Which scanning option is right for you?

Frequent file transferers

You scan colour negatives regularly and want to transfer the files to a computer quickly afterwards. Whether saving directly to your computer or using an SD card and importing the files later works better depends on whether you want your computer available while scanning. reflecta describes the x44-Scan as offering SD storage and USB transfer.

35 mm photographers who edit their scans

You want to view and edit 35 mm colour negatives on your computer. Suitable software and supported file formats are key here; Plustek lists software for Mac and Windows for the OpticFilm 8300i SE. The Library of Congress recommends TIFF and image data that has not been upscaled as desirable properties for digital photographs.

Owners of negatives in different formats

You may have negatives in several formats. Check the list of supported formats and the supplied holders against your collection: the Plustek OpticFilm 8300i SE is described as supporting 35 mm film, while Epson lists holders for 35 mm and 120/220 film for the Perfection V600 Photo. Epson Germany states that this model is no longer available.

What should you look for when choosing?

First decide whether you want files created directly on your computer or imported from a memory card after scanning. Then check that the formats, holders and file types you need are suitable for your collection.

Computer-connected scanner

A good fit if: you want to work at your computer while scanning and add the files to your existing editing and filing workflow.

Bear in mind: your computer, operating system and software must be compatible with the specific model.

Stand-alone scanner with memory card

A good fit if: you want to scan negatives without your computer running and then transfer the files using a memory card or USB.

Bear in mind: you’ll need to import the files to your computer for filing later. Also check that the scanner supports your preferred file format.

Buying criterion What to look for Who it matters most to
File transfer Check the storage destination and transfer method: SD card, USB or direct saving to a computer. Also check the output format. If I want to file my scans quickly after each session, I want the transfer method to fit my computer setup as closely as possible. Around 36% of consumers put file transfer first.
Suitable negative format Check the film format, strip length and compatible or supplied holders against your collection. With a mixed collection, I want to be sure my negatives will fit the holders provided. Around 29% of consumers prioritise format compatibility.
Editable files Check the output format supported by the specific scanner and software combination, and distinguish sensor or optical resolution from interpolated figures. If I want to adjust colours or tones later, I look first at the file format and the image detail actually captured. Around 21% of consumers prioritise editability.
Film strip throughput Check that automatic feed and supported strip lengths suit your collection, and find out how many frames can be scanned per load. If I regularly scan lots of compatible strips, I want to reload less often. Around 14% of consumers consider throughput their top priority.

Which common mistakes can you avoid?

  • Assuming a USB connection means files save directly to your computer

    According to the manufacturer, the reflecta x44-Scan saves images as JPEGs to an SD card; USB is also listed as a transfer method. A USB port alone does not mean that scans are saved directly to your computer.

    For the exact model, check the storage destination, transfer method, output format and what’s included in the box.

    Importing and checking the files afterwards takes extra time; depending on what’s included, you may also need a memory card.

  • Mistaking interpolated pixels for extra image detail

    For the DF-S 1300 SE, Rollei distinguishes between a 13-megapixel sensor resolution and upscaling to 25 megapixels. The higher output pixel count does not mean the sensor has a correspondingly higher resolution.

    Compare sensor or optical resolution separately from interpolated output figures.

  • Buying a scanner without checking your negative format

    The OpticFilm 8300i SE is described as supporting 35 mm film. Epson also lists holders for 120/220 film for the Perfection V600 Photo, but states that the model is no longer available in Germany.

    Sort your negatives by format and check them against the holders supplied with the specific model.

    Depending on your negative format, you may need suitable additional holders or a different device.

Which brands and models are worth considering?

reflecta

The models listed here offer two ways to scan 35 mm film: the x44-Scan saves files to an SD card without a computer, while the RPS 10S is designed for computer-connected film transport.

  • reflecta lists JPEG storage on an SD card and USB transfer for the x44-Scan.
  • For the RPS 10S, reflecta specifies automatic transport for film strips containing 3 to 40 frames.
  • Using the x44-Scan’s memory card requires you to import the files afterwards; the RPS 10S needs a computer and compatible strip lengths.

Plustek

The OpticFilm 8300i SE is a computer-connected 35 mm scanner supplied with compatible software.

  • For the OpticFilm 8300i SE, Plustek lists SilverFast SE Plus 9 and QuickScan Plus, as well as compatibility with Mac and Windows.
  • A review of the OpticFilm 135i does not apply to the OpticFilm 8300i SE. F.A.Z. Kaufkompass says the 135i can scan up to six frames from a film strip per pass and supports 135-format film only.

Rollei

The DF-S 1300 SE offers a stand-alone workflow with a display and memory card slot.

  • Rollei lists transfer by memory card or direct connection to a PC for the DF-S 1300 SE.
  • Rollei distinguishes the 13-megapixel sensor resolution from upscaling to 25 megapixels; the upscaled figure does not represent additional sensor resolution.

Epson

The Perfection V600 Photo illustrates a flatbed workflow for different types of originals, but it should not be taken as an indication that a new model is currently available.

  • Epson lists film holders for 35 mm and 120/220 film, as well as TIFF output.
  • Epson Germany states that the Perfection V600 Photo is no longer available.

Suitable products on Joybuy

Similar products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

Does your computer need to be switched on while you scan?

It depends on the model. reflecta describes the x44-Scan as working without a computer: it saves JPEG files to an SD card, which can then be transferred via USB. The RPS 10S is part of reflecta’s computer-connected range.

What should you do with your files after each scanning session?

Transfer and check the new files before using the storage medium again. If you want to edit colours or tones several times later, check whether the software for your specific scanner can output TIFF files. The Library of Congress recommends TIFF and image data that has not been upscaled as desirable properties for digital photographs.

What should you do if your scanner develops a fault after purchase?

Germany’s consumer advice centre distinguishes between your statutory rights against the seller and a voluntary guarantee from the manufacturer or retailer. Check the terms of any guarantee offered separately from your statutory rights.

Can you put an old scanner in your household rubbish?

No. The German Environment Agency explains that old electrical equipment must be collected separately from unsorted municipal waste. Use a suitable local collection point or a retailer take-back scheme.