Which scanner is right for you?

Collectors with limited PC storage

You want to scan compatible slides onto a memory card first, then back up the files separately later. reflecta says the x22-Scan saves JPEG files directly to an SD card, while the German consumer advice centre recommends backing up photos too.

Owners of mixed film formats

If you have negatives or film formats in addition to 35mm slides, the supported formats and compatible holders will determine your choice. Kodak Photo Plus describes the EU version of the SLIDE N SCAN as compatible with the listed 135, 110 and 126 formats; reflecta lists additional film formats for the x66-Scan.

Owners of full slide magazines

If you want to scan a large number of slides that are already sorted, with less need to load them individually, check that your magazines are compatible and that a computer-based workflow is possible. reflecta lists CS, Universal, LKM and Paximat magazines among those supported by the computer-connected DigitDia 8000.

What should you look for when buying?

Standalone SD card scanner

Suitable if: You want to scan compatible slides without saving them straight to your computer’s hard drive. reflecta says the x22-Scan saves JPEG files directly to an SD card.

Keep in mind: The card format and capacity depend on the model, and a memory card is not a separate backup.

PC-connected scanner

Suitable if: You want to edit compatible 35mm originals on your computer and can provide a suitable storage location. The F.A.Z. Kaufkompass highlights the software and scan quality of the Plustek OpticFilm 135i.

Keep in mind: A PC-based workflow won’t solve limited storage by itself. In testing, the OpticFilm 135i was limited to four mounted slides or six film-strip frames per pass.

Magazine scanner

Suitable if: You have lots of slides in compatible magazines and can organise a computer-based workflow. reflecta lists several supported magazine types for the DigitDia 8000.

Keep in mind: A magazine feed doesn’t mean the scanner saves to an SD card. Check that your magazines are compatible and decide where the files will be stored before you buy.

Buying priority What to check Who it matters most to
Storage and backup Check the card format, maximum capacity and what’s included. For the EU version of the Kodak SLIDE N SCAN described here, Kodak Photo Plus specifies SD/SDHC cards up to 32 GB; the card is not included. If there’s hardly any space on my computer’s hard drive, I want to save scans to SD first and back them up separately later. Consumers prioritising storage and backup are estimated to make up 36% of buyers.
Film formats and holders Sort your originals by film type and frame thickness, then check them against the scan area and the holders supplied. reflecta says the x22-Scan holders accommodate mounted slides up to 3.2 mm thick. If my collection includes different negatives, slides or frames, I need to check that each format will fit. Consumers prioritising format and holder compatibility make up around 29% of buyers.
Handling large numbers of slides Check the capacity per pass and, for magazine scanners, which magazine types are supported. The F.A.Z. Kaufkompass says the tested Plustek OpticFilm 135i can scan a maximum of four mounted slides per pass. With a large collection, I want to reload as rarely as possible and keep using my existing magazines. Consumers prioritising throughput make up around 21% of buyers.
Image checking and editing Check the output format, software and storage space needed for edited files. reflecta describes the x66-Scan’s 22 MP output as interpolated, compared with its 14 MP sensor. If I want to check my scans and make adjustments later, suitable software and an available storage location are important. Consumers prioritising editing make up around 14% of buyers.

Common buying and scanning mistakes

  • Using the memory card as your only archive

    A single card is not a separate backup of your digitised photos.

    Before scanning, choose a second, separate storage location for the finished files.

    You’ll need suitable additional storage for a second copy.

  • Assuming every slide scanner works with every format and frame

    Film formats and frame thicknesses vary. reflecta says the holders for mounted slides in the x22-Scan can accommodate frames up to 3.2 mm thick.

    Sort out some typical originals and check them against the scan area and holders for the specific model.

    If your originals don’t fit, you may need additional holders or a different scanner.

  • Assuming interpolated resolution captures more image detail

    According to the manufacturer, the reflecta x66-Scan’s 22 MP output is interpolated; it is not the same as the stated 14 MP sensor resolution.

    Compare the sensor specification and output format separately, and look at suitable scan samples.

  • Confusing a short scan time with quickly finishing your whole collection

    Even with automatic processing, limited batches or frequent reloading can make the overall process take longer. The F.A.Z. Kaufkompass says the tested Plustek OpticFilm 135i can scan a maximum of four mounted slides per pass; a magazine scanner also requires compatible magazines.

    Compare the full process with your slides and magazines, and allow time for reloading and organising the files.

    Repeatedly loading, reloading and sorting can take extra time.

Key brands at a glance

reflecta

The models listed here suit different workflows: the x22-Scan saves to SD, the x66-Scan is described as supporting additional film formats, and the DigitDia 8000 is designed for compatible slide magazines and use with a computer.

  • According to reflecta, the x22-Scan saves JPEG files directly to SD; its listed holders are designed for mounted slides up to 3.2 mm thick.
  • The DigitDia 8000 connects to a computer, so it is not a proven SD card alternative.

Kodak Photo Plus

The EU version of the SLIDE N SCAN described here is designed for the listed 135, 110 and 126 originals, with an on-screen preview and saving to SD.

  • Kodak Photo Plus lists compatible adapters and support for SD/SDHC cards up to 32 GB.
  • The product page says the memory card required for use is not included. These details do not automatically apply to other SLIDE N SCAN versions.

Plustek

The OpticFilm 135i is a PC-connected option for 35mm slides and film strips if computer-based editing fits your planned workflow.

  • The F.A.Z. Kaufkompass gives the OpticFilm 135i positive marks for its software and scan quality.
  • The test states that it can scan a maximum of four mounted slides or six film-strip frames per pass, and that it is limited to 135 film. These details apply to this model.

Rollei

According to Rollei, the PDF-S 240 SE is a standalone multi-scanner for the specified slides, negatives and printed photo formats.

  • Rollei lists an SD/SDHC/MMC card slot.
  • The stated increase from 1800 to 2400 dpi is interpolated; the format and quality specifications apply to this model.

Somikon

According to Somikon, the SD-1700 is a standalone scanner for the listed slides, negatives and printed photos, including photos in albums.

  • Somikon lists SD/SDHC storage up to 32 GB.
  • The memory card must be purchased separately; holders for 110 and 126 film must also be ordered separately.

Joybuy products

Related products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

Can I scan without free internal storage on my PC?

Yes, with a standalone model that saves directly to a memory card. reflecta says the x22-Scan saves JPEG files directly to SD. Check that you have a compatible card and make a separate backup too.

Does the Kodak SLIDE N SCAN need an additional memory card?

Yes, for the version described on the EU product page. Kodak Photo Plus specifies SD/SDHC cards up to 32 GB and notes that the card required for use is not included.

What should I check when setting up and handling my scans?

First, check that your originals fit the holders provided. After scanning, check a few files and make a separate backup as well as keeping the card you’re working from; the German consumer advice centre recommends backing up photos too.