Cricket fans on noisy trains
If you want to follow the commentary at a sensible volume despite train noise, start by checking the fit and isolation.
Start with well-fitting ear tips and a connection that works with your playback device. Passive isolation can help reduce train noise without the need to charge a wired monitor. If you often need to hear announcements or would rather avoid a cable, consider a modular Bluetooth monitor or ANC earbuds with an ambient sound mode instead. None of these options replaces listening at a sensible volume or pausing for important announcements.
If you want to follow the commentary at a sensible volume despite train noise, start by checking the fit and isolation.
If you need to hear station announcements and other updates, look for an easy-to-reach pause function or an ambient sound mode.
If you use different audio outputs or want to switch between wired and Bluetooth connections, check the connector and what’s included with the exact variant.
First decide whether you mainly want passive isolation, the option to switch between wired and Bluetooth, or ANC with an ambient sound mode. Then check the fit, how easy it is to pause for announcements, and whether the connection works with your playback device.
| What matters | What to check before buying | Who is this important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Understanding voices | Assess speech playback using a commentary at a comfortable volume; don’t rely on a sound description alone. | When I listen to cricket commentary, I want to be able to follow voices clearly. Around 28% of consumers prioritise speech intelligibility. |
| Reducing train noise | Check the fit and seal; manufacturers’ dB figures are not directly comparable measurements taken on a train. The WHO recommends well-fitting and, where appropriate, noise-reducing headphones to help avoid turning up the volume in noisy surroundings. | When train noise gets in the way of listening, I want to reduce it without making the audio unnecessarily loud. Around 28% of consumers say noise isolation is their top priority. |
| Fit and announcements | Check that the ear tips fit comfortably and try the pause function or ambient sound mode. Deutsche Bahn says loud listening, including through headphones, is not welcome in ICE quiet zones. | On longer journeys, I need a comfortable fit and want to hear important announcements. Around 22% of consumers prioritise comfort and being able to hear announcements. |
| Connection and operating mode | Match the connector on the headphones to the output on your playback device; if the cable is replaceable, check the exact connector type too. For Bluetooth, remember that the device will need charging. | If I use different devices or want to switch between wired and wireless listening, the connection needs to work with my playback device. Around 22% of consumers say connection flexibility is their top priority. |
The dB figures quoted by Shure and Etymotic relate to different models. They don’t tell you how the headphones will fit your ears or how well you’ll hear commentary or announcements on a particular train.
Check the ear tips and speech playback using a suitable example. Pause for announcements rather than relying on a noise-reduction figure.
The SE215, ATH-E40 and JD1 use different connectors on the headphones. The plug also needs to match your playback device.
Check the headphone connector, device connection and what’s included separately for the exact variant.
Depending on the connection, you may need a compatible replacement cable or adapter.
The wired SE215 is designed to provide passive isolation; the WF-1000XM5 offers electronic noise cancellation and an ambient sound mode. These features are not interchangeable.
First choose between a passive monitor and adjustable noise reduction. Then check the fit and controls, and pause playback for important announcements.
Bluetooth and ANC models need charging, which adds an extra step to using them.
The wired SE215 is an option if you’re looking for a passive monitor with a detachable cable and an output that suits your device.
The IE 100 PRO is wired; the IE 100 PRO Wireless is a separate variant with a Bluetooth module and standard cable.
The ER2SE is a wired monitor for buyers interested in a neutral sound profile and passive isolation.
The JD1 is a dynamic in-ear monitor, and its different connection variants should be considered separately.
The wired ATH-E40 is another option to consider when checking fit and connection for your everyday listening.
The WF-1000XM5 are not traditional wired in-ear monitors, but an alternative for listeners who want ANC and an ambient sound mode.
This selection features wireless in-ear headphones with active noise cancellation as an alternative to traditional in-ear monitors for listening on the go.
No image available
A wireless ANC alternative if you want to pause playback on the go using touch controls.
Product details list ear tips in three sizes and a rechargeable battery.
No image available
An ANC alternative if you want to adjust noise cancellation and pause playback on the go.
Product details list ear tips and stability bands in three sizes, along with a rechargeable charging case.
No image available
These wireless in-ear headphones are an ANC alternative for listening on the go.
The product description states up to 42 hours of total battery life with the charging case; wireless use requires charging.
No image available
A wireless ANC alternative if you want to switch between noise cancellation and hearing your surroundings.
Product details list hybrid ANC, a transparency mode and a charging case.
No image available
These wireless in-ear headphones offer an ANC alternative with a mode that lets you hear your surroundings.
Product details list touch controls for switching between ANC and ambient sound mode, as well as a charging case.
No, the monitor only plays the audio signal from the connected playback device. Check which device is receiving the broadcast and whether its output matches the plug or a suitable adapter.
Try the ear tip sizes supplied with your specific model until you find a comfortable, secure fit. Before travelling, check how to pause playback, and follow the model’s instructions for cleaning and changing the ear tips.
Deutsche Bahn says loud music, including through headphones, is not welcome in ICE quiet zones; this does not mean headphones are generally prohibited. Listen considerately and pause playback for important announcements or instructions.
Check the product identification and the relevant manufacturer documentation for the specific item on offer. The Federal Network Agency monitors products and checks, among other things, CE marking, manufacturer details, German-language instructions and the declaration of conformity. A model being named does not mean that the individual item for sale has been checked.
If a purchase is faulty, statutory legal guarantees from the seller are separate from a voluntary manufacturer’s warranty. According to consumer information from the European Union, goods bought from a retailer are generally covered by a statutory guarantee of at least two years from receipt; the specific circumstances of the purchase remain important.