Which controller is right for you?

Co-op players sharing a screen

If you’re playing together, check whether your particular puzzle game needs two separate inputs, and whether one Joy-Con per person is enough or everyone needs a full gamepad.

Players who find clues hard to read

If the picture is small or split between players, it may help to check your seating distance and display settings separately from your controller. Zoom needs to work with the game mode and may reduce how much of the picture you can see at once.

Players who need adapted controls

If certain buttons are hard to reach or you want to control one character together, check the button mapping and shared-input features before simply choosing a second standard controller.

What should you look for in a co-op puzzle controller?

Start by checking the game, platform and inputs you need. If clues are hard to read, treat that as a separate display issue; connection and seating only become important after that.

What matters What to check before buying Who will find this most useful?
Compatibility and separate inputs Check the console, game version and local co-op mode. Nintendo says the software determines whether individual Joy-Con are suitable. If we’re controlling separate characters together, we want to know whether the specific game supports the inputs we have in mind. Around 33% of consumers put compatibility and player numbers first.
Readability on a small or split screen Check your seating distance, along with the game’s and device’s zoom and display settings. Nintendo notes that some modes don’t support zoom. If we can barely make out important clues on a small screen, we check the display aids first and bear in mind that zoom may show less of the overall picture. Around 27% of consumers prioritise screen readability.
Accessible buttons and shared controls Check whether the button mapping you want is supported and whether two controllers provide separate or shared inputs. According to Microsoft, Xbox Controller Assist combines two controllers into one input. If a button is hard to reach or we want to control the same character together, the right button mapping or input-sharing option matters. Around 20% of consumers put adapted controls first.
Connection and seating Check the connection options for your device and make sure there’s a safe cable route for both seats. Microsoft lists USB, a wireless adapter and Bluetooth for the Xbox Wireless Controller on Windows. If the seating positions aren’t convenient for the connection, we want to choose a suitable option and route any cables so they’re not in the way. Around 20% of consumers prioritise seating and connection.

Mistakes to avoid when buying

  • Assuming two controllers mean two separate sets of game controls

    Whether two people can play independently, and how a Joy-Con is held, depends on the specific game and mode.

    Before buying, check the game’s details for local co-op and supported controllers.

  • Buying a premium controller to make hard-to-read clues clearer

    A controller won’t make the text or clues on screen any bigger. Zoom and display settings are features of the device or game.

    First, try adjusting your seating distance and using the available display aids. Choose extra controller features only if you actually need them.

  • Assuming similarly named models work on the same platforms

    8BitDo lists the Ultimate 2C Wireless for Windows and Android, while the Ultimate 2C Bluetooth is listed for Switch. Nintendo says Joy-Con 2 are designed for Nintendo Switch 2 only.

    Check the full model name, console generation and, where applicable, the required system version.

  • Assuming ‘wireless’ means the same thing on every platform

    Connection types and available features depend on the controller and the device you’re using.

    Check the connection type for your platform and, if you’ll be using a wired controller, plan a safe route for the cable.

A guide to the main controller brands

Nintendo

Joy-Con are suitable for supported co-op games on Nintendo Switch; Joy-Con 2 are a separate platform variant for Nintendo Switch 2.

  • Nintendo explains how to use a single Joy-Con, but the right way to hold it depends on whether the software supports it.
  • Nintendo says Joy-Con 2 are designed for Nintendo Switch 2 only. Check your console generation before buying.

Sony PlayStation

DualSense is suitable for PS5 and supported PC games; the extra settings on the DualSense Edge are mainly useful if you plan to use them.

  • Sony lists Bluetooth and USB connections for supported devices.
  • On PC, some features depend on the game. Sony says haptic feedback also requires a USB connection on PC.

Microsoft Xbox

The Xbox Wireless Controller is suitable for compatible Xbox and Windows setups, especially if you need wireless freedom or want to share control of one character.

