For many older project versions, an external HDD is an obvious starting point, provided its capacity meets your needs. If you regularly transfer large files between compatible computers, an SSD may be a better fit for your workflow. It’s also important to choose a backup method that actually retains older versions and to test that you can restore them. For confidential documents or those containing personal data, access controls and organisational measures should be appropriate to the risks.
Which solution is right for you?
People responsible for project archives
If you want to back up decisions, documents and previous project versions separately, you should decide how individual versions can be restored as well as how much storage you need. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security (BSI) specifically includes restoration as part of a complete data backup plan.
Clubs with changing teams
If files are transferred between different club computers, the ports, cables, file system and backup software all need to work together. Check that they’re compatible with the devices you actually use before setting up your backup.
People responsible for confidential documents
If you transport a drive containing club data or manage it jointly with others, decide who should be able to access it. If it contains personal data, Germany’s Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information recommends technical and organisational safeguards that are appropriate to the risks.
What should you look for when buying?
External HDD for project archives
A good fit if: you mainly need to store many completed project versions and have worked out the capacity you need in advance.
Consider: The slower speeds compared with an SSD may matter if you transfer files often. A single HDD is not a substitute for a separate backup.
External SSD for frequent transfers
A good fit if: you regularly copy large, current project folders between compatible computers.
Consider: Manufacturers’ maximum speed claims don’t guarantee the transfer rate you’ll get on a club computer. You’ll also need to allow space for older versions.
Drive with built-in access controls
A good fit if: you need to decide who can unlock a drive when it’s being carried around.
Consider: The Verbatim Fingerprint Secure #53650 has a stated capacity of 1 TB. Verbatim recommends installing a security update promptly for this model. Encryption is no substitute for a second backup or organisational measures.
First, work out which project versions you need to keep. Then compare capacity, device compatibility and access controls against the way your club works.
| What you need |
What to check when buying |
Who is this important to? |
| Restore older versions |
Check the backup software’s version retention and test restoring files. |
If I need an older project version, I want to be able to retrieve it easily. Around 28% of consumers put restoration first. |
| Space for project versions |
Allow for folder sizes, how long you want to keep files and expected growth. |
If I want to back up lots of existing documents and additional versions, the capacity needs to suit my archive. Around 22% of consumers prioritise available storage space. |
| Protect confidential files |
Check how the drive is unlocked, how authorised users are managed and what device maintenance is needed. |
If I transport or jointly manage club data, I want to limit access to authorised people. Around 17% of consumers prioritise access controls. |
| Use with club computers |
Check the ports, cables, file system and backup software on the computers you use. |
If I back up files on different club computers, the drive needs to work with the devices and backup method. Around 17% of consumers put compatibility first. |
| Transfer large files frequently |
Choose an HDD or SSD to suit how you’ll use it, and check the computer’s ports and cables. |
If I often copy large, current project folders, fast transfers matter to me. Around 16% of consumers prioritise transfer time. |
Common mistakes to avoid
-
Assuming one external drive is a complete backup plan
A fault, accidental deletion or malware could make the version you need inaccessible if you only have one copy.
Keep copies in separate locations and test whether you can restore an older project file.
Keeping another copy separately requires an additional storage device, and restoration tests take time.
-
Comparing only the stated capacity
The capacity you need depends on how many project versions you want to keep and how your archive is likely to grow.
Check the size of your existing folders and decide which older versions you want to keep before choosing a model.
-
Assuming the connector, format and advertised SSD speed are all you need
A compatible plug alone doesn’t guarantee that your operating system and backup software will use the drive as intended. Manufacturers’ maximum sequential speed claims don’t necessarily reflect performance on a club computer.
Check your computer, cable, file system and backup software before your first backup. If you need to reformat the drive, first check what data is already stored on it.
-
Treating encryption as complete data protection or a replacement for backups
Access controls can’t prevent every kind of data loss or answer every organisational question. Verbatim also recommends a security update for the Fingerprint Secure #53650.
For sensitive data, set access permissions, keep the specific device up to date and maintain a separate copy that you can restore.
Brands to consider
Western Digital
The My Passport range is a portable HDD option for larger collections of local files. According to the manufacturer, models are available from 1 to 6 TB.
- Western Digital lists password protection, hardware encryption and backup software for the range.
- Check whether and how your chosen software retains older versions. These features don’t mean the drive is immune to failure.
Toshiba
Canvio Flex is a portable HDD range supplied with USB-A and USB-C cables for compatible devices. Toshiba lists models with capacities of up to 4 TB.
