Which printer is right for you?

Groups that mainly print text lists

If you mostly print donation summaries and other text documents, check whether black-and-white output will be sufficient, whether automatic double-sided printing would be useful, and whether the available connections suit your workspaces. Brother Germany lists LAN, Wi-Fi and duplex printing for the HL-L2445DW; this model does not have a built-in scanner.

Groups with paper receipts

If you also want to digitise or copy receipts, compare all-in-one printers. Consider whether a flatbed scanner will do or whether an automatic document feeder is important for handling lots of loose sheets. Brother Germany and HP Germany describe different features for their respective models.

Teams sharing a printer

If several authorised users print documents containing personal information, think beyond the network connection and decide who can send print jobs and collect printouts. The Federal Office for Information Security points out that confidential information may remain on printers; the Data Protection Conference covers the processing of personal data under instructions.

Key buying considerations

Black-and-white printer without a scanner

A good fit if: Your documents are mostly text and tables that remain readable without colour, and you don't need to digitise paper receipts at the printer.

Bear in mind: This type of printer cannot scan or copy paper receipts. Brother Germany lists duplex printing, LAN and Wi-Fi for the HL-L2445DW, but it has no built-in scanner.

Black-and-white all-in-one printer

A good fit if: You want to scan or copy paper receipts as well as print.

Bear in mind: Check the document feeder separately: Druckerchannel lists it as a distinct feature for the models it compares. Duplex printing does not automatically mean double-sided scanning.

Colour printer or ink-tank printer

A good fit if: Colour coding or other group documents would not make sense without colour.

Bear in mind: Compare the consumables for the specific model with your printing needs. Epson's claims about EcoTank savings are manufacturer claims, not evidence of what it will cost your group.

Consideration What to check before buying Who this matters to
Readable text documents Check that your typical templates remain clear in black and white and whether you need automatic duplex printing. If I mainly print lists and tables, they should be easy to understand without colour and shouldn't require unnecessary printer features. Around 27% of consumers prioritise legible text printing.
Confidential printing Decide who can send print jobs and collect printouts; check the security and deletion options on the specific model. If donation documents identify individuals, I want to keep track of who can access them and whether printouts are left behind in the team. Around 20% of consumers prioritise the confidential handling of shared documents.
Scanning paper receipts Check printing, scanning and copying functions, as well as the document feeder and, if needed, duplex scanning, separately. If receipts need to be filed digitally or copied, I need more than a printer alone. Around 20% of consumers prioritise scanning or copying paper receipts.
Ongoing consumables Compare the suitable toner or ink and other replaceable parts for the number of pages you expect to print, using the same basis for each. If our group prints documents regularly, I want to consider all the consumables we need together. Around 27% of consumers prioritise ongoing printing costs.
Documents that rely on colour Check a typical template in black and white; if colour output is necessary, compare a specific model and its consumables. If a template uses colour to distinguish important information, I want that distinction to be retained in the printout. Around 6% of consumers prioritise colour output when it is necessary.

Buying pitfalls

  • Confusing duplex printing with double-sided scanning

    Automatic double-sided printing does not tell you whether a printer can automatically scan double-sided originals. Druckerchannel lists duplex printing and a document feeder as separate features.

    If you often scan double-sided originals, check the scanning and document-feeder specifications for the full model.

    Manually capturing double-sided receipts can take extra time.

  • Looking only at the consumables supplied with the printer

    Brother lists toner and drum as separate consumables for the Brother HL-L2445DW. A single page-yield figure therefore won't cover every compatible part.

    Include your expected page count and all the consumables you need in your comparison.

  • Assuming network access means your data is protected

    A printer that several people can access doesn't automatically manage who can view print jobs or collect printouts. The BSI also points out that confidential information may remain on printers.

    Plan how you will manage printing, access permissions and the eventual decommissioning of the device; check the relevant features on the specific model.

Brands to consider

Brother

Black-and-white printers without scanners and black-and-white all-in-one printers, such as the HL-L2445DW and DCP-L2620DW.

  • Brother Germany lists LAN, Wi-Fi and duplex printing for the HL-L2445DW; the DCP-L2620DW also prints, scans and copies.
  • The HL-L2445DW uses separate toner and drum consumables. For the DCP-L2620DW, check whether its available connections suit your workspaces.

