Which option is right for you?

Photographers who want camera RAW files

If you want to photograph old 35 mm portraits with your camera and invert the negatives yourself, check your macro lens, holder and light source. Nikon specifies JPEG rather than camera RAW for the D850’s automatic negative digitisation.

People looking to preserve damaged family negatives

If your negatives have dust, scratches or colour casts, you’ll need a suitable correction workflow and the option to retouch them manually. SilverFast explains that infrared retouching is limited with conventional silver-based black-and-white film because of its silver layer.

Owners of mixed film archives

If your collection includes 120 film as well as 35 mm, or strips of varying lengths, make sure the holder is compatible with the film format. VALOI specifies a universal 120 holder for the easy120; standard 35 mm film has its own holder requirements.

What should you look for when buying?

Camera digitisation

A good fit if: you want to photograph negatives with a suitable camera and macro lens, then invert them yourself.

The trade-off: the holder and light source must suit your camera and film format; colour inversion and correction are still part of the editing process.

Computer-connected film scanner

A good fit if: a scanner file format meets your needs and you want to scan suitable 35 mm strips.

The trade-off: scanner DNG and camera RAW are different file types; you’ll also need to consider retouching and software.

Flatbed scanner with transparency unit

A good fit if: you may need to scan other film formats and TIFF files will work for you instead of camera RAW.

The trade-off: Epson lists the V600 Photo and V850 Pro models as discontinued.

Priority What to check before buying Who is this especially important to?
Camera RAW rather than scanner raw data Check whether your camera actually saves the negative capture as RAW, or whether automatic inversion produces a JPEG instead. Nikon documents JPEG output for the D850’s automatic negative digitisation. If I want to edit the negatives later in my camera’s RAW format, it matters which device captures the file. Around 36% of consumers put camera RAW first.
Portrait detail and retouching Distinguish between colour negatives and silver-based black-and-white film, and allow for colour inversion, cleaning and any necessary corrections. SilverFast says infrared retouching is limited with conventional silver-based black-and-white film. If recognisable faces and correcting dust or scratches matter more to me than speed, I look for a suitable editing workflow. Around 29% of consumers prioritise preservation and retouching.
Film format and holder Check whether you have 35 mm or 120 film, and make sure short strips are compatible with the specific holder. VALOI specifies a minimum length of 160 mm, or four standard frames, for the easy120 standard 35 mm holder. If my archive contains different formats or short strips, the holder must suit the negatives I actually have. Around 21% of consumers put format compatibility first.
Handling lots of strips Compare the manufacturer’s stated capacity per pass and check that your strips are suitable for the feed mechanism. reflecta specifies 3 to 40 frames per film strip for the RPS 10S; Plustek specifies up to six strip frames per pass for the OpticFilm 135i. If I want to digitise lots of suitable strips, what matters to me is how often I’ll need to reload and check them. Around 14% of consumers prioritise throughput.

Which buying mistakes can you avoid?

  • Assuming scanner DNG is the same as camera RAW

    The label “RAW” alone doesn’t tell you which device created the file. reflecta specifies DNG output from the scanner for the RPS 10S; Nikon’s automatic negative digitisation on the D850 saves JPEG files.

    Before buying, decide whether you want an unprocessed capture from your camera or raw data from a scanner.

  • Choosing a holder based on film format alone

    According to the manufacturer, the VALOI holder for standard 35 mm film on the easy120 is not suitable for strips shorter than 160 mm, or four standard frames.

    Measure your shortest strips in particular and check which holder is actually compatible with your chosen system.

  • Expecting infrared dust removal to work on every black-and-white negative

    With conventional silver-based black-and-white film, the silver layer can interfere with the detection needed for infrared retouching. SilverFast describes this limitation with its infrared technology.

    Identify the film stock and, if necessary, plan for cleaning and manual or suitable software-based corrections.

Key brands at a glance

VALOI

Camera digitisation with holders for different film formats.

  • VALOI describes the easy35 v2 as suitable for 35 mm film and smaller formats, with an integrated light source; the system attaches to a macro lens.
  • A universal 120 holder is specified for the easy120. Standard 35 mm film requires a separate holder, which the manufacturer says is unsuitable for short strips under 160 mm.

Nikon

The ES-2 is a film digitising adapter for a compatible Nikon camera and macro lens.

  • Nikon lists specific compatible lenses for the ES-2.
  • For the D850’s automatic negative digitisation, Nikon documents positive JPEG files rather than camera RAW.

reflecta

Computer-connected 35 mm film scanners, including the RPS 10S for suitable longer film strips.

  • reflecta specifies automatic feeding for film strips with 3 to 40 frames, infrared retouching and DNG output for the RPS 10S.
  • The DNG comes from the scanner; it is not a RAW file from your own camera. The stated scanning area is designed for 35 mm film.

Plustek

Computer-connected scanners for 35 mm strips and slides.

  • Plustek specifies up to six strip frames or four slides per pass for the OpticFilm 135i.
  • The manufacturer describes a scanner-based workflow; this is not the same as camera RAW.

Epson

Flatbed scanners with transparency units offer an alternative for film formats and scanner files.

  • Epson specifies support for 120/220 film and TIFF output for the Perfection V600 Photo and V850 Pro.
  • Epson lists both models as discontinued.

Joybuy products

Suitable products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

Does Nikon’s automatic negative digitisation produce camera RAW?

No. Nikon documents positive JPEG files for the D850’s automatic negative digitisation, regardless of the image quality selected. If you want camera RAW, look into a capture and inversion workflow outside this automatic function.

What do I need to set up and check on the film before my first capture?

Check that your holder and macro lens are compatible, and set up a suitable light source. Nikon also describes how to prepare the film for the ES-2; check focus and the edges of the frame using a test negative.

Does infrared retouching remove dust from old black-and-white portraits too?

It cannot be used reliably with conventional silver-based black-and-white film. According to SilverFast, the silver layer interferes with the infrared detection this technique needs, so cleaning and, where necessary, software-based retouching remain important.

Who should I contact if my device is faulty?

For consumer purchases in Germany, you have statutory rights against the seller. These are separate from any voluntary guarantee. The Verbraucherzentrale describes repair or replacement as the first remedies available if a product is faulty.

Can I digitise old portrait negatives for personal use and then publish the images?

Digitising an image for personal use does not automatically give you permission to publish it. Under the conditions set out in § 53 UrhG, individual copies may be made for private, non-commercial use; for distributing or publicly displaying a portrait, § 22 KunstUrhG generally requires the consent of the person depicted. Whether a particular portrait may be published depends on the circumstances and any other rights involved.