Which digitising method is right for you?

Camera RAW enthusiasts

If you already own a suitable camera and want to keep your negative capture as a camera file for editing later, check the macro lens, holder and method of converting negatives. Nikon Germany explains the differences between camera RAW and processed files, while VALOI describes a camera-based setup for 35mm and smaller formats.

35mm film archivists

If you want to digitise lots of 35mm strips without setting up a camera, transport, holder capacity and software are important factors to consider. reflecta documents automatic film transport on the RPS 10S, while Plustek says the OpticFilm 135i Ai can handle several frames per holder pass.

Collectors with mixed film formats

If you want to scan medium-format negatives as well as 35mm film, check which formats are supported and which holders are actually included. Epson lists support for 120/220 medium format as well as 35mm film for the V850 Pro; according to Epson Germany, this model is no longer available.

Key buying considerations: camera RAW or film scanner?

Camera with film holder

A good fit if: You have a suitable camera that can shoot in RAW and a compatible macro lens, or want to use this kind of setup.

Keep in mind: The camera, lens, holder and lighting all need to work together. According to Nikon, the automatic negative conversion on the D850 and D780 is saved as a JPEG.

Dedicated 35mm film scanner

A good fit if: You want to scan without photographing the film, or process compatible 35mm strips using automatic transport.

Keep in mind: The reflecta RPS 10S’s DNG is a scanner raw format, not a RAW capture from your camera. Its documented scan area is designed for 35mm film.

Flatbed scanner with transparency unit

A good fit if: You want to scan medium-format negatives as well as 35mm film using a suitable scanner and compatible holders.

Keep in mind: Epson lists the V600 Photo and V850 Pro as no longer available in Germany, so you’ll need to assess any specific offer and its included holders separately.

Buying priority What to check before buying Who it matters to
Camera RAW Check that the camera’s capture format, macro lens and holder work together; don’t confuse automatic JPEG conversion with camera RAW. If I want to keep a camera file as my starting point and edit the positive image later, the right camera setup is essential. Around 36% of consumers prioritise a genuine camera RAW capture.
Colour negative workflow Check the conversion software and any dust correction options, and consider the scanner’s specific output format. If I need to turn colour negatives into positive images and account for dust removal, the entire editing workflow matters. Around 29% of consumers prioritise colour negative conversion and dust treatment.
Throughput Compare the transport method and the number of compatible frames per strip or holder. If I have lots of 35mm strips to scan, I want to minimise manual changes and use a suitable transport system. Around 21% of consumers put throughput first.
Film formats Check the supported formats and the holders actually included with each device. If I want to scan formats beyond 35mm, I need suitable holders and a device designed for them. Around 14% of consumers prioritise format versatility.

Common mistakes when digitising colour negatives

  • Confusing scanner DNG with camera RAW

    A scanner raw format, such as the DNG from the reflecta RPS 10S, is created during scanning. It isn’t a RAW capture from your digital camera.

    Before looking for a device, decide whether the original file must come from your camera.

    If you specifically need a camera file, you may also need a suitable camera setup or an extra editing step.

  • Buying a holder without checking your lens and film format

    The Nikon ES-2 is designed for use with specific lenses, and a 35mm holder won’t automatically work with medium format.

    Check the exact lens model and each of your film formats against the details for the specific kit.

    If you don’t have a compatible macro lens or suitable holder, you may need a different setup or extra accessories.

  • Assuming an older Epson model is available new

    Epson lists the Perfection V600 Photo and V850 Pro as no longer available on its German product pages.

    Use the documented features for comparison, and check the condition and included holders separately if you find a specific second-hand or clearance offer.

Key brands and what they’re best for

VALOI

VALOI describes the easy35 v2 as a camera-based film holder with an integrated light source for 35mm and smaller formats.

  • Designed for use with a suitable camera and macro lens.
  • The system itself doesn’t create a camera RAW file; the result also depends on your camera, lens and settings.

Nikon

The ES-2 is a film digitising adapter for 35mm film and specific Nikon macro lenses.

  • Nikon documents film and slide holders for the adapter.
  • Not every Nikon macro lens is compatible. According to Nikon, the D850 and D780 save automatic negative conversion as a JPEG; with other listed cameras, you may need to convert negatives manually in image-editing software.

reflecta

The RPS 10S is a dedicated 35mm film scanner with automatic strip transport.

  • reflecta specifies transport for strips of 3 to 40 frames and DNG raw output.
  • DNG is a scanner file, not a RAW capture from a digital camera; the documented scan area is limited to 35mm film.

Plustek

The OpticFilm 135i Ai is a computer-connected 35mm film scanner supplied with SilverFast Ai Studio software.

  • Plustek lists holders for six frames of film or four slides per pass.
  • The scanner doesn’t create a camera RAW capture. A F.A.Z. review of the OpticFilm 135i found the batch size limiting when scanning larger quantities; this was not a test of the 135i Ai model.

Epson

Epson documents transparency units and film holders for various formats with the Perfection V600 Photo and V850 Pro.

  • For the V850 Pro, Epson lists holders for 35mm film and 120/220 medium format, among others.
  • Epson Germany lists both models as no longer available; their documented standard output formats are not camera RAW captures.

Recommended products on Joybuy

Recommended products coming soon.

Questions about digitising colour negatives

Is scanner DNG the same as my camera’s RAW file?

No. reflecta describes the RPS 10S’s DNG output as a scanner raw format. A camera RAW file is created when you take a picture with a digital camera set up accordingly. Nikon explains that camera RAW contains data captured by the camera sensor. So check which type of original file you want to keep.

Can I automatically convert negatives with the Nikon ES-2 and save the converted image as camera RAW?

According to Nikon, automatic negative conversion on the Nikon D850 and D780 outputs a JPEG. If keeping the original RAW capture matters to you, treat recording it and converting the negative later in software as separate steps, and check your camera settings.

What should I consider when setting up and editing later?

First, check that your film format, holder, lens and camera are compatible. Keep the original file separate from edited exports if you may want to make changes later. Hamrick Software says VueScan can reprocess scanner raw files without scanning the film again.

What extra costs and service considerations should I check before buying?

Compare the cost of the complete setup you need: an existing camera and macro lens, compatible holders, lighting and any required software. If you’re buying a second-hand flatbed scanner, also check which film holders are included and whether suitable software and drivers are available. Epson lists the V600 Photo and V850 Pro as no longer available in Germany.

Can I digitise someone else’s colour negatives for my own use and then publish the scans?

Under the conditions set out in § 53(1) of the German Copyright Act (UrhG), individuals may make certain copies of a protected work for private, non-commercial use. This does not grant general permission to publish them: § 53(6) excludes the distribution and public communication of such copies. The Federal Ministry of Justice and the Federal Office of Justice publish the text of the law. If the photographs belong to someone else and you plan to publish them, you should check the relevant rights separately.