Which solution is right for you?

Choir archivists

If you want to keep rehearsal recordings locally for the long term, make sure you allow for enough storage and set up a clear backup routine. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security recommends disconnecting backup media from the device after backing up.

People responsible for mobile recording

If you receive files at the rehearsal venue or carry them between the rehearsal room and a computer, look for a portable drive with suitable connections and power requirements. Seagate and Toshiba offer USB-powered portable drives in their ranges.

People responsible for protected recordings

If voices can be linked to individuals, responsibilities, access rights and the specific data processing involved need to be clarified. The data protection authority of Rhineland-Palatinate notes that clubs and societies are also affected when processing personal data.

What should you look for when buying?

Portable HDD

A good fit if: You regularly take the drive between the rehearsal venue and your computer.

The trade-off: The focus is more on portability and storage capacity than on especially fast transfers of large files.

Desktop HDD

A good fit if: You back up your archive mainly on a computer in one fixed location.

The trade-off: The location and power supply required by the specific model must suit stationary use.

External SSD

A good fit if: You often copy large recordings while on the move and fast transfer times matter.

The trade-off: Manufacturers’ peak speed figures apply only under the stated conditions for the host device, cable and operating environment.

The main considerations for this purchase can be broadly compared. Your choice of capacity and backup routine should be based on the recordings you actually have and the computers you use.

Priority What to check when buying Who is this important to?
Restoring files Plan how to copy files, disconnect the drive afterwards and test restoring individual recordings. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security recommends checking that backups can be read. I want to be able to retrieve individual recordings after a fault, so I need a routine that I test regularly. Around 28% of consumers put restoring files first.
Archive capacity Allow for existing files, new recordings and the backup versions you want to keep; check the capacity of the specific model. As the choir archive grows, I want to allow enough space for existing and new files, including the versions I want to keep. Around 22% of consumers prioritise archive capacity.
Access protection Check who manages the recordings and whether encryption works with the computers you use. A password feature does not automatically mean that protection has been set up. When recordings contain identifiable voices, I want to restrict access and check that suitable encryption is available. Around 22% of consumers put access protection first.
Device compatibility Check the operating system, file system, connection and backup software. Toshiba lists NTFS as the Windows file system for the Canvio Advance; according to the manufacturer, reformatting is required for Mac use. If I use several computers or systems, I want to know before copying whether the drive and backup software will work together. Around 17% of consumers put compatibility first.
Portability and transfer time Check that the connector and power requirements of the specific drive match your computer; consider whether frequent large transfers justify an SSD. If I collect recordings straight after rehearsal, I want a drive that’s easy to carry and quick to connect. Around 11% of consumers prioritise portability and transfer speed.

Common backup mistakes

  • Relying on a single external hard drive as your complete backup

    An external drive can fail or be damaged at the same time as your computer. A single copy doesn’t reliably protect against these situations.

    Keep your originals and backup separate, plan another copy to be stored separately and regularly check that you can restore files.

  • Assuming a USB connection means immediate compatibility with your system

    A compatible connector doesn’t tell you whether the file system and backup software will work with your computer. Reformatting may affect files already on the drive.

    Check the specific model and target system before setting everything up. Back up any existing files elsewhere before reformatting.

  • Treating peak speed or a password feature as a complete backup solution

    Manufacturers’ SSD speed figures assume compatible devices and connections. A password feature, if available, isn’t necessarily set up, nor does it prove that files can be restored.

    Only consider paying extra for speed if you regularly transfer large files. Set up access protection and test restoring your files.

Key brands to consider

Toshiba

Canvio Basics is a range of portable HDDs. Canvio Advance adds backup and security software options for mobile backups.

  • Toshiba describes both ranges as USB-powered.
  • The Canvio Advance model described comes set up with NTFS for Windows; according to the manufacturer, reformatting is required for Mac use. Make sure the software features suit your backup routine.

Western Digital

My Passport is a range of portable HDDs. The black 6-TB model described by Western Digital is one option for a larger archive that you can take with you.

  • Western Digital lists a USB connection and included Acronis software for this model.
  • Manufacturer information about software and protection isn’t an independent guarantee of data security. Check that the software is suitable and confirm the exact model before setting it up.

Seagate

Seagate offers the Portable Drive range for mobile use and the Expansion Desktop range for archives that are more likely to stay in one place.

  • Seagate lists Portable Drive models from 1 to 5 TB and Expansion Desktop capacities of up to 28 TB.
  • These figures refer to different product ranges, not every individual model. A desktop drive isn’t as suitable for carrying between rehearsal venues as a portable drive.

Samsung

The T7 Shield is an external SSD option for situations where frequent copying and portability matter more than the typical capacity advantage of an HDD.

  • For the 1-TB model tested, Samsung lists sequential peak speeds of 1.050 MB/s for reading and 1.000 MB/s for writing.
  • Samsung notes that these speeds depend on the host device, cable and UASP. They don’t guarantee the same performance on your choir’s computer.

Joybuy products

These drives are suitable for local backups of choir recordings. The selection includes portable HDDs for taking with you and desktop HDDs for an archive kept by a computer in one place.

WD Elements Portable 5 TB USB-C

WD Elements Portable 5 TB USB-C

This portable HDD is designed for local file copies when you need to carry recordings between the rehearsal venue and your computer.

5 TB; USB-C; described as pre-formatted for Windows and Mac.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements Portable 4 TB USB-C

WD Elements Portable 4 TB USB-C

This portable HDD is a good choice for local copies that you can take between the rehearsal venue and your computer.

4 TB; USB-C; described as pre-formatted for Windows and Mac.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements Portable 2 TB USB-C

WD Elements Portable 2 TB USB-C

This compact drive is an option for local copies that need to be carried between your computer and the rehearsal venue.

2 TB; 2.5-inch format; 131 g; USB-C and USB 3.2 Gen 1; exFAT; described as compatible with Windows and macOS.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements Desktop 6 TB

WD Elements Desktop 6 TB

This desktop HDD is better suited to a larger local archive on a computer in one place than to regular transport.

6 TB; 3.5-inch format; USB 3.0; AC power adapter included.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements Desktop 8 TB

WD Elements Desktop 8 TB

A desktop HDD may suit a large archive of recordings kept in one place. If you need to take the drive to rehearsals, bear in mind that this is a stationary model.

8 TB; 3.5-inch format; USB 3.0; AC power adapter included. According to the description, reformatting is required for Mac use.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How do I set up a backup without the cloud?

On a Mac, Time Machine can use a connected external drive. On Windows, File History can back up selected files and libraries. Check that the folder containing your recordings is included, try restoring a file and disconnect the drive after backing up.

Does a new hard drive need to be formatted for a Mac?

Not necessarily; it depends on the drive and your backup routine. Toshiba lists NTFS as the Windows file system for the Canvio Advance model described and says that reformatting is required for Mac use. Time Machine may also ask you to erase a drive when setting up a backup volume. So make sure you save any existing files somewhere else first.

Will the manufacturer’s warranty cover lost recordings?

No. A warranty won’t automatically restore lost files. Germany’s consumer advice centre distinguishes the statutory rights that apply to faulty goods from a voluntary manufacturer’s warranty. A readable backup remains essential for restoring files; check the terms of any additional data recovery services separately.

Can a choir simply store identifiable rehearsal recordings locally?

Choosing to store recordings locally doesn’t, by itself, settle the data protection question. If a choir processes personal data, the GDPR applies under German data protection rules. Those responsible must check that they have a suitable legal basis and appropriate safeguards for the level of risk. Whether a specific recording and its use are permitted depends, among other things, on whether people can be identified, the purpose and how the choir is organised.