Who is a NAS archive for?

Those responsible for the choir archive

If you need to recover original recordings after a fault or accidental deletion, plan for a separate backup as well as your NAS, and test the recovery process. The BSI recommends making sure you can restore your data, too.

Editors working with multiple project versions

If you regularly create new edits or mixes, check whether you can restore specific earlier file and backup versions. Synology and QNAP document versioning features for this purpose; make sure you set appropriate retention rules.

Choirs with a shared archive

If several people need access to a growing project archive, you’ll need enough storage and appropriate access permissions. If recordings feature identifiable people, you’ll also need to clarify the relevant data protection requirements. The Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information (BfDI) provides guidance on this.

What should you look for when buying?

First decide how you want to restore earlier versions, then plan for usable capacity and access permissions. Important recordings should be backed up to a destination separate from the NAS.

Priority What to check before buying Who needs this?
Restoring recordings Check for a separate backup destination and a backup schedule, and test restoring a file. If I need to recover an original recording after a device failure or accidental deletion, a separate copy matters. Around 29% of consumers put recoverability first.
Finding earlier project versions Check whether you can enable versioning for the folders you need, and how long earlier versions will be kept. If I regularly work on edits or mixes, I want to be able to return to a specific earlier version. Around 29% of consumers say access to earlier versions is their main priority.
Usable archive capacity Allow for project folders and planned versions, and check the usable capacity of the specific drive configuration. If my archive grows to include originals, exports and additional versions, I need enough space for everything I plan to keep. Around 24% of consumers prioritise archive capacity.
Access to shared recordings Check user and folder permissions for viewing and editing. If identifiable people feature in the recordings, clarify the specific purpose of processing and its legal basis. For shared choir folders, I want to control who can view or edit projects. Around 18% of consumers say controlled access is their top priority.

Avoid common misconceptions

  • Treating RAID 1 as a complete backup

    Mirroring also copies changes, so on its own it won’t protect you from accidentally overwriting a file. The BSI does not consider RAID mirroring to be a data backup.

    Plan for a separate copy as well, and test that you can restore a file from it.

  • Confusing snapshots with project versions and off-site backups

    A snapshot on the same volume can give you access to an earlier version after certain changes, but on its own it isn’t an independent safeguard against losing the NAS. Synology notes that snapshots are stored on the same volume.

    Use snapshots to restore earlier versions on the NAS, and set up an additional versioned backup on another destination in case the device fails.

  • Assuming raw capacity or the enclosure alone gives you a complete archive

    Usable capacity depends on the drives and the RAID configuration you choose. QNAP sells the TS-264-8G without HDDs.

    Before you decide, check the usable capacity of your planned configuration, what’s included and whether the drives are compatible.

    You’ll need to budget separately for suitable hard drives to build a complete archive; according to QNAP, HDDs are not included with the TS-264-8G.

NAS brands to consider

Synology

The DS225+ is a two-bay option, while the DS925+ is a four-bay model described as suitable for larger storage needs.

  • Synology documents Snapshot Replication and Hyper Backup with multiple backup versions for both models.
  • Snapshots are stored on the same volume, so they are not a substitute for an independent backup. Synology recommends checking drive compatibility before buying.

QNAP

The TS-264-8G is a two-bay alternative to consider if HBS versioning and its documented network ports suit your planned setup.

  • QNAP lists two 2.5 Gigabit Ethernet ports and documents intelligent versioning in HBS 3.
  • According to QNAP, intelligent versioning requires HBS 3 version 24.0 or later and a suitably configured backup schedule. The model is sold without HDDs, and a fast NAS connection won’t automatically speed up your existing network.

ASUSTOR

The Lockerstor 2 Gen2 (AS6702T) is a two-bay option for a setup with Btrfs snapshots.

  • ASUSTOR documents Snapshot Center for Lockerstor Gen2 and lists 2.5 Gigabit Ethernet for the AS6702T.
  • Volume snapshots require a suitable Btrfs volume. You’ll also need to plan for a separate backup destination.

Suitable products at Joybuy

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Can I recover accidentally overwritten project files using RAID alone?

No. The BSI expressly distinguishes RAID mirroring from data backup because changes are mirrored too. Set up versioning and an independent backup, and test restoring a file.

What should I configure after setting up my NAS to keep earlier versions?

Set up the backup task, destination, schedule and retention period to suit your needs. QNAP notes that an hourly retention rule won’t work if backups are only taken daily. Synology’s Hyper Backup also lets you configure multiple versions and how they are rotated.

Are hard drives and a second backup included with the enclosure?

Not necessarily: QNAP explicitly sells the TS-264-8G without HDDs. Check what’s included with the specific offer, and plan for compatible drives and a separate backup destination.

Can a choir simply give everyone access to recordings featuring identifiable members?

Buying a NAS does not give you permission to publish or share recordings. If you process personal data, the BfDI’s guidance explains that you need an appropriate legal basis under the GDPR. Consent is one possible basis, but not the only one. The basis that applies to a specific recording and how it is shared will depend on the circumstances.