Which type is right for you?

Collectors with large video archives

If you back up digitised films, source files and large project folders at a fixed workstation, take your entire collection and its potential growth into account when choosing capacity. Western Digital and Seagate list options for desktop storage in their manufacturers’ data sheets.

Careful family archivists

If you want to be able to recover recordings after accidental deletion or damage to where they’re stored, you’ll need more than just a drive: keep a separate copy and check that you can restore from it. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security describes several possible causes of data loss and recommends testing the restore process too.

Mobile project editors

If you regularly carry projects between work locations, the drive’s format and power supply matter. Its capacity must still be sufficient for your entire backup. Toshiba describes its Canvio Basics range as portable and USB-powered.

What should you look for when buying?

First, list the folders you want to back up. Then decide whether desktop capacity or easy portability matters more for the way you work.

Criteria What to check Who is it important to?
Capacity for growing folders Work out the total size of your films, source files and project versions, and allow extra space for your planned backup routine. As my project folders grow, I want room for everything, including the versions I need. An estimated 31% of consumers are likely to prioritise having enough capacity.
Recoverability Decide where to keep another copy and how you’ll restore a sample folder. For irreplaceable family recordings, I don’t just want a copy; I also want to be able to retrieve it if something goes wrong. An estimated 25% of consumers are likely to prioritise this need for recoverability.
Computer and backup method Check that the operating system, connection, cable and file system suit the backup method you plan to use. When I back up videos on a Mac or Windows PC, I want the drive to work with both my computer and the backup method I use. An estimated 19% of consumers are likely to prioritise this compatibility.
Portability and power Check whether there’s a suitable USB port or power socket where you’ll use the drive, and that it has enough capacity for the entire project. If I want to take my backup between work locations, I need a suitable drive that’s easy to connect. An estimated 13% of consumers are likely to put portability first.
Large file transfers Don’t assume the stated interface rate is the same as the drive’s measured speed. Consider whether you regularly transfer large files. If I regularly copy large film folders, I want to allow enough time based on my own computer and workflow. An estimated 12% of consumers are likely to prioritise large file transfers.

Avoid common buying mistakes

  • Assuming one large hard drive is a complete backup strategy

    Your backup drive could fail too, or be damaged at the same time as your computer if they’re kept in the same place.

    Decide where to keep another copy, then check you can use it by restoring a sample folder.

    Keeping an additional copy in a separate location requires more storage and regular maintenance.

  • Confusing the USB interface rate with copying speed

    The USB interface rate quoted by Western Digital isn’t a measurement of how quickly your video folders will actually copy. LaCie’s advertised transfer rate is based on a specific manufacturer test setup using a Mac.

    Only compare figures measured under similar conditions, and allow plenty of time for your first backup.

  • Overlooking the power supply or capacity limit

    The desktop models described require a power adapter. The Toshiba Canvio Basics range reviewed here is USB-powered and, according to the manufacturer, available up to 4 TB.

    Work out how much data you have and where you’ll use the drive before choosing its format and capacity.

    A desktop HDD needs space and a power socket. If a portable drive isn’t large enough for your backup plan, you’ll need additional storage.

Key brands at a glance

Western Digital

The Elements Desktop range offers a fixed-location option with plenty of capacity for larger archives. The manufacturer’s data sheet lists versions from 4 to 26 TB.

  • The manufacturer’s data sheet lists USB 3.2 Gen 1 and a power adapter for the desktop range described.
  • According to the manufacturer, reformatting is required for the macOS use described. The interface rate is not a measured backup speed.

Seagate

Expansion Desktop is a fixed-location option for storing files. The manufacturer’s data sheet lists, among other versions, an 8 TB model for EMEA.

  • According to the manufacturer, a power adapter and USB cable are included.
  • The Rescue data recovery services listed aren’t available in every country. Check the terms for your country before buying.

Toshiba

According to Toshiba, Canvio Basics is a portable, USB-powered product range for EMEA, with versions up to 4 TB.

  • According to the manufacturer, no separate power adapter is needed.
  • The EMEA version is formatted as NTFS out of the box. According to the manufacturer, reformatting is required for the macOS use described.

LaCie

The d2 Professional is a desktop range with USB-C, designed for large photo and video files. The manufacturer’s data sheet lists versions up to 24 TB.

  • LaCie quotes speeds of up to 290 MB/s; according to the manufacturer, this figure is based on a test using a Mac.
  • The Rescue services listed aren’t available in every country. The advertised transfer rate doesn’t make a single copy more secure.

Joybuy products for video archives

This selection from Joybuy includes portable WD Elements drives for carrying between work locations, as well as a desktop model for a dedicated storage space.

WD Elements Portable 5TB USB-C

WD Elements Portable 5TB USB-C

This portable drive could suit you if you want to carry project files between work locations.

5 TB; USB-C.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements Portable 6TB USB-C

WD Elements Portable 6TB USB-C

This portable model suits a backup plan where you regularly move the drive between locations.

6 TB; USB-C.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements Portable 4TB USB-C

WD Elements Portable 4TB USB-C

This portable drive is an option if its capacity is enough for your entire backup plan.

4 TB; USB-C.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements Portable 2TB, USB-C, USB 3.2 Gen 1, 2.5-inch, exFAT, Black

WD Elements Portable 2TB, USB-C, USB 3.2 Gen 1, 2.5-inch, exFAT, Black

This portable drive is an option for smaller backups that you need to carry between locations.

2 TB; USB-C; USB 3.2 Gen 1; 2.5-inch; exFAT.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements Desktop 24TB, USB 3.2 Gen 1, 3.5-inch

WD Elements Desktop 24TB

This desktop drive could suit you if you have a large media archive at a fixed workstation.

24 TB; USB 3.2 Gen 1; 3.5-inch; external power supply required.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is it enough to copy finished films to a large external hard drive?

Only if finished films make up your entire backup. If you also want to be able to recover source files and project versions, include them too. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security describes equipment failure, accidental deletion and building damage as different causes of data loss. So keep another copy in a separate location and test restoring a sample folder.

How do I set up a backup on Windows or a Mac?

On Windows, File History can back up to an external drive. Microsoft notes that you may need to add folders that aren’t included in the selected libraries. On a Mac, a compatible external drive can be used as a Time Machine destination. Before setting up your backup, check which project folders the chosen method actually includes.

Do I need to prepare an NTFS-formatted hard drive for a Mac?

For the WD Elements Desktop and Toshiba Canvio Basics ranges reviewed, the manufacturers say that reformatting is required for the macOS use described. Check the file system of the specific version you buy, and back up any files already on the drive before reformatting it.

Are a warranty or data recovery service the same as a backup?

No. A warranty is subject to the relevant product terms, while an advertised data recovery service has its own conditions and, according to the Seagate and LaCie documents reviewed, isn’t available in every country. Neither replaces a separate copy that you can restore from.

Can I back up private home videos to an external hard drive in Germany?

For recordings processed solely for personal or family activities, the German Data Protection Conference describes a household exemption. Outside this scope, obligations under the General Data Protection Regulation may apply. If your videos include other people’s protected works, you’ll need to consider the copyright position separately: section 53 of the German Copyright Act (UrhG) permits individual copies for private use only under the conditions set out there. This is not blanket permission to publish or share them.