Who should consider this headphone question?

Listeners following quiet directions

You want to understand even the quieter parts of spoken directions at a comfortable volume. Fit, noise isolation and clear playback may matter more to you than a general promise of ANC. The World Health Organization recommends well-fitting noise-cancelling headphones to reduce the need to turn up the volume in noisy environments.

City walkers who like to stay alert

You listen to directions in changing traffic conditions and still want to hear the sounds around you. It’s worth comparing an easily accessible ambient mode with an open design.

Listeners on longer routes

You want a comfortable fit that lasts and enough battery life per charge. Remember that the earbuds’ battery life is not the same as the additional battery life provided by the charging case.

What to look for when choosing

For spoken walking directions with quiet passages, clarity, awareness of your surroundings, fit and battery life matter most. First, decide whether your route calls for more noise isolation or for hearing as much of the surrounding sound as possible.

Closed-fit ANC earbuds with ambient mode

Best if: traffic or other steady background noise drowns out quiet directions and you want to switch modes as you go.

Bear in mind: fit and the seal affect how well they work; ambient mode does not guarantee that you’ll hear every warning signal.

Open earbuds without ANC

Best if: you want to keep hearing the sounds around you as continuously as possible, and your route isn’t so noisy that the directions get drowned out.

Bear in mind: the open design lets sound in but doesn’t actively block it, so check that quiet passages remain clear on your route.

Priority What to check when buying Who it matters most to
Understanding quiet directions Check the fit and seal, ANC, and playback of a quiet voice recording of your own at a comfortable volume. If I want to understand quiet passages without instinctively turning up the volume, I pay particular attention to fit and clear playback. Around 34% of consumers whose main priority is clarity look for these features.
Hearing your surroundings while walking Check that ambient mode is easy to access; with open designs, test how clearly you can hear on your own route. When I’m out in changing traffic conditions, I don’t want to block out the surrounding sounds completely. Around 33% of consumers whose main priority is awareness of their surroundings pay particular attention to the design and mode switching.
Fit on longer routes Check the supplied ear tip sizes, how well they fit you and how easy the controls are to use while walking. On longer walks, I want my earbuds to feel comfortable and stay in place without constant adjustment. Around 20% of consumers whose main priority is fit look for a secure fit in particular.
Battery life and controls on the go Compare battery life per charge in the mode you plan to use, and check the controls for pausing, adjusting volume and switching modes. If I want to listen to a route without stopping to recharge, the earbuds’ battery life per charge is essential. Around 13% of consumers whose main priority is battery life focus on this feature.

Common misconceptions

  • Assuming ANC means you’ll safely hear your surroundings

    Noise cancellation and ambient mode serve different purposes. No mode has been shown to take the place of paying attention to traffic.

    Choose a design that suits your route, and pay particular attention to traffic when crossing the road.

  • Assuming a manufacturer’s claim means quiet speech will be clear

    A noise-cancellation claim doesn’t tell you whether a particular voice recording will remain clear against the sounds on your route.

    Check the fit and listen to quiet speech at a comfortable volume, rather than instinctively turning it up.

  • Counting the charging case’s battery life as uninterrupted listening time

    Recharging in the case interrupts your listening. Manufacturers distinguish between battery life per earbud charge and the extra battery life provided by the case.

    For the length of your route, compare the stated battery life per charge in the mode you plan to use.

Relevant brands at a glance

Sony

Worth considering if you want to compare closed-fit WF earbuds with ANC against the open LinkBuds Open.

  • Sony lists ANC, ambient mode and up to 8 hours of music playback with noise cancelling switched on for the WF-1000XM5.
  • The open LinkBuds Open let in surrounding sounds but don’t actively cancel them. Manufacturer specifications are not a comparative test.

Samsung

The Galaxy Buds3 Pro are a closed-fit option with several noise control modes.

  • Samsung describes ANC, ambient and adaptive modes, as well as an optional automatic switch when sirens are detected.
  • Samsung says noise control requires both earbuds to be worn and switched on, as well as a smartphone connection. Detection is no substitute for staying alert yourself.

