Who is this controller guide for?

Switch co-op group

If you’re playing on a Switch or Switch 2, the number of separate player inputs you need is what matters. According to Nintendo, Overcooked! 2 requires one compatible controller per person; individual Joy-Con can each be used separately with supported software.

PC co-op group

On PC, check the connection type and whether your specific game version recognises the controller. Microsoft lists USB, Bluetooth and Xbox Wireless as connection options for the Xbox Wireless Controller; you may need an adapter to use Xbox Wireless on PC.

Group using a PC and console on the same screen

If you switch between a PC and console display, plan the inputs for whichever device is running the game separately from switching the video source shown on screen.

What should you look for when buying?

First, decide which device you’ll be playing on and how many separate player inputs you need. Treat switching the video source on screen as a separate step.

What matters What to look for Who it matters most to
Compatibility Check the device you’ll play on, the full model variant and connection mode against the specific game version. If I switch between PC and Switch, I check the exact variant rather than assuming it’s compatible based on a similar model name. Around 36% of consumers put compatibility with their gaming device first.
Separate player inputs Count the number of players, the controllers you already have and the play styles the game supports. For a local multiplayer session, I want to know whether we have enough controllers for everyone. Around 29% of consumers prioritise the number of separate player inputs they need.
Switching video sources Decide which device is running the game, and whether you’re just switching the display or actually trying to play together across devices. If I’m switching between a PC and console display on the same screen, I plan the inputs for each gaming device separately. Around 21% of consumers mainly want to keep controller input and switching video sources separate.
Additional costs and effort Check the available player slots, what’s included in the box, connection accessories and how the exact model is charged. If I just want to add more player slots, I want to spot unnecessary purchases and any accessories I’ll need beforehand. Around 14% of consumers put extra costs and accessories first.

Common misconceptions when buying a controller

  • Joy-Con and Joy-Con 2 are interchangeable because their names are similar

    According to Nintendo, Joy-Con 2 are designed for Switch 2 only. Older Joy-Con can be used wirelessly with Switch 2, but they can’t be charged directly on the console.

    Before buying, check which console generation the set is for and how it can be charged.

    Key brands at a glance

    Nintendo

    Joy-Con, Joy-Con 2 and the Switch Pro Controller cater for different Switch setups.

    • Nintendo says individual Joy-Con can be used as separate inputs in supported games.
    • Joy-Con 2 are designed for Switch 2; older Joy-Con can’t be charged directly on Switch 2.

    Microsoft Xbox

    The Xbox Wireless Controller is a good fit for Xbox and Windows PC setups where each player needs a full-size gamepad.

    • Microsoft lists USB, Bluetooth and Xbox Wireless as connection options for PC.
    • You may need an adapter to use Xbox Wireless on PC; connecting the controller doesn’t guarantee support in every game version.

    Sony PlayStation

    DualSense is designed for PS5 and compatible Windows PC games.

    • Sony lists USB-C and Bluetooth as connection options for supported PCs.
    • According to Sony, extra features depend on the game; supported PC games require a USB connection for haptic feedback.

    8BitDo

    Ultimate models differ in the platforms they’re designed for and how they connect.

    • According to the manufacturer, the Ultimate Bluetooth Controller connects to Switch via Bluetooth and to PC via 2.4 GHz or USB.
    • The similarly named Ultimate 2C Wireless is listed for Windows and Android; the two model variants aren’t interchangeable.

    PowerA

    The wired Enhanced Wired Controller for Switch is an option for a docked console.

    • For the Pikachu Black & Silver variant reviewed, PowerA lists a detachable 3 m USB cable and battery-free operation.
    • According to the manufacturer, this specific variant only works when the console is docked and doesn’t support features including motion controls or HD Rumble.

Controllers for co-op cooking games at Joybuy

This selection includes controllers for adding separate player inputs on Switch and Switch 2, as well as full-size gamepads for PC, Xbox and PlayStation setups. For multi-platform models, check the exact variant and game support.

Nintendo Switch 2 Joy-Con 2 2-Piece Set (Blue/Light Yellow)

Nintendo Switch 2 Joy-Con 2 2-Piece Set (Blue/Light Yellow)

This pair is designed to provide extra separate player inputs on Switch 2, provided the specific game supports this play style.

The set includes two Joy-Con 2 and, according to Nintendo, isn’t designed for the original Switch.

View at Joybuy
Microsoft Xbox Series X/S Wireless Controller Deep Pink

Microsoft Xbox Wireless Controller Deep Pink (Xbox One/Xbox Series X/S/PC)

A good fit for a PC or Xbox setup where each player needs a full-size gamepad. Also check that your specific version of the cooking game recognises it.

The product details list Bluetooth and Xbox Wireless. According to Microsoft, you may need an adapter to use Xbox Wireless on PC.

View at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch Joy-Con Pair Neon Purple/Neon Orange

Nintendo Switch Joy-Con Pair (Neon Purple/Neon Orange)

With a supported play style, this pair can provide two separate player inputs for a local Switch game.

Nintendo says an individual Joy-Con can be held sideways and used as a controller in supported games.

View at Joybuy
PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller Midnight Black with USB Cable

PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller Midnight Black (including USB cable)

For PS5 or compatible PC games when each player needs their own full-size controller.

According to Sony, haptic feedback and adaptive triggers depend on the game and platform. Supported PC games require a USB connection for haptic feedback.

View at Joybuy
BEITONG PanGu Modular Wireless Gaming Controller

BEITONG PanGu Modular Wireless Gaming Controller

The product details list PC, Nintendo Switch and Switch 2 as compatible platforms. Before buying, check that your specific version of the cooking game recognises the gamepad.

Wired, wireless and Bluetooth connections are listed. Check which mode is right for your device before you buy.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is one Joy-Con per person enough on Switch?

It depends on whether your specific game version supports using a single Joy-Con held sideways. Nintendo describes individual Joy-Con as separate controllers in supported games; for Overcooked! 2, Nintendo specifies one compatible controller per person. Before you play, check that everyone can connect the inputs they need.

Can I use Joy-Con interchangeably between Switch and Switch 2?

Not both ways. According to Nintendo, older Joy-Con can be used wirelessly with Switch 2, but they can’t be attached to or charged directly on the console. Joy-Con 2 are designed for use with Switch 2.

What should I check if my PC controller doesn’t respond in a cooking game?

First, check the connection mode for your exact model and whether your PC and specific game version recognise its input. Microsoft lists USB, Bluetooth and Xbox Wireless for the Xbox Wireless Controller, although you may need an adapter to use Xbox Wireless on PC. For the Ultimate Bluetooth Controller, 8BitDo lists 2.4 GHz or USB for PC. A successful connection to your device doesn’t automatically mean every game will support the controller.

Can a gamepad switch between the PC and console display?

No. A gamepad sends input to the gaming device you’re using; it doesn’t control the screen input. Set up the controller connection and switch the video source shown on screen separately.