HP

Black-and-white all-in-one printing with a document feeder, as exemplified by the LaserJet MFP M234sdw.

  • HP lists printing, scanning, copying, duplex printing and a document feeder for this model.
  • HP notes that dynamic security measures may block cartridges without a suitable HP chip in the specified model.

Canon

Another black-and-white all-in-one option is the i-SENSYS MF272dw.

  • Canon Germany lists printing, scanning and copying, as well as double-sided printing, for this model.
  • If you process lots of paper receipts one after another, check separately whether you need a document feeder. Duplex printing does not mean double-sided scanning.

Epson

EcoTank is an ink-tank alternative worth considering, particularly if you genuinely need colour printing.

  • Refillable ink tanks work differently from toner cartridges.
  • Epson's savings figures are conditional comparisons produced by the manufacturer. Your choice should be based on the specific model, compatible ink and your printing needs.

Joybuy products

The following Joybuy products include colour and black-and-white all-in-one printers for groups that want to scan or copy as well as print.

HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP 3302sdwg colour laser printer

HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP 3302sdwg

A good fit if your templates need colour and you want printing, scanning and copying in one device.

Colour laser all-in-one printer; automatic double-sided printing; Wi-Fi, Ethernet and USB.

View at Joybuy
PANTUM BM2300AW A4 monochrome laser all-in-one printer

PANTUM BM2300AW A4-Monochrom-Laser-Multifunktionsdrucker

A good fit if you mostly print black-and-white documents and want to feed in, scan or copy receipts on the same device.

22 pages per minute; Wi-Fi; automatic document feeder; monochrome printing and colour scanning.

View at Joybuy
PANTUM BM2300NW A4 monochrome laser all-in-one printer

PANTUM BM2300NW A4-Monochrom-Laser-Multifunktionsdrucker

A good fit if you need a black-and-white all-in-one printer with network connectivity for printing, scanning and copying.

22 pages per minute; dual-band Wi-Fi and Ethernet; printing, copying and colour scanning. Double-sided printing is manual.

View at Joybuy
HP Envy 6520 all-in-one inkjet printer

HP Envy 6520 All-in-One Wireless Inkjet Printer

A good fit if you want colour printing, scanning and copying, with a document feeder, all in one device.

Automatic double-sided printing; colour touchscreen; dual-band Wi-Fi, Bluetooth and USB. The product description recommends genuine HP cartridges and mentions dynamic security features.

View at Joybuy
HP Envy 6120 all-in-one inkjet printer

HP Envy 6120 All-in-One Wireless Inkjet Printer

A good fit if your group needs colour and printing, copying and scanning functions.

Automatic double-sided printing; colour touchscreen; dual-band Wi-Fi and USB. The product description recommends genuine HP cartridges and mentions dynamic security features.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does our group need a scanner in its printer?

Only if you want to digitise or copy paper receipts using the same device. If you have several documents, check the document feeder separately; automatic double-sided printing does not automatically mean double-sided scanning.

What matters when sharing a printer?

Decide who can send print jobs and collect printouts, and plan how to decommission the device securely. The Federal Office for Information Security points out that confidential information may remain on printers and all-in-one devices; this doesn't mean that a particular model will handle these tasks automatically.

Which consumables should I compare?

Check the consumables compatible with the complete model and compare their page yields on the same basis. The Brother HL-L2445DW uses separate toner and drum parts. HP notes that cartridges without a suitable HP chip may be restricted on the LaserJet MFP M234sdw.

Does a tax-deductible donation receipt have to be printed on this printer?

Not in every case. Section 50 of the German Income Tax Implementation Ordinance (EStDV) sets out the official form or specified alternative evidence. Where the electronic transmission to the tax authority covered by that section applies, the data submitted about the donor must be provided electronically or, if they request it, as a printout. This applies to donation receipts under those conditions, not to every internal printout of a donation list. The basis is Section 50 EStDV, issued by the Federal Ministry of Justice and the Federal Office of Justice.

Are data protection requirements relevant to voluntary groups too?

If your group processes personal data, you should manage who can access it. The Data Protection Conference refers to associations in connection with processing personal data under instructions; the Federal Office for Information Security describes the risks of confidential information remaining on printers. You will need to check which measures suit your specific workflow.