- The cables supplied by the manufacturer can make it easier to connect to compatible devices with different types of USB port.
- Canvio Flex specifications don’t automatically apply to Canvio Basics. For the documented Basics model, Toshiba lists NTFS as the Windows file system and says reformatting is required for Mac OS.
Seagate
According to Seagate, the Expansion Portable STKM5000400 is a portable 5-TB HDD with a USB 3.0 connection and USB-powered operation.
- The specific model details describe a drive powered via USB.
- For EMEA, Seagate lists a limited two-year warranty and says reformatting is required for Time Machine. These model specifications don’t mean that versions are automatically retained.
Samsung
These specifications are for the black 2-TB portable T7 Shield SSD, model MU-PE2T0S/EU.
- Samsung lists USB 3.2 Gen 2, USB-C and USB-A cables, and maximum sequential speeds of up to 1,050 MB/s read and 1,000 MB/s write.
- These maximum speeds aren’t measurements taken on club computers. You’ll need to check separately whether 2 TB is enough for the project versions you plan to keep.
Verbatim
Fingerprint Secure #53650 is a portable 1-TB HDD for use by a defined group of people who are authorised to unlock it.
- Verbatim lists AES-256 hardware encryption and up to eight authorised users, including an administrator.
- Its capacity may be tight for keeping lots of project versions. Verbatim recommends installing a security update promptly. The manufacturer’s statement about GDPR compliance doesn’t prove that a club’s entire data processing operation is compliant.
Joybuy products for club backups
The portable and desktop WD Elements HDDs below are options for keeping local copies of club documents. Choose the capacity to suit the collection you plan to store, and make sure your backup method covers older versions and how to restore them.
No image available
WD Elements Portable 5TB USB-C
A portable HDD for a larger collection of local project documents. Choose the capacity based on the versions you need to keep.
5 TB storage capacity; USB-C and USB 3.2 Gen 1; 2.5-inch format; 240 g.
The drive alone won’t automatically retain older versions. Include version retention in your backup method and test that you can restore files.
View at Joybuy
No image available
WD Elements Portable 4TB USB-C
A portable HDD for local copies of completed project versions, if 4 TB is enough for your club’s archive.
4 TB storage capacity; USB-C and USB 3.2 Gen 1; 2.5-inch format; 240 g.
Your backup method needs to retain older versions. Test that you can restore a version when you need it.
View at Joybuy
No image available
WD Elements 2TB Portable, USB-C
A portable HDD for local backups, if 2 TB is enough for the files you plan to store and you use both Windows and Mac computers.
2 TB storage capacity; USB-C and USB 3.2 Gen 1; pre-formatted as exFAT for Windows and macOS; USB-powered.
The drive alone doesn’t guarantee that older versions will be retained. Set this up in your backup method and check that you can restore files.
View at Joybuy
No image available
WD Elements Portable 2TB, USB 3.0
A portable external HDD for local club files, provided its stated capacity is enough for the collection you plan to store.
2 TB storage capacity; USB 3.0; USB-powered; formatted for PC and Mac according to the product details.
Before setting it up, check that the file system and backup software are compatible with the computers you use. Your backup method will need to retain older versions.
View at Joybuy
No image available
WD Elements Desktop 8TB, USB 3.0
A desktop HDD for a large local archive, if its higher capacity suits the project collection you plan to store.
8 TB storage capacity; USB 3.0; 3.5-inch format; powered by the supplied AC adapter.
The desktop format requires the power adapter. Make sure your backup method retains older project versions, and test that you can restore them.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Does an external hard drive automatically save older project versions?
No. The type of drive alone won’t create version history. Decide which older versions to keep as part of your backup method, and test that you can restore one of them.
What should I consider when setting it up on Windows and Mac computers?
Check the file system, write access and backup software requirements before transferring files. For the documented Canvio Basics model, Toshiba lists NTFS for Windows and says reformatting is required for Mac OS. This doesn’t automatically apply to Canvio Flex.
Should the club test that it can restore files?
Yes. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security (BSI) includes restoration as part of a data backup plan. As part of your club’s routine, check that you can retrieve both a file you need and an older project version.
Is an encrypted hard drive required for club documents containing personal data?
The general guidance from Germany’s Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information doesn’t establish a blanket requirement to use a particular encrypted hard drive model. When processing personal data, you need appropriate technical and organisational measures based on the risks. Whether encryption is suitable should be assessed alongside access, retention and restoration.