Which scanner is right for you?

Sketchbook users with A4 pages

If you regularly scan pages that lie sufficiently flat on your desk, first check that the usable scanning area matches the page size. Canon lists a maximum scanning area of 216 × 297 mm for the CanoScan LiDE 300 and LiDE 400; Epson describes the Perfection V39II as an A4 scanner with an integrated stand.

Artists working with large sheets

If a drawing won’t fit entirely within an A4 scanning area, the scanning area is key if you want to capture the whole page in one scan. Plustek lists the OpticSlim 1180 as supporting originals up to 29,7 × 43,1 cm.

Users of sketchbooks with a fixed binding

If drawings extend close to the spine or the book won’t lie flat easily, the book-edge design should be one of your selection criteria. Avision describes the FB2280E as a book-edge scanner for bound originals.

What should you look for when buying?

What matters What to check when buying Who is this important for?
Scanning area Compare your largest drawing with the usable area in millimetres; for larger originals, check that the scanning bed is big enough. If I want to capture whole pages without stitching together partial scans, getting the right scanning area is my main concern. Around 36% of consumers put capturing a complete page first.
Book spine Check the book-edge design and how the book rests against the scanner with your actual binding; consider the scanning area separately. If I don’t want to force my hardbound sketchbook open, I want to know how the inner edge of the page will lie on the scanner. Around 29% of consumers prioritise capturing pages gently near the spine.
Image quality Check the difference between optical and selectable resolution; choose the colour mode and file format to suit your original and how you plan to use it. If I want to edit fine lines or areas of colour later, useful scanning and saving options matter to me. Around 21% of consumers put image quality first.
Workspace and software Consider the space required and available connections; check that the drivers and scanning software work with your computer. If I want to fit the scanner into my home working routine, I look at the space it needs and whether the software is compatible. Around 14% of consumers prioritise how easily it fits into their setup.

Common misconceptions when buying a scanner

  • A4 doesn’t mean every sketchbook will fit in full

    An A4 scanning area can only capture originals within its usable dimensions. If your drawing is larger, you may need to make partial scans and spend extra time editing them afterwards.

    Measure your largest drawing, including any parts close to the edge, and compare it with the stated scanning area before choosing a size.

    Partial scans can take extra time to stitch together and edit.

  • A large scanning bed won’t automatically solve the problem of scanning near the spine

    The size of an original and how it rests against the book spine are two different things. A larger bed alone doesn’t tell you whether a hardbound book will lie properly on it.

    For bound pages, check the book-edge design and the scanning area separately. Avision describes the FB2280E as a book-edge scanner for bound originals.

  • The highest dpi figure isn’t the only measure of quality

    Canon distinguishes between optical and selectable resolution on the LiDE 400. Depending on your settings, you may end up with larger files and more editing work; the Library of Congress recommends choosing scanning and file settings to suit how you intend to use the scan.

    Compare the optical resolution and try out settings on a typical drawing, rather than relying on the highest selectable dpi figure alone.

    A higher resolution or less compression may require more storage space and extra time.

A guide to key scanner brands

Canon

The CanoScan LiDE 300 and LiDE 400 are A4 flatbed scanners for originals that lie sufficiently flat.

  • Canon lists a scanning area of 216 × 297 mm and USB power for both models. The LiDE 400 has an optical resolution of 4.800 × 4.800 dpi, while the LiDE 300 offers 2.400 × 2.400 dpi.
  • These specifications don’t show which model will reproduce a particular drawing more accurately. Larger pages won’t fit entirely within the stated area.

Epson

The Perfection V39II is an A4 option with an integrated stand, suitable for photo and document originals.

  • Epson lists 4.800 dpi and USB power for the V39II. You can also factor in its integrated stand when planning a space-saving workspace.
  • It’s worth testing a suitable original to see how it reproduces colours and how a book rests against the scanner near the spine. Features of another Epson model can’t be assumed to apply to the V39II.

Plustek

The OpticSlim 1180 is designed for larger originals; Plustek also offers book scanners for bound materials.

  • Plustek lists a maximum original size of 29,7 × 43,1 cm for the OpticSlim 1180, as well as CIS technology and a variable, removable lid.
  • A larger scanning area won’t eliminate shadows near the spine. Its suitability for drawings is how the manufacturer positions it; check the specifications for the specific book scanner you’re considering.

Avision

The FB2280E is a book-edge option for bound A4 originals; the FB25 is a slim A4 flatbed scanner.

  • Avision describes the FB2280E as having a sloped front edge for bound pages. For the FB25, Avision lists CIS technology and a TWAIN interface with various settings.
  • Avision’s claim that the FB2280E’s design reduces shadows near the spine isn’t based on independent testing of sketchbooks.

Flatbed scanners on Joybuy

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Should I choose the more expensive scanner because it has a particularly high dpi figure?

No, not for that reason alone. First measure your original and think about how you’ll use the scan. Canon distinguishes between optical and selectable resolution on the LiDE 400; the Library of Congress recommends choosing scanning and file settings to suit the original and how you intend to use it.

How should I prepare the glass and original before scanning?

Carefully clean the scanner glass with a slightly damp, lint-free cloth, and don’t spray liquid directly onto the device. The Library of Congress gives this advice for photo scanning; if your drawing is delicate or not resistant to wiping, consider separately how best to handle it.