Which controller is right for you?

Groups playing from different seats on the sofa

If you’re playing together on one screen, make sure the controllers and console work reliably from the seats you plan to use. Team17 lists local co-op for up to four players in Overcooked! 2, but the number of controllers you need will still depend on your game and setup.

PC cooking-game teams using multiple gamepads

If you’re connecting several controllers to a Windows PC, check which connection methods each model supports. Xbox Support lists USB, the Xbox Wireless Adapter for Windows and Bluetooth as connection options. Performance can vary by device when using several Bluetooth controllers.

Switch players adding another controller

For a Nintendo Switch or Switch 2, the exact controller generation matters: Nintendo confirms that the Switch Pro Controller can be used wirelessly with Switch 2, while the Switch 2 Pro Controller is compatible only with Switch 2.

What should you look for when buying?

Start by checking that the controller works with your platform and provides enough places for players. Then test the connection from your chosen seat, before considering comfort and power options.

What matters to you? What should you check? Who is this especially important for?
Platform compatibility Check support for your console or Windows, and confirm how the specific model connects. If I’m buying an extra gamepad, it needs to work with my console or PC using the connection I plan to use. Around 36% of consumers put platform compatibility first.
Connection from your seat Test from the seat you’ll use; place the console in an open area and, if needed, check whether a supported data cable can be used. If I’m sitting off to the side, I want to play without connection dropouts interrupting the game. Around 29% of consumers prioritise a reliable connection from their seat.
Extra places for players Check the game’s local player limit, how many controllers you have and how many can connect at once. If more people are joining us, I need enough controllers to use at the same time for that particular game and device. Around 21% of consumers prioritise having extra places for players.
Comfort and power Try the feel of the controller in your hands, and consider its battery, whether it uses replaceable batteries, and suitable charging or data cables. If I’m planning longer gaming sessions together, I want a controller that feels right and a charging option that suits my setup. Around 14% of consumers prioritise comfort and charging.

Common misconceptions when buying a controller

  • “Switch Pro” and “Switch 2 Pro” are interchangeable

    Compatibility differs: Nintendo says the Switch 2 Pro Controller works only with Switch 2, while the Switch Pro Controller can also be used wirelessly with Switch 2.

    Before ordering, check the full model name against the generation of your console.

  • A wireless controller improves your view from the side of the sofa

    The controller connection affects your inputs, not your viewing angle. So a different controller won’t solve a screen visibility problem.

    First, check that you can see the screen clearly from the seat you plan to use. Consider a different controller or connection only if you need to improve inputs or freedom of movement.

  • Connecting one gamepad over Bluetooth doesn’t tell you how several will perform

    Microsoft notes that the performance of multiple Bluetooth controllers on Windows can vary by device.

    Before playing together, test the planned number of controllers connected at the same time to the PC you’ll be using.

    Depending on your setup, you may need an extra adapter or a different connection.

Key brands to consider

Nintendo

Controllers for Nintendo Switch and Switch 2, when you need another player slot on a Nintendo console.

  • Nintendo confirms that the Switch Pro Controller can be used wirelessly with Switch 2.
  • Nintendo says the Switch 2 Pro Controller is compatible only with Switch 2, so check the model generation carefully.

Microsoft Xbox

Xbox Wireless Controllers for Xbox and Windows PCs, as long as your device and chosen connection are compatible.

  • Xbox Support lists USB, Bluetooth and the Xbox Wireless Adapter for Windows as connection options.
  • Microsoft says Bluetooth reliability depends on the device; performance can vary when using multiple Bluetooth controllers.

Sony PlayStation

The DualSense as an extra controller for PS5 and, with supported devices, for PC too.

  • Sony describes USB and Bluetooth connections for supported PCs.
  • On PC, extra features depend on the game. Sony says haptic feedback requires a USB connection in games that support it.

8BitDo

Different Ultimate 2C versions for different platforms, so the full model name matters.

