Who is this guide for?

People responsible for the club archive

If you want to preserve irreplaceable original recordings without using the cloud, plan for a separate backup and a tested recovery process. The German Federal Office for Information Security (BSI) points out that the lifespan of storage media cannot be predicted precisely.

Teams with lots of raw footage

If you have a large number of video files, work out their total size and expected growth before choosing a capacity. According to Toshiba, its documented Canvio Basics range goes up to 4 TB; Western Digital offers a 5 TB version of the WD Elements Portable.

Members who use different computers

If you share files locally between club computers, check that their connections and file systems are compatible. Toshiba states that the documented Canvio Basics is formatted as NTFS and needs to be reformatted for macOS.

What should you look for when buying?

Portable external HDD

A good fit if: You need to move recordings between club members or computers, and the capacity you’ve calculated fits the model you choose.

Consider: The capacity, cable and file system all need to suit your workflow. A drive that’s moved around is still at risk unless you have a second copy. Toshiba describes the Canvio Basics as USB-powered, while Western Digital offers a 5 TB version of the Elements Portable.

Desktop external HDD

A good fit if: Your archive will usually stay in one place and the amount of data makes a desktop model a practical choice. Seagate describes the Expansion Desktop as a drive for larger media collections.

Consider: It needs an additional power supply and is less convenient to move. This drive also doesn’t replace a second copy kept separately.

Requirement What to check before buying Who is it relevant to?
Backing up original recordings Allow enough capacity for every planned full copy; test that files open and keep the second copy separately. If I want to protect irreplaceable recordings against a drive failing or going missing, I’ll plan for an additional copy. Around 33% of consumers prioritise protection against data loss.
Space for raw footage Add up the file sizes and allow for future growth; make sure there’s enough capacity for each full copy. If my archive needs to hold lots of original files and further additions, I want to calculate the capacity I’ll need in advance. Around 33% of consumers prioritise having enough space.
Sharing files locally Check that the connections, cables and file systems are compatible with the computers you use; test the files on the receiving devices before handing them over. If I share recordings between different club computers without using the cloud, they need to be readable on the devices we actually use. Around 17% of consumers prioritise sharing files.
Access to recordings of people Decide who is authorised to access the files and how keys will be managed; test encryption and recovery with a copy. If identifiable people appear on the drive, I want to control who can open the recordings. The Bavarian Data Protection Authority points out that clubs must comply with the GDPR when processing personal data. Around 17% of consumers prioritise controlling access.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming a large hard drive is the same as a backup strategy

    Even a drive with plenty of storage can fail or go missing. If it holds your only copy, your recordings aren’t backed up.

    First, work out how much data you have and how many full copies you want. Keep another copy separately and check that you can open files from it.

  • Assuming a USB connection means the drive will work seamlessly with every computer

    A compatible connection alone doesn’t guarantee that every system involved can read and write to the file system. Toshiba says its documented Canvio Basics is formatted as NTFS and needs to be reformatted for macOS.

    Check the specific computers you use against the file system of the model you choose. Test the drives before transferring your archive.

    Reformatting and testing the drive afterwards take time. Back up any files already on it separately first.

  • Encrypting an archive without arranging how the key will be handed over

    If the recovery password isn’t available, authorised club members could lose access to the recordings.

    Decide who is authorised to access the files, store the key securely somewhere your successors can find it, and test opening a copy.

Key brands at a glance

Toshiba

The Canvio Basics is a portable, USB-powered HDD for storing files locally and making backups. Toshiba lists its EMEA range up to 4 TB.

  • For the documented use with Windows, Toshiba says no additional software is needed.
  • The documented model is formatted as NTFS and, according to Toshiba, needs to be reformatted for macOS. This doesn’t make a single copy of your archive safe.

Western Digital

The WD Elements Portable is a range of portable drives; Western Digital lists a 5 TB version.

  • For the documented model, Western Digital specifies USB 3.2 Gen 1 or USB 3.0.
  • The interface specification doesn’t prove that the drive is more durable for a club archive.

Seagate

Seagate offers the Expansion Portable range for portable storage and the Expansion Desktop range for larger media collections that stay in one place.

  • Seagate describes the documented 5 TB portable model as USB-powered.
  • According to Seagate, the documented Expansion Desktop drive needs a power supply. Manufacturer specifications don’t replace a second archive copy kept separately.

Joybuy products for local video archives

This selection includes portable WD Elements drives for moving files locally, plus an 8 TB desktop HDD for an archive that will usually stay in one place.

WD Elements Portable 5TB USB-C

WD Elements Portable 5TB USB-C

For a local copy of your videos that you need to move between workstations.

5 TB; 2.5 inches; USB-C. The right capacity depends on the size of your archive and how many copies you plan to keep.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements Portable 6TB USB-C

WD Elements Portable 6TB USB-C

For a local copy of your videos that you need to move between workstations.

6 TB; 2.5 inches; USB-C. The right capacity depends on the size of your archive and how many copies you plan to keep.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements Portable 4TB USB-C

WD Elements Portable 4TB USB-C

For a local copy of your videos that you need to move between workstations.

4 TB; 2.5 inches; USB-C. The right capacity depends on the size of your archive and how many copies you plan to keep.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements 2TB Portable External Hard Drive, USB-C, USB 3.2 Gen 1, 2.5 inches, exFAT, Black

WD Elements 2TB Portable External Hard Drive, USB-C, USB 3.2 Gen 1, 2.5", exFAT, Black

For storing and sharing files locally, if 2 TB is enough for your archive.

2 TB; USB-C; USB 3.2 Gen 1; 2.5 inches; exFAT. The capacity you need also depends on how many additional copies you plan to keep.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements 8TB Desktop External Hard Drive, USB 3.0, 3.5 inches, Black

WD Elements 8TB Desktop External Hard Drive, USB 3.0, 3.5", Black

For a large archive that will usually stay in one place.

8 TB; USB 3.0; 3.5 inches; requires an external power supply. The product information says the drive is formatted as NTFS and needs to be reformatted for macOS.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is one external hard drive enough for an archive?

Not if you want to keep your recordings safe if the drive fails or goes missing. Make another copy, keep it separately and check that you can open files from it. The German Federal Office for Information Security points out that the lifespan of storage media cannot be predicted precisely.

Can you use a hard drive set up on Windows with a Mac without preparing it first?

Not necessarily. For the documented Toshiba Canvio Basics, Toshiba specifies NTFS as the file system and says it needs to be reformatted for macOS. Check the specific model and test your planned file-sharing process before storing your only archive copy on the drive.

What ongoing costs and warranties should the club allow for?

Allow for an additional full archive copy as a separate storage requirement. Warranty terms depend on the specific model and region: Toshiba specifies a two-year warranty for the documented Canvio Basics, while Seagate also specifies a two-year limited warranty for the documented Expansion Portable in EMEA. A warranty won’t protect your files from being lost.

Can the club keep an archive of identifiable guests indefinitely just because it doesn’t use the cloud?

No. The Bavarian Data Protection Authority points out that clubs must comply with the GDPR when processing personal data; recordings of identifiable people need an appropriate legal basis. Whether keeping, using within the club or later publishing recordings is permitted in a particular case depends, among other things, on the purpose and circumstances. Avoiding cloud storage doesn’t remove the need to check.