If you only print a few order forms, compare a cartridge printer with an ink tank printer by looking at the purchase price, the right consumables and any maintenance needed after periods without printing. An ink tank printer may be worth considering if you regularly print a lot, but the stated page yields are no guarantee of how much ink you’ll use. In a shared house, you’ll also need to consider the space available, connections and whether you actually need scanning or duplex printing.
Which printer is right for you?
Occasional printers
If you only print order forms now and again, consider the purchase price, replacement cartridges and any maintenance needed after a long break from printing together. Epson Germany highlights the importance of both the initial cost and the cost of ink.
Shared houses that regularly need to print forms
If several people regularly print documents, it’s worth considering consumables, paper capacity and a convenient shared location for the printer. Brother Germany lists a 150-sheet paper tray for the DCP-J1260W.
Shared houses with limited space and several devices
If you share a small amount of space and want to print from a laptop or mobile phone, check the dimensions and connections of the specific model. Brother Germany lists Wi-Fi and USB for the DCP-J1260W.
What should you look for when buying?
Cartridge printer
A good fit if: you print only a few forms and the purchase price and space are your main priorities.
The trade-off: compare the right replacement cartridges and bear in mind that maintenance may be needed after breaks from printing.
Ink tank printer
A good fit if: your shared house regularly prints a lot and you want to compare costs for the same expected print volume.
The trade-off: manufacturers position ink tank printers for higher print volumes, but stated yields and potential savings won’t necessarily reflect your usage.
| What matters |
What to check before buying |
Who is this important to? |
| Total cost |
Compare the printer and consumables for the same estimated number of pages and the same period. |
If I want to keep track of what I spend on forms over the printer’s lifetime, I compare the printer and ink together. Around 29% of consumers say these total costs matter most to them. |
| Printing after a break |
Check the manual for instructions on nozzle checks and printhead cleaning; print a test page before an important deadline. |
If the printer has been unused for a while, I want to know what to do if the text looks faint or streaky. Around 23% of consumers say getting readable printouts after a break is their top priority. |
| Space |
Check the printer’s dimensions and make sure you can access the paper tray, controls and scanner where you plan to put it. |
If I share a small space with others in the house, the printer needs to be easy to position and use. Around 18% of consumers say available space matters most to them. |
| Shared access |
Check Wi-Fi, Wi-Fi Direct, USB and supported operating systems against the devices you actually use. |
If several housemates want to print from their own laptops or mobile phones, the right connection matters. Around 18% of consumers say shared access is their top priority. |
| Scanning and copying |
Check whether you need a scanner, an automatic document feeder or automatic A4 duplex printing for your documents. |
If I also want to scan or copy paper forms, I need the right features rather than just a printer. Around 12% of consumers say handling paper documents matters most to them. |
Common buying misconceptions
-
Comparing only the printer price
The right ink is also part of the buying decision; how much it adds to the cost depends on how much you actually print.
For the number of pages you expect to print, compare the consumables for the exact model you’ve chosen with its purchase price. Assess any ink subscription separately from the printer itself.
Replacement cartridges and, where applicable, an ink subscription are extra costs on top of the printer.
-
Assuming tank yields mean personal savings
Manufacturers position ink tank printers for higher print volumes, but a stated yield doesn’t predict how much you’ll print in your shared house. Ink tank printers may also need maintenance.
Compare cartridge and ink tank printers over the same estimated period and for the same number of pages.
If you print rarely, a larger supply of ink may go unused; depending on the model, maintenance may also be required.
-
Assuming any cheap replacement cartridge will work
HP notes that dynamic security measures on the DeskJet 2920 may block cartridges with certain modified or non-HP circuitry.
Before buying, check cartridge compatibility for the exact model and the terms of any subscription you’re considering.
Printer brands to consider
Brother
Brother Germany describes the DCP-J1260W as a compact multifunction printer for A4 printing, scanning and copying, with Wi-Fi and USB.
- For this model, Brother lists a 150-sheet paper tray and the connection options mentioned above.
- These details apply to the DCP-J1260W; automatic duplex printing is not listed for this model.
Epson
For the Expression XP-4205, Epson Germany lists A4 printing, scanning and copying, individual ink cartridges and automatic double-sided printing.
- Individual cartridges and automatic duplex printing are specific features of this model.
- Assess any optional ink subscription separately from the printer purchase and against the number of pages you expect to print.
Canon
Canon describes the PIXMA TS7750i as a cartridge printer with A4 duplex printing and an automatic document feeder; the MAXIFY GX2051 is a refillable ink tank model.
- Canon lists a single-sided document feeder with a capacity of up to 35 sheets for the PIXMA TS7750i.
- The ink tank features of the MAXIFY GX2051 don’t automatically apply to the PIXMA TS7750i.
HP
HP describes the DeskJet 2920 as a cartridge-based multifunction printer and its Smart Tank range as a refillable alternative for higher print volumes.
- The Smart Tank range offers a refillable option to compare with cartridge printers.
- On the DeskJet 2920, dynamic cartridge security may block certain cartridges with modified or non-HP circuitry.
Suitable products at Joybuy
Related products coming soon.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need an automatic document feeder for occasional order forms?
Not just for printing. If you regularly scan or copy multi-page paper documents, an automatic document feeder can be useful. Canon lists a single-sided feeder with a capacity of up to 35 sheets for the PIXMA TS7750i; check the feature on the model you’re considering.
What can I do if the text looks streaky or faint?
First check the printout, then follow the instructions for your specific printer. For affected EcoTank or Expression printers, Epson recommends running a nozzle check and then cleaning the printhead using the maintenance function.
Who is responsible if there’s a fault: the retailer or the manufacturer?
For a new purchase by a consumer in Germany, statutory rights are generally against the seller; a manufacturer’s guarantee is separate. The Verbraucherzentrale states that new goods are covered for two years from delivery or receipt, with repair or replacement among the possible remedies.
Can an old printer go in the general waste?
No. According to the German Environment Agency, electrical waste must not go in household rubbish and needs to be collected separately. You can take it to a local recycling centre or an appropriate take-back point.