Who’s facing which decision?

Camera RAW editors

You want to photograph portrait negatives with your digital camera and keep native RAW files for editing later. The key things to consider are a compatible camera, a suitable macro lens and a film holder that fits. Nikon explains where camera RAW comes from, while VALOI and Nikon describe suitable digitising setups.

35 mm film archivists

You have lots of 35 mm portrait negatives and want to find out whether a strip or batch workflow can reduce the need to load each frame individually. reflecta and Plustek offer different workflows for 35 mm originals.

People with mixed film formats

Before choosing a device, you need to find out whether your portraits are on 35 mm, 110, 126 or 120 film, for example, and which holder you’ll need. VALOI and KODAK Photo Plus list the formats supported by specific systems.

What to consider when buying

First, decide what type of raw file you need. Then check your film format, how much you need to scan and how you’ll deal with dust and scratches.

Buying criteria What to check Who it matters most to
Type of raw file Check the output format for the specific model and software. reflecta describes the RPS 10S output as scanner DNG; Nikon defines camera RAW as data from the camera sensor. If I want to re-edit my portraits later, I need the right raw file format, not just a similar-sounding file name. Around 36% of consumers put the ability to re-edit a raw file first.
Film format and holder Identify the film type and frame size, then check the specific holder. VALOI lists 35 mm and smaller formats; KODAK Photo Plus lists adapters for 135, 110 and 126. Before choosing a device, I want to know whether my negatives will actually fit the holder it’s designed for. Around 29% of consumers prioritise format compatibility.
Volume and workload Compare the supported strip length and batch size. For the RPS 10S, reflecta lists suitable 35 mm film strips with 3 to 40 frames; Plustek lists six frames on a strip or four mounted slides per pass for the OpticFilm 135i. If I have lots of suitable strips to scan, I want to know how often I’ll need to reload them. Around 21% of consumers put throughput first.
Dust, scratches and retouching Check the film type before relying on infrared dust removal. According to VueScan, it doesn’t work with traditional silver-based black and white film. With old or damaged originals, I want to plan realistically for cleaning and retouching. Around 14% of consumers prioritise how well a system deals with image defects like these.

Common pitfalls when digitising

  • Assuming scanner raw files are the same as camera RAW

    These file formats come from different ways of capturing an image. Scanner DNG or TIFF isn’t a native RAW file from your digital camera. reflecta describes DNG output for the RPS 10S, Nikon explains that camera RAW contains sensor data, and Hamrick Software documents unprocessed scanner TIFF.

    Before you buy, decide what kind of file you need and how you want to edit it later. Check the output format for the specific model and software package.

  • Assuming “negative scanner” tells you which film format it supports

    A device for 35 mm film won’t automatically support other formats. Even systems with several format options need the right holder.

    Identify the film type and frame size of your originals, then check whether the holder you need is included with the specific offer or must be bought separately.

  • Assuming infrared dust removal works with every type of black and white film

    According to VueScan, infrared dust removal doesn’t work with traditional silver-based black and white film.

    Identify the film type before giving this feature too much weight in your decision, and factor in cleaning and manual retouching if needed.

  • Confusing interpolated megapixels with sensor resolution

    For the Slide N Scan, KODAK Photo Plus lists a 14 MP sensor and an interpolated output of 22 MP. These figures refer to different things.

    Compare the native sensor specification with the output workflow you want, rather than focusing only on the highest MP figure.

Relevant brands and product ranges

reflecta

The RPS 10S is a computer-connected scanner for compatible 35 mm film strips.

  • reflecta lists DNG output, infrared retouching and automatic transport for suitable strips with 3 to 40 frames.
  • The stated scan area applies to this specific 35 mm model; DNG isn’t a native RAW file from a digital camera.

VALOI

The easy35 v2 is a film holder and light system used with a separate camera and macro lens.

  • The manufacturer lists built-in lighting and a standard holder for 35 mm film.
  • Check that your camera, suitable lens and holder are compatible with your film format.

Nikon

The ES-2 is designed to digitise film originals with certain Nikon camera and lens combinations.

  • Nikon describes an automatic negative digitising function for the D850 and D780.
  • According to Nikon, this function saves JPEG files; it shouldn’t be taken as a guarantee of native camera RAW output. Check compatibility for the specific combination.

Plustek

The OpticFilm 135i is designed for 35 mm negatives and smaller batches.

  • Plustek lists six frames on a strip or four mounted slides per pass, as well as an infrared channel.
  • With larger archives, the batch size means you’ll need to reload more often. According to VueScan, infrared dust removal doesn’t work with traditional silver-based black and white film.

KODAK Photo Plus

The Slide N Scan is a standalone system for viewing and saving film originals.

  • KODAK Photo Plus lists a display, SD storage and adapters for 135, 110 and 126 film.
  • For this specific model, the manufacturer lists a 14 MP sensor and 22 MP through interpolation.

Joybuy products

Suitable products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Will a film scanner give me the same RAW file as my digital camera?

No. reflecta describes the RPS 10S output as the scanner’s DNG raw file format; Nikon defines camera RAW as data from the camera sensor. If you need native camera RAW files, check that you can photograph your negatives with a compatible camera, suitable lens and film holder.

Does the Nikon ES-2 automatically invert colour negatives and save them as RAW files?

For the automatic negative digitising function on the D850 and D780, Nikon describes the saved files as JPEGs. The ES-2 is an adapter, so check the camera, lens and capture and editing workflow you want separately.

Does infrared dust removal help with old black and white portraits?

Not with traditional silver-based black and white film, as the VueScan manual explains. First check the film type, and allow for cleaning and manual retouching if necessary.

What equipment and software should I check before buying?

For a camera setup, check that the camera, macro lens, lighting and holder are suitable for your originals. For a PC-connected scanner, important things to check include the specific output format, software package and support for your operating system.

Can I digitise old portrait negatives for personal use and publish the images?

Under certain conditions, § 53 UrhG allows individuals to make single copies for private use, provided they are not made directly or indirectly for commercial purposes. This does not amount to general permission to publish. In principle, § 22 KunstUrhG requires the consent of the person pictured before an image is distributed or shown publicly; § 23 sets out exceptions and a restriction to protect legitimate interests. Whether a particular image can be used depends on the circumstances.