  • Microsoft lists USB, a wireless adapter and Bluetooth as connection options on Windows. Xbox Controller Assist can combine two controllers into one shared input.
  • Microsoft says audio through the controller isn’t supported over Bluetooth on Windows. Controller Assist doesn’t replace two separate player inputs.

8BitDo

According to the manufacturer, compatibility varies between Ultimate 2C models and platforms.

  • 8BitDo lists the Ultimate 2C Wireless for Windows and Android, and the Ultimate 2C Bluetooth for Switch.
  • The model variants aren’t interchangeable. For Switch 2, 8BitDo lists a required system version for the Ultimate 2C Bluetooth.

GameSir

The G7 HE is a wired option for compatible Xbox and Windows devices; the G7 Pro’s connection options vary by platform.

  • GameSir specifies a 3 m cable and no battery for the G7 HE.
  • GameSir describes the G7 Pro as wired for Xbox and wireless for PC and mobile devices.

Controller picks at Joybuy

This selection includes controllers for local co-op on Nintendo Switch and Switch 2, as well as Xbox, Windows and PS5 gaming setups. Check the display settings separately to make sure clues are easy to read.

Nintendo Switch 2 Joy-Con 2 2-piece set in Blue and Light Yellow

Nintendo Switch 2 – Joy-Con 2 (2-piece set, Blue/Light Yellow)

For local co-op on Nintendo Switch 2, provided the specific game supports separate Joy-Con inputs.

Left and right Joy-Con 2; designed for Nintendo Switch 2, not the original Nintendo Switch.

View at Joybuy
Razer Wolverine V3 Tournament Edition White gamepad

Razer Wolverine V3 Tournament Edition White

For compatible Xbox and Windows setups if you want a wired connection and extra customisable controls.

Four rear paddles and six assignable buttons; wired connection with a 3 m USB-C cable.

View at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch Joy-Con Controller Pair in Neon Red and Neon Blue

Nintendo Switch – Joy-Con Controller Pair (Neon Red/Neon Blue)

For local co-op on Nintendo Switch, if the game supports using the Joy-Con separately as you intend.

Joy-Con pair in Neon Red and Neon Blue; listed for Nintendo Switch.

View at Joybuy
GameSir G7 HE wired controller

GameSir G7 HE Wired Controller

For a wired gaming setup with a compatible connection to Xbox, Windows or Steam.

Hall Effect sticks; wired connection with a 3 m USB-C cable. The product details list Xbox, Windows and Steam.

View at Joybuy
PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller White

PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller White

For a PS5 setup that needs another gamepad; features on other devices depend on the game.

Bluetooth and USB-C are listed as connection options. Sony says haptic feedback on PC requires a supported game and a USB connection.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions about controllers for co-op puzzles

Are two individual Joy-Con enough for every co-op puzzle game?

No, it depends on the game. Nintendo says the way you can hold a Joy-Con depends on the software. For It Takes Two on Switch, Electronic Arts specifically lists either a pair of Joy-Con or one controller per person; check each game’s details on local co-op for other titles.

How can I make small clues bigger?

First, check the display settings on your game and device. Nintendo describes zoom for Switch and Switch 2, while Xbox offers a console magnifier that you can control with a controller. Some game modes don’t support zoom, and magnification may reduce how much of the overall screen you can see.

Can a second person use a second Xbox controller to control the same character?

Yes. Microsoft says Xbox Controller Assist combines two controllers into one shared input. To control two separate characters, you’ll need two inputs supported by the specific game mode instead.

Does the DualSense work the same way on PC as it does on PS5?

Not necessarily. Sony lists Bluetooth and USB for supported devices, but some features depend on the game and connection. Sony says haptic feedback on PC requires a supported game and a USB connection.

What are my rights if a controller bought online is faulty?

For online purchases, you generally have 14 days from delivery to cancel your order; exceptions and possible return costs apply. Separately, if the product is faulty, you have a statutory right to a minimum two-year guarantee from the seller. These details are provided by the EU consumer portal Your Europe; a voluntary manufacturer’s guarantee does not replace your statutory rights.