Apple

The AirPods Pro 3 are worth considering when comparing ANC, Transparency mode and playback controls.

  • Apple lists up to 8 hours of playback per charge with ANC and five ear tip sizes.
  • The stated battery life applies to this specific model and doesn’t guarantee the same playback time on every route.

Bose

The 2nd Gen QuietComfort Ultra Earbuds are ANC earbuds supplied with fit accessories.

  • Bose lists a Fit Kit with three sizes of eartips and three sizes of stability bands, as well as up to 6 hours of battery life.
  • Battery life is a manufacturer’s estimate and depends on the mode you use.

soundcore

The Liberty 4 NC are a closed-fit ANC option where it’s worth checking the fit and controls.

  • The manufacturer lists adaptive noise cancelling and an in-app fit test.
  • A manufacturer’s noise-cancellation claim doesn’t prove that quiet directions will remain clear on your route.

Joybuy products for routes with quiet passages

The following Joybuy picks are ANC earbuds for anyone who wants to take disruptive background noise into account when listening to spoken directions.

Bowers & Wilkins Pi6 True Wireless in-ear headphones

Bowers & Wilkins Pi6 True Wireless in-ear headphones

These closed-fit earbuds with Active Noise Cancelling are worth considering if you want to reduce disruptive background noise.

12 mm bio-cellulose drivers; aptX Adaptive; Bluetooth 5.4 with Multipoint; up to 8 hours of battery life.

View at Joybuy
AKG N5 Hybrid True Wireless Earbuds

AKG N5 Hybrid True Wireless Earbuds

If you want to switch between noise isolation and hearing more of your surroundings while walking, check the stated Ambient Sound Transparency feature.

True Adaptive Noise Cancelling; Bluetooth 5.3; 2.4 GHz USB-C dongle; colour: White.

View at Joybuy
Bose QuietComfort Wireless Earbuds, Dewdrop Mint

Bose QuietComfort Wireless Earbuds, Dewdrop Mint

For changing listening conditions, the adjustable noise cancelling and stated control over the sounds you hear around you are worth considering.

Bluetooth 5.3 with Multipoint; IPX4; customisable touch controls; colour: Dewdrop Mint.

View at Joybuy
CMF Buds 2, Green

CMF Buds 2, Green

The touch controls are described as handling playback, volume and calls, which may be useful when you’re on the move.

Active Noise Cancellation; Bluetooth 5.4; 11 mm drivers; IP55; up to 7.5 hours of battery life; colour: Green.

View at Joybuy
LG Tone Free T90S in-ear Bluetooth headphones, Black

LG Tone Free T90S in-ear Bluetooth headphones, Black

If you want to hear the sounds around you while out and about, check the stated Environmental Sound Mode and the option to switch between noise modes at the touch of a button.

Active Noise Cancellation; IPX4; colour: Black.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Are headphones categorically banned when walking on German roads?

Sections 1 and 25 of the German Road Traffic Regulations do not impose a blanket ban on pedestrians wearing headphones. The Federal Ministry of Justice and the Federal Office of Justice require road users to pay attention to traffic in the situations covered by those provisions, and to watch for vehicles when crossing a road. Section 23 of the StVO concerns the duties of drivers and does not establish a corresponding blanket ban for pedestrians.

How should I set up my earbuds for a route with quiet passages?

If you’re using sealed in-ear earbuds, try different ear tip sizes and test speech playback at a comfortable volume. Choose the noise mode you need before setting off, and familiarise yourself with the pause and mode-switching controls; features vary by model.

Can I keep ANC on during a pause in the directions?

It depends on the settings of the specific model, because ANC and playing spoken directions are separate functions. Sony says that certain models have an adjustable automatic shut-off when playback stops. Check whether your model stays on and connected during longer pauses.

What are my rights when buying online?

In the EU, distance purchases generally come with a 14-day right to cancel from the date of delivery; exceptions and return postage costs may apply. For faulty goods, you are generally entitled to a legal guarantee of at least two years from the seller, regardless of any additional manufacturer’s warranty being advertised. This information is based on Your Europe, the European Union’s portal.