Who are the different types of recorder suited to?

Interviewers at a set seating area in the garden

If you want to record someone speaking while seated, you can position the recorder or microphone securely before the conversation and check the sound from the intended spot.

Recording in windy conditions and around garden noise

When recording outdoors, wind on the microphone and changing background noise are factors to consider when planning its position and choosing wind protection.

Collecting longer stories

If you want to find, transfer or edit conversations later, choose the storage, file format and power supply to suit your workflow.

What should you look for when choosing?

When recording someone telling a story while seated in a community garden, microphone placement, wind, storage for later and ease of use may all be priorities.

What matters to you What to look for when buying Who should pay particular attention?
Clear speech Check the stand or microphone position, then listen to a short test recording made from the seat. If I want to record someone speaking while seated clearly, I make sure the microphone is positioned to suit the spot. Around 36% of consumers would put microphone placement first.
Wind noise Check that the wind protection is compatible with the model and test it in the conditions you’ll actually be recording in. When recording outdoors, I want to account for wind on the microphone and test the set-up beforehand. Around 29% of consumers would prioritise wind noise.
Archiving stories Make sure the recording format, storage, power supply and file transfer suit your planned workflow. If I want to find or edit longer stories later, I compare storage and transfer options. Around 21% of consumers would prioritise archiving.
Ease of use Check how to start recording, monitor it and transfer files on the specific model. For a conversation, I want to be able to start and monitor the recording easily. Around 14% of consumers would prioritise ease of use.

Avoid common mistakes

  • Assuming 32-bit float guarantees clear speech outdoors

    The recording format won’t eliminate wind right by the microphone or make up for poor microphone placement.

    First, decide where to position the microphone and choose suitable wind protection. Then listen to a test recording.

    Depending on your set-up, you may also need to budget for suitable wind protection and a microphone mount.

  • Buying wind protection without checking model compatibility

    Zoom describes the WSH-1e as wind protection for the H1essential. Tascam provides a separate list of compatible DR models for the WS-11.

    Check the full model name against the information provided by the relevant manufacturer.

  • Assuming permission to record also covers sharing the recording later

    Section 201 of the German Criminal Code (StGB) covers unauthorised recording of non-public speech and certain subsequent uses. Permission to record does not automatically cover every later use.

    Agree in advance on the purpose of the recording, who will receive it, and whether it may be published or processed in the cloud.

Key brands at a glance

Zoom

Zoom positions the H1essential as a compact handheld recorder with built-in microphones and a stand option for conversations.

  • Zoom lists built-in X/Y microphones and 32-bit float for the H1essential. The manufacturer says the device can be mounted on a stand for conversations.
  • Zoom recommends positioning the built-in X/Y microphone differently rather than placing it directly on a table, as reflections can affect clarity. The WSH-1e is a model-specific wind protector.

Tascam

The DR-05XP is designed for portable stereo recording, while the DR-40XP offers additional external inputs for a more involved set-up.

  • Tascam lists built-in microphones and 32-bit float for both models. For the DR-40XP, the manufacturer also lists two XLR/TRS inputs with phantom power.
  • Extra inputs aren’t automatically necessary when recording one person telling a story. The WS-11 is a separate wind protection product; check that it’s compatible with your specific model.

Sony

The ICD-UX570 is a compact voice recorder designed for a recording workflow using internal storage.

  • Sony lists 4 GB of internal storage, Linear PCM and MP3 recording, USB charging and a recording monitor.
  • These features don’t tell you whether speech will be clearly recorded from your chosen distance or in windy conditions in your garden.

OM SYSTEM

The WS-883 is aimed at people who prefer a straightforward recording process, with built-in options for transferring and finding files.

  • OM SYSTEM lists 8 GB of internal storage, a built-in stand, calendar search, built-in USB data transfer and a simple mode.
  • Try a test recording to check whether speech is captured clearly from a seat exposed to the wind.

Philips

The VoiceTracer DVT4115 is worth considering for conversations whose files you plan to use later as MP3 or PCM/WAV.

  • Philips lists three microphones, 8 GB of internal storage and smartphone remote control.
  • Philips describes cloud transcription as uploading recordings to the Sembly application. Before uploading personal stories, check the purpose and the legal basis for processing the data.

Joybuy products

The Joybuy products listed here are compact or portable voice recorders for recording conversations and storing stories for later. A test recording from the intended seat will help you check whether speech is captured clearly from that spot.

PLAUD Note Pro voice recorder, 64GB, black

PLAUD Note Pro voice recorder, 64GB, black

If you want to archive longer stories, the listed storage capacity may be one factor to consider. Try a test recording from your seat to check that speech is clear.

64GB storage; 30 hours of battery life; four MEMS microphones; compatible with Android and iOS.

View at Joybuy
Mobvoi TicNote Standard voice recorder, 64GB, dark grey

Mobvoi TicNote Standard voice recorder, 64GB, dark grey

If you want to save conversations and manage them later, check beforehand that the controls and microphone position suit your recording spot.

64GB storage; three microphones; 20 hours of recording; Wi-Fi and Bluetooth; OLED display.

View at Joybuy
WaveNote voice recorder, 64GB, rose gold

WaveNote voice recorder, 64GB, rose gold

If you want to keep stories as audio files, check that the recording format and microphone position suit your planned workflow.

64GB storage.

View at Joybuy
Digital voice recorder, 64 GB, with transcription function

Digital voice recorder, 64 GB, with transcription function

If you want to work with recordings later, check that the transcription function on offer suits your preferred workflow.

64 GB storage; transcription function.

View at Joybuy
PLAUD NotePin S wearable voice recorder, 64GB, silver

PLAUD NotePin S wearable voice recorder, 64GB, silver

If you want to record conversations over a longer period, check that the wearable design suits your seating arrangement and captures speech clearly.

64GB storage; up to 20 hours of recording.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I record a story in a community garden without asking first?

Not necessarily: section 201(1) of the German Criminal Code (StGB) covers unauthorised recording of another person’s non-public speech and certain subsequent uses. Whether a conversation is public cannot be determined by its location alone. Before recording, make sure the person explicitly agrees and understands what the recording will be used for. The legislation is set out in section 201 of the German Criminal Code (StGB) on the Federal Ministry of Justice’s Laws on the Internet website.

Can I publish the recording later or upload it for cloud transcription?

Permission to record and the legal basis for later processing or publication need to be considered separately. If consent is the chosen legal basis under data protection law, the Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information stresses that it must be given freely and involve a genuine choice. Philips describes cloud transcription for the DVT4115 as uploading to the Sembly application; don’t assume that agreeing to a recording also means agreeing to this use.

How should I set up a recorder for someone who’s sitting down?

Point the microphone towards the person speaking from the planned recording position, then listen to a short test recording before the conversation. Zoom recommends using a stand for conversations with the H1essential. In its user manual, Zoom notes that placing the built-in X/Y microphone directly on a table can affect clarity because of reflections. This is a model-specific recommendation, not a fixed distance rule.

How do I find wind protection that’s suitable for my recorder?

Check the full model name against the manufacturer’s compatibility information. Zoom describes the WSH-1e as wind protection for the H1essential; Tascam lists the WS-11 for certain DR models, including the DR-05XP and DR-40XP. Then test your set-up in the conditions you plan to record in.