Choose a drive based on the size of your photo archive and the connections available on the computers you’ll actually use. Also consider how you’ll protect private photos and check that you can restore them. A desktop HDD is better suited to a fixed backup location, while a portable HDD is easier to move between compatible devices. An SSD may be a better choice for frequent transfers of large files. None of these options replaces a separate, verifiable backup.
Who is this guide for?
People with irreplaceable photos
If you want to recover photos after accidentally deleting them or a drive failing, check that your backups are readable and keep them separate. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security recommends checking from time to time that a backup contains the data and that it can be read.
People with private photos on a shared computer
If several people use the same workstation, access protection for your drive may be important. Guidance from WD, Verbatim and Microsoft also shows that the unlock method, where you keep the recovery key and the devices you use all need to work with your chosen protection method.
People with more than one computer
If you want to back up or open photo folders on different computers, check the connections, file system and backup software separately. Toshiba lists USB-A and USB-C cables for Canvio Flex, while Apple sets out its own formatting requirements for Time Machine volumes.
What should you look for when buying?
Start by working out how much storage you need and what your backup software requires. Then check how you’ll protect the drive on a shared computer and test that you can restore your files.
The figures represent consumers choosing an external drive for local photo backups on a shared workstation. Each person’s main purchasing concern is shown.
| Priority |
What to check before buying |
Who is this particularly important for? |
| Recoverability |
Allow for your photo folders and the backup versions you plan to keep. Try restoring a file and store another copy separately. |
If I want to recover photos after deleting them or a drive failing, I need a readable backup and a tested way to restore them. Around 33% of consumers put recoverability first. |
| Access protection |
Check whether the exact model supports your preferred unlock method. Keep your password or recovery key somewhere separate from the drive. |
On a shared computer, I want to protect private photos from other people’s access while still being able to open them reliably myself. Around 27% of consumers prioritise access protection when buying. |
| Storage capacity |
Take into account the storage you’re already using, future photos and any older backup versions you want to keep. Check the capacity of the specific model. |
As my photo archive grows, I want enough room for my existing pictures and planned backup versions. Around 20% of consumers put archive capacity first. |
| Connection and transfer |
Check that the connections, cables, operating systems and backup software on your computers are compatible. Compare SSD performance claims only under the stated connection conditions. |
If I want to use the drive with several computers or often transfer large folders, the connection and backup software need to work together. Around 20% of consumers prioritise device compatibility and transfer effort. |
Common photo backup mistakes
-
The only copy is on the external drive
Moving your original files elsewhere doesn’t automatically give you a recoverable backup. A second copy kept in the same place may also be affected by the same incident.
Keep your original files, regularly check that you can restore them and store another copy separately.
-
Assuming USB-C or exFAT guarantees backup compatibility
A suitable connector and readable files don’t automatically mean a particular backup programme can use the drive. Apple recommends APFS or APFS (Encrypted) for Time Machine volumes; reformatting can erase existing data.
Check the computers’ connections, supplied cables, file system and backup software separately. Back up the data on the drive elsewhere before reformatting it, if needed.
-
Setting up a protected drive without a recovery plan
A password or unlock method won’t help much if you can’t open your backup later. WD says a forgotten WD Security password cannot be recovered; the drive must be erased before it can be used again. Verbatim notes that a security update is available for Fingerprint Secure.
Test the unlock method on the systems you need, keep your login details separately and check for security updates specific to your product.
-
Relying on an SSD’s maximum speeds as your actual transfer speed
Samsung quotes specific maximum speeds for the T7 Shield, which require a compatible USB 3.2 Gen 2 host, suitable cables and UASP.
First check the connection on the shared computer, then weigh your transfer needs against the storage capacity you require.
Brands to consider
Toshiba
Canvio Flex is a range of portable HDDs for compatible devices with USB-A or USB-C.
- Toshiba’s EMEA materials list supplied USB-A and USB-C cables, exFAT pre-formatting and models with capacities of up to 4 TB.
- Being able to access files doesn’t automatically mean the volume, without changes, will work with every backup programme. Apple recommends APFS or APFS (Encrypted) for Time Machine.
Seagate
Expansion Desktop is a range of desktop HDDs for backing up files at a fixed workstation.
- The Seagate manual lists a power supply and a USB Micro-B to USB-A cable in the box.
- The manual says a different cable, not supplied, is needed for a compatible USB-C connection. Check the connections on the specific model you’re considering.
Samsung
The Portable SSD T7 Shield is a portable SSD option for frequent transfers of larger files.
- For the German 2 TB model MU-PE2T0S/EU, Samsung quotes sequential maximum speeds of up to 1,050 MB/s for reading and 1,000 MB/s for writing.
- These manufacturer figures require a compatible USB 3.2 Gen 2 host, suitable cables and UASP. The stated IP65 rating was tested under controlled conditions.
Western Digital
Supported My Passport models are worth considering if you want to set up access protection using drive software.
- WD Security supports certain drives with 256-bit AES hardware encryption, according to Western Digital.
- WD says a forgotten password cannot be recovered; the drive must be erased before it can be used again.
Verbatim
Fingerprint Secure Portable Hard Drive 1 TB is an HDD option with biometric unlocking.
- Verbatim lists AES-256 hardware encryption and support for up to eight authorised users, including an administrator.
- The manufacturer says a security update is available. Its general statement about GDPR compliance doesn’t confirm how every specific photo is processed.
Joybuy products for local photo backups
The Joybuy products below include portable HDDs, a desktop HDD and a portable SSD. Before buying, check that the capacity, connection and backup software are compatible with your computers.
No image available
WD Elements Portable 5 TB USB-C
This portable HDD is an option if you want to move a local photo archive between compatible workstations.
5 TB; USB-C; USB 3.2 Gen 1.
View at Joybuy
No image available
WD Elements Portable 4 TB USB-C
This portable HDD is worth considering if you want to back up photos across compatible devices.
4 TB; USB-C; USB 3.2 Gen 1.
View at Joybuy
No image available
WD Elements Portable 2 TB USB-C
This portable HDD lets you open photo folders on compatible Windows and Mac computers.
2 TB; USB-C; exFAT; described as compatible with Windows and macOS. Being able to access files doesn’t mean it will work with every backup programme.
View at Joybuy
No image available
WD Elements Desktop 8 TB
This desktop HDD is an option for a large local photo archive kept at a fixed workstation.
8 TB; USB 3.0; a power supply is included, according to the product description.
View at Joybuy
No image available
KEXIN external SSD 256 GB, USB 3.1 Type-C
A portable SSD option if you want to store and transfer photos locally. Check whether 256 GB is enough for the backups you need.
256 GB; USB 3.1 Type-C; quoted transfer speed of up to 500 MB/s. Actual transfer speeds depend on the devices and connection used.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Can I leave the external hard drive connected to the shared computer all the time?
For a separate backup, Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security recommends disconnecting the storage device from the computer when you’re not backing up. Also check regularly that you can restore a photo from it.
Will a hard drive that works with both Windows and Mac automatically work with Time Machine?
No. Being able to access files doesn’t automatically mean a drive is suitable for Time Machine. Apple recommends APFS or APFS (Encrypted) for Time Machine volumes; reformatting can erase existing data. So decide in advance whether you want to share files or create a Time Machine backup.
Can I simply use BitLocker to protect access?
It depends on your edition of Windows: Microsoft doesn’t list BitLocker Drive Encryption as a feature of Windows Home. Check the computer’s edition, keep your recovery key safe and test unlocking on the devices you’ll actually use.