First, check whether the specific detective games you want are available for the console and version you’re considering. Only then decide between a home console and the flexibility of handheld play. PlayStation and Xbox are options for a fixed screen, while Nintendo Switch 2 lets you switch between handheld and monitor play. With Steam Deck, check compatibility for every Steam game you’re interested in; for PlayStation and Xbox, you’ll also need to consider the disc drive and exact model variant.
Who are these console options for?
Players with a specific game in mind
If you’ve already got a particular Sherlock Holmes, Ace Attorney or other detective game in mind, check the platform and version first. The PlayStation Store Germany, Xbox Germany and Nintendo Germany list specific detective games for their respective platforms.
Desk-based players
If you’ll mainly be playing on your existing monitor, compare home consoles from PlayStation and Xbox with the connection options for a Switch 2 or Steam Deck.
Players who like solving puzzles on the go
If you want to play away from your desk too, the Switch 2 and Steam Deck are portable options to consider. Nintendo notes that some original Switch games may have compatibility limitations, while Valve provides a compatibility rating for each Steam Deck title.
What should you consider when choosing?
Start with the specific games you want, then compare screen and handheld use, along with disc drive and connection requirements.
| Purchase priority |
What to look for when buying |
Who is this important for? |
| Game compatibility |
Check the platform and version for each game you want; for original Switch games, also check compatibility with Switch 2. |
If I want to play a particular detective game, I need to be sure I choose the right version for my console. Around 33% of consumers put compatibility with the game they want first. |
| Monitor connection |
Check that your monitor’s video input matches the console and the dock or connection solution you’ll need. |
If I want to play on my home-office monitor, the connection needs to work with my existing setup. Around 27% of consumers say a desk connection is their main purchase priority. |
| Playing on the go |
Think about whether you’ll regularly switch between desk and handheld play, and check compatibility for the games you prefer. |
If I want to carry on playing away from my desk, being able to switch between handheld and monitor play matters to me. Around 20% of consumers say portability is their main priority. |
| Game format and accessories |
Check the exact model variant, whether it has a disc drive and whether you’ll need a monitor connection solution. |
If I own games on disc or need to budget for accessories, I want to know what I can keep using before I buy. Around 20% of consumers give the most weight to game format and possible extra purchases. |
Avoid common buying mistakes
-
Choosing the console before checking the game you want
Game versions are tied to specific platforms. Compatibility with Switch 2 may be limited for some original Switch games.
Make a list of the games you want first, then check the specific platform version for each one and, where relevant, its compatibility status on Switch 2.
-
Assuming every “PS5” or “Series X” has a disc drive
Sony’s PS5 Digital Edition does not have a disc drive. Microsoft offers the digital, disc-free Xbox Series S, as well as disc-drive and all-digital versions of the Series X.
Check the full model name and make sure it works with any game discs you already own.
-
Assuming handheld and monitor play work the same without checking connections
Nintendo says you can play Switch 2 on a monitor using the dock. Valve offers a dock as a connection option for Steam Deck.
Before buying, check which connection your monitor needs and whether your planned console and accessories will work with it.
Console platforms to consider
Sony PlayStation
Home PS5 consoles for games available on the PlayStation Store in the version for the platform you’re using.
- The PlayStation Store Germany lists Sherlock Holmes Chapter One and Return of the Obra Dinn for PlayStation.
- Sony offers the PS5 Digital Edition without a disc drive. Check the model and game version separately.
Microsoft Xbox
Home Series X and Series S consoles for detective games listed as compatible with Xbox Series X|S.
- Xbox Germany lists Sherlock Holmes Chapter One for Series X|S.
- The Series S has no disc drive. The Series X comes in disc-drive and all-digital versions, so check the full model name.
Nintendo
According to Nintendo, Switch 2 lets you switch between handheld play and monitor play using the dock.
- The German Nintendo catalogue includes Switch games such as Ace Attorney Investigations Collection and Detective Pikachu Returns.
- Nintendo notes that some original Switch games may not be compatible with Switch 2, or may only work with limitations.
Valve
Steam Deck is a portable gaming PC for titles available on Steam that suit the way you plan to play.
- Valve offers compatibility ratings for individual titles and a docking station.
- Valve notes that some games may not play as well on Steam Deck as they do on a desktop PC. This is not a blanket rating of individual detective games.
Joybuy products
Joybuy console picks for detective games, with monitor play at your desk and the option to play on the go.
No image available
Nintendo Switch 2 console (EU)
An option if you want to switch between playing on a monitor at your desk and handheld gaming.
For original Switch games, check the compatibility status of each one. Nintendo notes that some titles may not be supported, or may only be supported with limitations.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Can I use Switch 2 with my home-office monitor?
Yes. Nintendo explains how to connect the Switch 2 dock to a TV or monitor for TV Mode. Check that your specific monitor works with the connection you plan to use.
Will my existing Switch detective games automatically work on Switch 2?
No, that’s not guaranteed for every game. Nintendo notes that some original Switch titles may not be fully compatible, or may not work at all. Check the status of each game you want to play.
Do I need a gaming subscription to play detective adventures?
You can’t tell from the genre alone. Check the relevant store page for each game to find out how it’s sold, whether online features are required and whether any subscription conditions apply.
How should I look after a console at my desk?
Follow the guidance for the exact model you’ve bought when it comes to positioning, cleaning and ventilation.