Who are the different controllers for?

Co-op duo on one console

If you’re looking for a second controller for PS5, Xbox or Switch, first check whether your console and the specific game support local multiplayer, and how players are identified.

Co-op duo on PC

If you’re playing together on a Windows PC, check that the game recognises both inputs and that the connection supports the controller features you want to use.

Gaming in a dimly lit room

If lighting or a clear player indicator matters to you, check which parts of the controller actually light up and whether its connection and features suit your setup.

What should you look for when buying?

Start by checking that the platform and game are compatible. Then consider whether player indicators or lighting, the connection and the power supply suit your shared gaming setup.

What matters when buying What to check Who is it important to?
Platform and game Check the full model name, supported platform, connection and whether the specific game supports the controller. If I’m playing on a PC or console, I mainly want to be sure the game and controller work together; around 33 % of consumers put compatibility first.
Playing together Check whether the game supports local multiplayer and separate inputs. Sony says that up to four DualSense controllers can be used simultaneously with PS5. If we want to play an adventure together, it’s important to me that both of us can take part in the game; around 27 % of consumers prioritise separate inputs for playing together.
Finding your way in the dark Check which areas light up, whether the brightness can be adjusted or the lighting switched off, and whether key game features still work. If I want to tell controllers or players apart more easily in a dimly lit room, I look for visible indicators or adjustable lighting; around 20 % of consumers prioritise visibility.
Connection and power Check the cable length and distance from your seat, as well as the charging, rechargeable battery or battery options for the exact model. If we’re playing together for longer, I want a power option that suits where we’re sitting and avoids unnecessary interruptions; around 20 % of consumers look first at the connection and power supply.

Which assumptions should you avoid?

  • RGB lighting doesn’t automatically mean the action buttons are illuminated

    The models described have lighting zones or lighting modes on the casing. That doesn’t mean the button labels light up too or are easier to read in the dark.

    Check which part of the exact model is illuminated and whether you can adjust the brightness.

  • Controller generations with similar names aren’t automatically interchangeable

    Nintendo says that the Switch 2 Pro Controller is only for Switch 2. For the 8BitDo Ultimate 2 Bluetooth, the manufacturer says a firmware update is needed to use it with Switch 2.

    Before ordering, check your console model against the controller’s full name and any firmware requirements.

    A controller that isn’t compatible with your console could mean you need to buy another one.

  • Consider the connection, power supply and range together

    Microsoft’s Xbox controller doesn’t support audio through the controller on Windows over Bluetooth. A wired model such as the one from PowerA, on the other hand, has a fixed cable length.

    Consider the features you need, the connection, the power supply and the distance from where you sit together.

    Depending on the model, you may need batteries or an adapter; a cable can also limit where you sit.

Which brands are worth considering?

Sony PlayStation

DualSense controllers are an option if you need an extra controller for PS5. The DualSense Edge is aimed at players who want more ways to customise their controller.

  • Sony describes the DualSense as offering colour-coded player indicators, haptic feedback and adaptive triggers in supported games.
  • Some features may not be available on PC, depending on the game and connection. The PS5 player indicator doesn’t mean the action buttons are illuminated.

Microsoft Xbox

The Xbox Wireless Controller is an option for compatible Xbox consoles and Windows PCs, provided the available connection options suit your setup.

  • Microsoft lists USB, Bluetooth and the Xbox Wireless Adapter as connection options on Windows.
  • Audio through the controller isn’t supported over Bluetooth on Windows. Before buying, check which connection and accessories you’ll need.

Nintendo

When choosing a Pro Controller, it’s important to check whether you have a Switch or Switch 2.

  • Nintendo lists motion controls, HD Rumble and amiibo support for the original Switch Pro Controller.
  • Nintendo says the Switch 2 Pro Controller is only for Switch 2. Battery life figures are estimates, not a guarantee of how long a gaming session will last.

8BitDo

The Ultimate 2 Bluetooth is an option for buyers considering a Switch and Windows controller with a charging dock and lighting modes.

  • 8BitDo lists Switch and Windows compatibility, along with several lighting modes, for this model.
  • The manufacturer says a firmware update is needed to use it with Switch 2. The manual lists NFC and HD Rumble among the Switch features that aren’t supported.

PowerA

The wired Advantage Wired with Lumectra is an illuminated option for the Xbox and Windows systems listed by the manufacturer.

  • PowerA lists four lighting zones and a 3-m cable for this model; according to the manual, you can adjust the lighting or switch it off.
  • The lighting zones don’t mean the button labels are easier to read. Features of this model don’t necessarily apply to other Lumectra controllers.

Controller selection at Joybuy

The Joybuy products below include extra controllers for PS5, Xbox and Windows, as well as Nintendo Switch and Switch 2. A wired PC and Switch model rounds out the selection for anyone looking for adjustable RGB lighting.

BIGBIG WON Rainbow 2 Pro Wired Controller

BIGBIG WON Rainbow 2 Pro Wired Controller

An option if you’re looking for a wired controller for PC or Nintendo Switch with RGB lighting.

The product details list customisable buttons, a turbo function, gyro controls and dual vibration. RGB lighting doesn’t mean the button labels are illuminated.

View at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch Pro Controller, Black

Nintendo Switch Pro Controller – Black

A good option if you’re looking for a wireless Pro Controller for a Nintendo Switch console.

The product details list motion controls, HD Rumble and a rechargeable lithium-polymer battery.

View at Joybuy
Microsoft Xbox Wireless Controller, Pulse Red

Microsoft Xbox Wireless Controller – Pulse Red

An option for Xbox One, Xbox Series or Windows PC, provided the listed platform and connection suit your setup.

The product details list Bluetooth, Xbox Wireless and two AA batteries.

View at Joybuy
PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller, Midnight Black, with USB cable

PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller – Midnight Black

An extra PS5 controller, if player identification and the DualSense features suit the game you want to play.

The product details list haptic feedback, adaptive triggers and a USB cable. Sony describes colour-coded identification for connected controllers on PS5.

View at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch 2 Pro Controller

Nintendo Switch 2 Pro Controller

An option for co-op games on Switch 2; Nintendo says this model is only for this console generation.

The product details list HD Rumble 2, motion controls, amiibo functionality and assignable GL/GR buttons.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Are two controllers enough for us to play any adventure together?

No. It also depends on the game itself: it must support local multiplayer and the necessary controller inputs. Sony confirms that up to four DualSense controllers can be used at the same time on PS5, but that alone doesn’t tell you whether a particular game has a co-op mode.

How do I connect a second DualSense to PS5?

For the initial pairing, Sony recommends connecting the controller to your powered-on PS5 using a USB cable and pressing the PS button. Once paired, you can use it wirelessly if the battery is sufficiently charged; pressing the PS button assigns the player a colour.

Will a headset work with an Xbox controller connected over Bluetooth on Windows?

Microsoft says audio through the controller isn’t supported over Bluetooth on Windows. For audio through the controller, Microsoft lists USB or an Xbox Wireless Adapter as supported connection options.

Does RGB lighting make the buttons easier to read in a dimly lit room?

You can’t tell from the lighting specification alone. Check whether the button labels or just parts of the casing light up on the exact model, and whether you can adjust the lighting.

Is the Nintendo Switch 2 Pro Controller also designed for the original Switch?

No. Nintendo says the Switch 2 Pro Controller is only for Switch 2. Check your console generation against the full model name before choosing a controller.