough means 4K recording

    Passthrough and recording are different modes. Elgato lists passthrough up to 4K60 for the Game Capture Neo, while the maximum recording resolution is 1080p60, according to the manufacturer.

    Check the mode table for the exact model, separately for the source, gaming monitor and recording.

  • Planning to use an HDMI capture card with an analogue retro console

    An HDMI input won’t capture Composite, S-Video or Component signals directly. Blackmagic Design lists these analogue inputs for the Intensity Pro 4K, which requires a suitable PCIe slot.

    First identify your console’s video output, then check the input type and the signal path to your gaming monitor.

    With an HDMI solution, you may also need a converter that’s suitable for your specific console signal.

  • Leaving cables and the host connection until after you’ve chosen a device

    Elgato says that an HDMI cable isn’t included with the Game Capture Neo. For the 4K X, Elgato states that a slower USB connection reduces the capture resolution.

    Check the connections you’ll need and what’s included with the exact model, then compare them with your console, monitor and recording PC.

    Depending on the model, you may need an additional suitable HDMI or USB cable.

Which brands are worth considering?

Elgato

The models listed support different HDMI signal paths. The mode specifications come from Elgato and don’t replace measuring latency across your entire set-up.

  • For the Game Capture Neo, Elgato lists 4K60 passthrough and recording up to 1080p60. For the 4K S, it lists recording modes up to 2160p60 and 1080p120, among others.
  • The 4K X is designed for an HDMI 2.1 signal path and specifies USB 3.2 Gen 2 at 10 Gbit/s.
  • Check the host connection for the 4K X: Elgato lists reduced capture resolution with USB 3.2 Gen 1. An HDMI cable isn’t included with the Game Capture Neo.

AVerMedia

The Live Gamer MINI GC311 and Live Gamer ULTRA 2.1 GC553G2 support different signal modes. Specifications apply to the specific model and software listed.

  • AVerMedia lists a maximum of 1080p60 for recording and passthrough on the GC311.
  • According to AVerMedia, the GC311 doesn’t support 4K, HDR or high refresh rates.
  • The advertised 4K144 recording on the GC553G2 requires Streaming Center on Windows and MJPEG. This doesn’t mean the same mode is available in every software package.

Blackmagic Design

The Intensity Pro 4K is worth considering as an internal solution if your retro console uses one of the documented analogue video outputs.

  • Blackmagic Design lists Composite, S-Video and Component video inputs, as well as a PCIe x4 interface.
  • You’ll need a suitable, available PCIe slot. The technical specifications don’t provide measured latency for a specific speedrun set-up.

Joybuy products for HDMI capture

This selection includes external HDMI capture cards with passthrough for consoles or HDMI gaming sources, with separate recording on a computer.

HDMI capture card with input up to 4K 30 Hz and recording up to 1080p 60 Hz

HDMI capture card, 4K input and 1080p60 recording

For an HDMI gaming source with a separate recording path. The product specifications list HDMI passthrough and USB recording.

HDMI input up to 4K 30 Hz; recording up to 1080p 60 Hz. The product description lists microphone and headphone connections.

View at Joybuy
4K USB 3.0 video capture card with five connections and 1080p60 recording

4K USB 3.0 capture card with five connections

For an HDMI gaming source and a separate monitor. The product description lists passthrough and simultaneous recording.

4K/60 Hz input and passthrough; recording at 1080p/60 Hz. Audio recording is listed in the product specifications.

View at Joybuy
VIELLAN HDMI capture card with 4K passthrough and 1080p recording

VIELLAN 4K HDMI Video Capture Card

For HDMI gaming sources such as the consoles named in the product title. The description lists passthrough and USB recording on a computer.

4K passthrough and 1080p recording. The product description lists a microphone input and headphone output.

View at Joybuy
VIELLAN HDMI capture card with 4K passthrough, UVC and UAC

VIELLAN HDMI Video Capture Card with UVC and UAC

For an HDMI console with a separate monitor. The product specifications list passthrough and simultaneous recording over USB.

Recording up to 1080p and 4K passthrough. UVC/UAC, a microphone input and a headphone output are listed.

View at Joybuy
VIELLAN HDMI capture card with 4K passthrough and microphone input

VIELLAN HDMI Video Capture Card with microphone input

For an HDMI gaming source and a separate monitor. The product description lists USB recording and passthrough.

4K passthrough and recording up to 1080p. The product description lists a microphone input and headphone output.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a capture card to speedrun on my only gaming PC?

Not necessarily. If your game and OBS are running on the same PC, first try OBS Game Capture with the game you plan to play. OBS Project notes that it may not work with some games.

How do I connect an HDMI console for gaming and recording?

With a device that has HDMI passthrough, connect the console to HDMI In, the gaming monitor to HDMI Out and the recording PC to the designated USB connection. The supported modes depend on the exact model. Elgato’s guide for the 4K X specifies two HDMI cables for a PS5.

What should I check if the audio is silent, doubled or out of sync?

Check the selected audio source and audio mixer in OBS, then listen back to a test recording. OBS Project warns against capturing the same source both globally and within a scene, as this can cause an echo.

Why is the screen black when I connect a PS5 to the Elgato 4K X?

Elgato lists HDCP being enabled as one possible cause, and explains that you can turn off HDCP in the system settings to capture PS5 gameplay. This product-specific set-up does not give you permission to record protected films or other content.

Can I publicly stream any captured gameplay and music?

No. Being able to record something technically doesn’t automatically mean you have permission to share it. Under §§ 15 and 19a UrhG, public performance and making protected works available to the public are exclusive rights of the relevant rights holders. Check which rights you need for the specific content and how you plan to publish it.