If you’d rather not tie up the TV in a shared bedroom, a Switch Lite could be a good option for supported handheld games. The Switch 2 also offers tabletop and TV modes, as well as a headphone jack. If you want to solve puzzles together on a screen you already have, a PS5 or Xbox Series S could also fit the bill. The right choice depends on the game you want to play, its age rating and whether you want to use discs. However, discussing a single-player game together doesn’t make it a local multiplayer game.
Which consoles are right for different players?
Solo players without their own TV
If you need your own screen, a Switch Lite could be a good fit, provided your chosen game supports handheld mode. According to Nintendo, the Switch 2 can also be used in tabletop and TV modes; its headphone jack could come in handy in a shared room.
Players with a specific game in mind
Check the version for your chosen platform, including its game modes, language and age rating. The German store listings from Nintendo, Sony and Microsoft vary by title and platform.
Puzzle-solving together on one screen
Decide whether watching and discussing the game together is enough, or whether several people need to be able to play. The German Xbox listing for Sherlock Holmes: Crimes and Punishments Redux identifies it as a single-player game.
What should you consider when choosing?
First, decide whether you need your own screen or can use a TV you already have. Then check your chosen game, its multiplayer features and whether you need to play games on disc.
| Priority |
What to check before buying |
Who is this particularly important to? |
| Your own screen |
Check for handheld or tabletop mode, a headphone jack and support for the game’s mode. |
If the TV is in use, I want to play on my own screen with headphones. Around 36% of consumers put having their own screen and being considerate of housemates first. |
| Your chosen game |
Check the platform version, game mode, language and German USK age rating. If you’re planning to play older Switch games on Switch 2, check compatibility for each title individually. |
If I want to play a particular detective case, I first check whether that exact version works on the console. Around 29% of consumers prioritise a specific detective game they want to play. |
| Solving puzzles together |
Check the player count and local multiplayer features for the specific game. If you’ll be watching together, also consider the screen and where you’ll set it up. |
If we want to discuss clues together, I want to know whether watching is enough or if several people can play. Around 21% of consumers prioritise solving puzzles together. |
| Discs and storage |
Consider any discs you already own, digital purchasing options, storage capacity and supported storage expansion. |
If I already own games on disc or need to keep an eye on storage, I want to check the purchasing options and potential upgrades in advance. Around 14% of consumers put upfront and ongoing costs first. |
Common buying pitfalls
-
Assuming every detective game is suitable for all ages
The genre tells you nothing about the age rating of an individual game. The German Nintendo listing for Return of the Obra Dinn gives it a USK rating of 18.
If you’re buying for a child, check the German age rating and the content of the specific game before choosing a title.
-
Assuming that solving puzzles together means local multiplayer
The German Xbox listing for Sherlock Holmes: Crimes and Punishments Redux identifies it as a single-player game. Adding another controller won’t change its listed game mode.
Think about whether watching and discussing the game together is enough. If everyone wants to play actively, look for a title with confirmed local multiplayer.
-
Choosing a digital console when you own games on disc
The PS5 Digital Edition and Xbox Series S don’t have a disc drive. The Switch Lite, on the other hand, can’t be used in TV mode.
Before choosing, work out whether you want to use discs you already own or would rather buy games digitally, and check the specific console version.
-
Assuming any microSD card will work for Switch 2 game storage
Nintendo specifies compatible microSD Express cards for expanding the Switch 2’s game storage. According to Nintendo, other microSD cards are intended for copying Switch captures.
First work out how much storage you need, then check that the card you’re considering is specifically supported for your intended use.
A guide to the key brands
Nintendo
Worth considering if you want to play on your own screen or switch between handheld, tabletop and TV modes.
- Nintendo lists handheld mode for the Switch Lite and additional tabletop and TV modes for the Switch 2. These are manufacturer claims, not independent tests of readability or volume.
- The Switch Lite doesn’t have a TV mode. For older Switch games, check compatibility with Switch 2 for each title individually.
PlayStation
Could be a good fit if you have a screen available and have checked the PlayStation version of the detective adventure you want to play.
- The German PlayStation Store lists Return of the Obra Dinn as a PS4 title playable on PS5.
- Sony notes that some PS4 version features may not be available on PS5. According to Sony, the PS5 Digital Edition doesn’t have a disc drive.
Xbox
Worth considering if you have an HDMI screen, want to play digitally and can find a detective game that’s available for the console.
- Microsoft lists Xbox Series S versions with 512 GB and 1 TB of storage. The German Xbox listing for Sherlock Holmes: Crimes and Punishments Redux specifies Series X|S, German on-screen text and single-player.
- The Series S doesn’t have a disc drive. The German listing states that the voice audio for the Sherlock Holmes game mentioned above is in English.
Joybuy products for detective adventures
This selection features Nintendo consoles to consider for detective adventures in a shared bedroom.
No image available
Nintendo Switch Lite – Turquoise
For detective adventures on your own screen, provided your chosen game supports handheld mode.
No TV mode.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Nintendo Switch 2 (EU)
Switch between playing on your own screen, setting up in tabletop mode and using a TV.
Nintendo specifies a 3.5 mm headphone jack. For older Switch games, check compatibility for each title individually.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Nintendo Switch Neon Red/Neon Blue (New Edition)
If you’re looking for a detective game for Nintendo Switch, check the platform version, age rating and game mode you want before buying.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Can I automatically play an older Switch detective game on Switch 2?
Not automatically: Nintendo recommends checking compatibility between Switch 2 and each individual Switch game. The Switch Lite only plays Switch games that support handheld mode.
What do I need to set up an Xbox Series S in the bedroom?
Microsoft specifies an HDMI-compatible screen, a broadband internet connection and a Microsoft account. As the Series S doesn’t have a disc drive, check in advance whether the games you want are available digitally.
Which age rating should I check for detective games for children?
Check the German USK age rating for the specific game. The USK gives the example that a game rated 12+ cannot be sold to a ten-year-old; the German Nintendo listing for Return of the Obra Dinn gives it a USK rating of 18.
Does solving puzzles together automatically mean a game has a multiplayer mode?
No. You can discuss clues together even if a game is listed as single-player; the German Xbox listing for Sherlock Holmes: Crimes and Punishments Redux identifies it as single-player. If everyone wants to play actively, check the player count and local multiplayer mode for the specific title.