Which setups are right for different users?

Players with a high-refresh-rate display

If you want to keep your gaming display’s resolution or frame rate while streaming, check the passthrough specifications for the exact model. Elgato lists passthrough of up to 2160p144 for the 4K X; AVerMedia also specifies up to 4K144 for the Live Gamer ULTRA 2.1 (GC553G2).

Full HD streamers with a computer

If you want to capture console gameplay in OBS and don’t need 4K files, compare the recording limit with the signal you’re sending to your display. The OBS Project describes capture cards as video capture devices; NZXT explains that the Signal HD60 can pass through a 4K signal, but doesn’t record in 4K.

Streamers using a headset and party chat

If you play with a headset, plan for game audio and, if needed, chat to follow separate signal paths. Elgato notes that, in its PS5 setup, a headset connected to the console or controller can affect whether game audio is output over HDMI.

What should you look for when buying?

First, check what signal you want your gaming display to receive. Then compare the recording format, audio setup and connection to your computer.

Buying priority What to check Who is it important to?
Gaming display output Check the HDMI input and output, along with the resolution and frame rate combinations specified for the exact model. Elgato lists passthrough up to 2160p60 for the 4K S; AVerMedia specifies up to 4K144 for the GC553G2. If I want to keep my usual display settings while gaming, I check the passthrough to the monitor first. Around 33% of consumers put the gaming display first.
Recording quality Compare the recording resolution and frame rate separately from passthrough. NZXT says the Signal HD60 can pass through 4K, but doesn’t record in 4K; Elgato lists recording up to 2160p60 for the 4K S. If recording resolution matters for my stream or footage, I don’t rely on the 4K input specification alone. Around 27% of consumers prioritise recording quality.
Game audio and headset Plan your audio output, HDMI audio, party chat and, if needed, a suitable audio input as separate signal paths. Elgato lists an analogue stereo input for the 4K S and explains the headset limitation for its PS5 setup. If I play with a headset and need game audio or party chat in my stream, I plan these connections before buying. Around 20% of consumers prioritise audio and chat.
Computer and setup Check your computer’s USB connection and operating system against the model’s requirements. The OBS Project lists capture cards as video capture devices that can be added as a source in OBS. If I want to keep using my existing streaming software and computer, I check the connections and setup first. Around 20% of consumers prioritise computer compatibility.

Capture card buying pitfalls

  • Confusing 4K passthrough with 4K recording

    A card can pass a 4K signal through to your display while still limiting recordings on your computer to Full HD. NZXT describes this limitation for the Signal HD60.

    Check the specifications separately to see which signal is passed through to your display and which format the software actually records.

  • Taking a maximum frame rate at face value

    AVerMedia’s advertised 4K144 recording for the Live Gamer ULTRA 2.1 (GC553G2) requires Streaming Center on Windows and the MJPEG format.

    Check that the mode you need works with your operating system and the recording software you actually plan to use.

  • Connecting your headset only after testing the picture

    For its PS5 setup, Elgato notes that when a headset is connected to the console or controller, game audio isn’t output over HDMI.

    Plan picture, game audio and chat as separate signal paths, then test them together with your setup.

    Depending on your connections, you may need additional audio equipment that’s suitable for your setup.

Key brands to consider

The specifications apply to the models named here and shouldn’t be assumed to cover an entire product range.

Elgato

The 4K S and 4K X differ in their listed passthrough modes, among other things, so choose between them based on your preferred gaming display settings and recording format.

  • Elgato lists recording up to 2160p60, OBS support and an analogue stereo input for the 4K S.
  • The 4K S is limited to 2160p60 for 4K passthrough, so it won’t support a 4K120 gaming display signal.
  • Elgato lists HDMI 2.1 and passthrough up to 2160p144 for the 4K X.

AVerMedia

The Live Gamer ULTRA 2.1 (GC553G2) is described as suitable for setups with an HDMI 2.1 display and high passthrough frame rates.

  • AVerMedia lists passthrough up to 4K144 for this model.
  • According to the manufacturer, 4K144 recording requires Streaming Center on Windows and MJPEG; it isn’t a general guarantee for other software.

NZXT

The Signal HD60 is worth considering if you need Full HD recording, even though it can pass a 4K signal through to your display.

  • NZXT lists 4K passthrough for the Signal HD60.
  • According to NZXT, this model doesn’t record in 4K and doesn’t support HDR.

Joybuy products for console streaming

This selection includes external HDMI capture cards for Full HD recording that can pass a higher-resolution signal through to your display.

USB 3.0 capture card with 5 ports

USB 3.0 capture card with 5 ports

An option if you want to record console gameplay in Full HD and pass a 4K signal through to your display.

Recording: 1080p/60 Hz. 4K/60 Hz: specified as input and loop-through, not as a recording format. USB 3.0.

View on Joybuy
HDMI capture card with input up to 4K/30 Hz

HDMI capture card, input up to 4K/30 Hz

For a console setup that needs Full HD recording and HDMI passthrough.

Recording: 1080p/60 Hz. HDMI input: up to 4K/30 Hz. The description also lists a microphone input and headphone output.

View on Joybuy
VIELLAN HDMI capture card with 4K passthrough

VIELLAN HDMI capture card with 4K passthrough

A good fit if you want to record gameplay in 1080p and send the gaming display signal to your monitor via 4K passthrough.

Recording: 1080p. USB 3.0. The description also lists a microphone input, headphone output and support for Windows, macOS and Linux.

View on Joybuy
VIELLAN HDMI capture card with UVC and UAC

VIELLAN HDMI capture card with UVC/UAC

An option for Full HD gameplay recording if you also want microphone and headphone connections on the device.

Video recording: up to 1080p. 4K HDMI passthrough. USB 3.0; supports UVC and UAC. The description lists OBS and compatibility with Windows, Mac and Linux.

View on Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How do I connect a capture card to OBS?

With a model that has HDMI passthrough, connect the console to HDMI-In and the display to HDMI-Out; connect the card to your computer using its specified interface. In OBS, add it as a video capture device. Check the instructions for the exact model before connecting it.

Why is the PS5 picture black when I use a capture card?

In Elgato’s documented PS5 setup, HDCP must be disabled for recording to work. For gameplay, Elgato advises turning off HDCP in the PS5 settings while the console is initially connected directly to the display. This doesn’t make protected films or streaming content available to record freely.

Why does game audio disappear when I connect a PS5 headset?

For its PS5 setup, Elgato notes that game audio isn’t output over HDMI when a headset is connected to the console or controller. Before choosing a card, decide whether you need HDMI audio or an additional audio solution that works with the specific model.

What happens if a product develops a fault after purchase in Germany?

According to the European Union’s Your Europe consumer information, purchases from a trader in the EU are generally covered by a minimum two-year legal guarantee from the date you receive the goods. This is different from a voluntary manufacturer’s warranty; the seller is responsible for handling claims under the legal guarantee.

Can I stream any game, including its music and videos, publicly?

No. Owning a capture card doesn’t automatically give you permission to use content. Germany’s Copyright Act treats the public performance and making available of protected works as rights of exploitation. Whether you can stream particular game, music or video content depends on the relevant rights and terms of use. This is neither blanket permission nor a blanket ban on all gameplay.