If you can set the balance while you play and are recording on a computer, a suitable stereo USB recording setup may be all you need. If you want to edit percussion microphones individually later, you’ll need the same number of genuinely separate recorded tracks. If you don’t want to use a computer, a device with a built-in card recorder may suit your workflow better. Check the microphone inputs and recording options separately, and test the mic placement in your classroom.
Who are the different recording options for?
Teachers recording quick rehearsal takes
If you’re recording percussion with just a few microphones and want to set the balance during the take, a stereo recording to a computer may be enough. Yamaha lists four Mic/Line inputs on the MG10XU, but its USB audio has two inputs and two outputs. So the number of inputs doesn’t mean you’ll get four separate USB tracks. Shure notes that microphone placement affects the balance between the instrument and room noise.
Teachers using several percussion microphones
If you want to edit individual instruments or microphone positions separately after the lesson, you’ll need enough microphone inputs to use at the same time, as well as genuinely separate recording signals. Allen & Heath lists four Mic/Line inputs and USB routing for individual inputs on the ZEDi-10FX. PreSonus lists eight microphone inputs and USB multitrack recording on the StudioLive AR12c.
Recording without a dedicated classroom computer
If you don’t want a computer running during the take, a standalone recorder that records to a card could be a good option. Zoom lists separate SD tracks and four headphone outputs for the LiveTrak L-8. For the specific model you’re considering, also check the card format, power supply and how you’ll transfer the files afterwards.
What should you look for when choosing?
Record a finished mix over USB
A good fit if: a few microphones will do, you can set the balance during the take and you have a computer ready to record.
Bear in mind: you won’t be able to remix individual microphone signals independently from the finished mix later.
Record microphones separately over USB
A good fit if: you want to edit individual percussion signals on a computer and have recording software available.
Bear in mind: the USB routing needs to match the signal path you want, and setup and editing later are part of the process.
Record directly to an SD card
A good fit if: you want to record without a computer running and the card recorder offers the recording options you need.
Bear in mind: you’ll need to plan for a memory card, power supply and file transfer. Tascam lists the Model 12 as discontinued on its European download page.
| What you need |
What to check before buying |
Who is it important to? |
| A recording you can use straight away |
Check the USB recording options, the number of Mic/Line inputs you need to use at once and the sound in the room with a short test recording. |
If I can set the balance while playing, I want to save the finished mix straight away. Around 34% of consumers whose main priority is a simple stereo recording pay particular attention to this. |
| Editing individual tracks later |
Count the microphones you need to use at once, then compare that number with the input signals that can be sent separately to the computer. |
If I want to edit different instruments separately after the lesson, I need separate recording signals, not just more inputs. Around 33% of consumers whose main priority is editing individual tracks pay particular attention to this. |
| Recording without a computer |
Check whether the device records separate tracks or just the main mix to an SD card, and which storage media it supports. |
If I don’t want a recording computer running in the classroom, I want to save the take directly on the device. Around 33% of consumers whose main priority is recording without a computer pay particular attention to this. |
Avoid common misconceptions
-
More microphone inputs don’t automatically mean the same number of separate USB tracks
The Yamaha MG10XU has four Mic/Line inputs, but its USB audio has two inputs and two outputs. You can’t later remix a finished mix independently in the same way as separate microphone signals.
Compare the number of analogue microphone inputs with the number of USB signals you can record independently.
If you need to edit signals separately, you may need a different recording setup or to record another take.
-
An SD card slot doesn’t tell you whether the device records multitrack audio
The SD recorder on the PreSonus StudioLive AR12c records the stereo main mix, while USB recording can capture individual channels. By contrast, Zoom describes the LiveTrak L-8 as recording separate tracks to an SD card.
Check exactly which signals the specific model records to the card and which it records over USB.
-
More mixer features won’t automatically fix room echo or background noise
Microphone placement affects how loud the instrument sounds in the recording compared with room noise and echo. Placing a microphone very close can also change the sound of the instrument.
Before choosing a more complex setup, record a short take in the actual room using the instruments and microphone positions you plan to use. Shure explains this interaction in its guidance on drum microphone placement.
-
Don’t assume the Tascam Model 12 is available as a current new product
Tascam lists the Model 12 among its discontinued products on its European download page.
If you’re considering a specific listing, check the condition of that exact device and what support is available for it.
Key brands to consider
Yamaha
The MG10XU is an example of a computer-based recording setup where you set the balance in advance.
- Yamaha lists four Mic/Line inputs, pad switches on these inputs and USB audio with two inputs and two outputs.
- The four microphone inputs don’t provide four separate USB recording tracks.
Allen & Heath
The ZEDi-10FX is a useful comparison for recording several microphone signals separately to a computer over USB.
- The manufacturer’s specifications list four Mic/Line inputs and a USB interface with four inputs and four outputs.
- To record inputs M1 to M4 separately, you’ll need to select the correct USB routing. These specifications apply to the ZEDi-10FX.
Zoom
The LiveTrak L-8 combines a standalone SD multitrack recorder with USB audio and several headphone outputs.
- Zoom lists six microphone preamps, separate SD tracks and four headphone outputs.
- You’ll need to plan for the card and power supply as well as connecting the microphones.
PreSonus
The StudioLive AR12c is worth considering for setups with more microphones and USB multitrack recording.
- PreSonus lists eight microphone preamps and a 14x4 USB interface.
- The SD recorder captures the stereo main mix; this is not the same as USB multitrack recording.
Tascam
The Model 12 is an example of a standalone SD multitrack recording setup.
- Tascam lists a 12-track SD recorder and a USB interface with twelve inputs and ten outputs.
- Tascam lists the Model 12 as discontinued on its European download page, so the condition and support available matter if you’re considering a specific listing.
Suitable products at Joybuy
Suitable products will be available soon.
Frequently asked questions
Do four microphone inputs mean four recording tracks?
No. Yamaha lists four Mic/Line inputs on the MG10XU, but its USB audio has two inputs and two outputs. If you want to record microphones separately, check the stated USB channels and their routing for the exact model.
How do I test the setup before my first classroom recording?
Set up the microphones by the instruments you plan to record, in the room where you’ll be using them, and make a short test recording. Shure notes that moving a microphone closer can reduce background noise and echo relative to the sound source, but placing it too close can change the sound.
Do I need a computer to record to SD on the Zoom LiveTrak L-8?
You don’t need a computer running to record separate tracks directly to an SD card, as described by Zoom. Also check the memory card, power supply and file transfer process for your setup.
Can I record conversations in the classroom while recording percussion?
§ 201 StGB prohibits recording another person’s private spoken words without authorisation. Whether a particular recording is authorised, and which additional school data protection requirements apply, depends on the recording situation, its purpose and the relevant German federal state. This does not amount to blanket permission to record lessons. Nor, on its own, does this provision establish a general ban on a purely instrumental recording that captures no conversations. The wording of the Federal Ministry of Justice and the Federal Office of Justice is authoritative.
What happens if a device I’ve bought develops a fault?
For consumer purchases, statutory claims are generally made against the seller. EU guidance on consumer purchases states that there is a minimum guarantee of two years from the date you receive the goods. If the device is bought by a school rather than a private individual, the type of contract and applicable rights should be checked separately.