Which drive is right for you?

Producers with lots of project versions

If you want to keep raw recordings, edits and earlier versions and be able to find them again later, you’ll need enough space for every version, as well as a separate backup. The BSI also recommends checking that backed-up data can be restored.

Producers who transfer files frequently

If you often copy large recordings between computers or work on them while you’re out and about, transfer speed, compatible connections and portability are important factors to consider. Manufacturers’ speed claims assume you’re using a suitable connection.

What should you look for when buying?

Portable SSD

A good choice if: You regularly transfer large concert files or need to access project versions while you’re out and about.

The trade-off: CHIP describes SSDs as faster than HDDs, but SSDs can cost more for the same storage capacity. Maximum speeds quoted by manufacturers depend on the connection you use.

Portable HDD

A good choice if: You want to keep lots of versions in a portable format and don’t regularly edit files directly from the drive.

The trade-off: CHIP describes HDDs as slower and more vulnerable to knocks than SSDs. A single archive drive is no substitute for a separate backup.

Desktop HDD

A good choice if: Your version archive is kept mainly in one place and storage capacity matters more than portability.

The trade-off: The Seagate Expansion Desktop requires a power supply and USB cable, making it less convenient if you move between locations frequently.

Buying consideration What to look for Who should consider this?
Space for project versions Add up the file sizes of all your raw recordings, edits you want to keep and planned new projects. Compare the total with the usable capacity of the specific model you’re considering. If I want to keep raw recordings, edits and exports, I need enough space for every complete version. Around 36% of consumers put having enough room for multiple project versions first.
Restoring files Check whether earlier versions are stored separately and whether you can successfully restore a test file. The BSI recommends checking that backups can be restored. If a drive failure or mistake could put earlier versions at risk, I want a separate backup that I can access. Around 29% of consumers prioritise being able to restore their project versions.
Transfer speed Check that your computer, drive and cable support the same USB mode. Manufacturer figures are maximum speeds under specific conditions, not guaranteed transfer speeds. When transferring large files frequently, I don’t want to spend longer than necessary waiting for them to copy. Around 21% of consumers put fast transfers first.
Portability and connections Check the connections, cables and power supply required, as well as the file system of the specific model if you use more than one operating system. If I move between a venue and my workspace, the drive needs to be easy to carry and compatible with my computers. Around 14% of consumers prioritise portability and a suitable connection.

Avoid common buying mistakes

  • Confusing a project copy with an independent backup

    If your only copy is kept in the same place or on the same drive as your working files, a failure or accident could affect both.

    Keep important versions in a separate location too, and test that you can restore a file.

    A separate copy requires extra storage and regular time to check it.

  • Assuming an SSD’s stated maximum speed guarantees a particular transfer time

    Samsung’s maximum speeds for the T7 Shield require a suitable host, compatible cable and UASP to be enabled. So a single product specification doesn’t tell you how quickly the whole connection will transfer files.

    Check the connection between your computer, cable and drive, and choose an SSD to suit your actual transfer needs.

  • Choosing a desktop HDD if you move between locations frequently

    The Seagate Expansion Desktop requires a power supply and USB cable. This can make it less convenient to move between a venue and your workspace than a portable drive powered via USB.

    Before buying, decide whether your archive will stay mainly in one place or needs to travel with you regularly.

    With a desktop model, you’ll need to account for the extra power supply and the effort of transporting it.

  • Assuming durability claims protect your data from loss

    Samsung states that the T7 Shield meets IP65 under controlled test conditions. According to the manufacturer, damage caused by liquids and dust isn’t covered by the warranty.

    Check the conditions for the specific model and keep a separate backup, regardless of what the drive’s casing claims.

Key brands at a glance

Samsung

The portable T7 Shield SSD, model MU-PE2T0S/EU with 2 TB, is designed for frequent transfers on the go.

  • Samsung quotes read speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s and write speeds of up to 1.000 MB/s under suitable conditions, as well as IP65 protection.
  • The maximum speeds require a suitable host, compatible cable and UASP. According to the manufacturer, damage caused by liquids and dust isn’t covered by the warranty.

Seagate

The Portable range offers storage for your archive on the move, while the Expansion Desktop is designed for keeping larger collections in one place.

  • Seagate offers its Portable range in capacities of up to 5 TB and the Expansion Desktop in capacities of up to 28 TB.
  • The Portable HDD is powered via USB. According to Seagate, the Expansion Desktop requires a power supply and USB cable.

Toshiba

Canvio Basics is a range of portable, USB-powered HDDs for project and version archives.

  • Toshiba offers models with capacities of up to 4 TB and describes Canvio Basics as ready to use with Windows.
  • If you use another operating system, check in advance that the file system of the specific model is compatible.

Crucial

The X9 Pro 2TB, model CT2000X9PROSSD9, is an example of a portable SSD.

  • Crucial quotes speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s under test conditions.
  • According to Crucial, speeds depend on factors including the host, cable and formatting.

Portable SSDs for project files

Here you’ll find portable external SSDs for copying and storing concert project files.

MOVESPEED Portable SSD, model YSPSRX20M-1TTG

MOVESPEED YSPSRX20M-1TTG, 1 TB

For frequent transfers of large files on the go. The product name lists 1 TB, USB 3.2, read speeds of 2.060 MB/s and write speeds of 1.800 MB/s.

View at Joybuy
Samsung Portable SSD T7, 2 TB, USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2

Samsung T7, 2 TB, USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2

A portable SSD for working in different locations. The product name lists 2 TB and USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2.

View at Joybuy
Samsung Portable SSD T7, 4 TB

Samsung T7, 4 TB

For keeping several project versions on one portable drive. The product name lists a capacity of 4 TB.

View at Joybuy
Samsung MU-PG2T0B, 2 TB, USB Type-C

Samsung MU-PG2T0B, 2 TB

For transferring files on the go and storing project files. The product name lists 2 TB and USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2 (3.1 Gen 2).

View at Joybuy
Samsung T9, 1 TB, portable SSD

Samsung T9, 1 TB

For transferring files on the go. The product name lists 1 TB, USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 and read and write speeds of 2.000 MB/s.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

What capacity do I need for multiple project versions?

Add up the file sizes of your raw recordings, all the project versions and exports you want to keep, and any files you expect to add. Allow extra space for separate backup copies too. The right capacity depends on the files you actually have.

Is one external hard drive enough for a backup?

If that drive contains your only remaining copy, it won’t protect you if the drive itself fails or is lost. The BSI recommends backing up your data and points out that you should check whether it can be restored. So keep another copy in a separate location and test that you can restore it.

What should I check when switching between Windows and Mac?

Before copying files, check that the connection and file system of the specific drive model are compatible with the computers you use. Toshiba describes Canvio Basics as designed for Windows; if you use another operating system, check the compatibility of the specific model.

What extra requirements might a backup plan involve?

A separate backup needs extra storage space and should be restorable. A desktop HDD such as the Seagate Expansion Desktop also requires a power supply and USB cable.

In Germany, can I record concert performances and copy them freely just because of the private-copying rule?

No, this doesn’t give you blanket permission. Under Section 53(7) of the German Copyright Act (UrhG), recording a public performance of a work requires the rights holder’s consent. Section 77 of the UrhG also sets out performers’ exclusive rights over recording and reproduction. Whether you may reproduce specific concert recordings for your project depends, among other things, on the rights involved, the permissions granted, where the source material came from and how you intend to use it. The legislation is available from the Federal Ministry of Justice and the Federal Office of Justice on “Laws on the Internet”.