  • 8BitDo lists 2.4 GHz and wired connections on Windows, plus Bluetooth on Android, for the Ultimate 2C Wireless; the Ultimate 2C Bluetooth version is listed for Switch.
  • Compatibility information for one version doesn’t necessarily apply to the other.

GameSir

The G7 Pro for PC- and Xbox-focused setups, if you’re looking for extra customisation alongside co-op gaming.

  • GameSir lists TMR sticks, extra settings and 2.4 GHz operation on PC.
  • These manufacturer claims don’t prove a particular advantage in any specific cooking game, or wireless play on Xbox.

Controllers for extra players

This Joybuy selection includes gamepads for extra players on PC and consoles. Before buying, check that the specific model works with your device and the connection you want to use.

EasySMX D10 PC Controller in black

EasySMX D10 PC Controller

For a wireless setup: the product title lists Bluetooth and PC, Switch, Android and iOS as supported platforms.

The title also lists a TMR joystick, dual-mode triggers, mechanical buttons and a 1000Hz polling rate.

View on Joybuy
Gaming controller with dual vibration and gyroscope for Switch and PC

Gaming controller with dual vibration and gyroscope for Switch and PC

For a Switch or PC setup: the product title lists both platforms.

The product description lists a wireless Bluetooth connection, while the title mentions dual vibration and a gyroscope.

View on Joybuy
Microsoft Xbox Series X/S Wireless Controller in Deep Pink

Microsoft Xbox Series X/S Wireless Controller – Deep Pink

For Xbox or PC gaming: the product title lists Xbox One, Xbox Series X/S and PC as supported platforms.

The description lists Xbox Wireless and Bluetooth, as well as textured grips and a Share button. Microsoft notes that performance can vary by device when multiple Bluetooth controllers are connected to a PC.

View on Joybuy
Nintendo Switch Pro Controller in black

Nintendo Switch Pro Controller – Black

For an extra controller on Nintendo Switch or Switch 2: Nintendo confirms that this Switch Pro Controller model can be used wirelessly with Switch 2.

The product description lists HD Rumble and motion controls. Don’t confuse it with the Switch 2 Pro Controller, which Nintendo says is compatible only with Switch 2.

View on Joybuy
BEITONG KP70 Elite Wireless Gaming Controller

BEITONG KP70 Elite Wireless Gaming Controller

For a setup with PC, Nintendo Switch, Switch 2, Steam or Android: these platforms are listed in the product title.

The title lists haptic trigger feedback, adjustable-resistance joysticks and six programmable buttons. The description lists wired, wireless and Bluetooth connections.

View on Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Will a different controller improve a poor view from the side of the sofa?

No. The controller connection affects your inputs, not your viewing angle. Check your seating and screen position; RTINGS describes viewing angle as a display characteristic.

Can I just connect any four Bluetooth controllers for Overcooked! 2?

Not necessarily. Team17 lists local co-op for up to four players, but the number of controllers that can connect at once also depends on your device and connection type. Microsoft notes that performance may vary when multiple Xbox controllers are connected to a PC over Bluetooth. Nintendo says that with a Bluetooth audio device connected to a Switch, a maximum of two controllers can be connected wirelessly at the same time.

What should I check first if the connection drops from a seat at the side?

For Switch Joy-Con, Nintendo recommends checking the charge level, distance and console position; the console should not be behind the TV or under metal. For other controllers, follow the manufacturer’s guidance and test the connection from the seat you’ll actually use.

Are the Switch Pro Controller and Switch 2 Pro Controller the same?

No. Nintendo confirms that the Switch Pro Controller can be used wirelessly with Switch 2; the Switch 2 Pro Controller is compatible only with Switch 2. Before buying, check the full model name and your console generation.

When is a cable a better option than a wireless connection?

If the wireless connection is unreliable from your seat at the side and you can safely route a cable, a supported wired connection could be an alternative. Make sure the cable can transfer data; a charging-only cable may not be enough for a PC.