Who is this buying guide for?

Choir archive managers

If you’re backing up complete rehearsal and project folders, including older versions, plan for the total amount of data and how you’ll restore it. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security recommends disconnecting backup media from the computer when a backup isn’t in progress.

Mobile recording managers

If recordings need to travel from the rehearsal venue to an editing computer, the drive’s form factor, connection and power supply are important considerations. Toshiba and Verbatim describe USB-powered versions of certain portable models; check the specifications for the exact variant.

Teams using multiple computers

If you’re backing up or restoring files across Windows and Mac computers, check the file system, connection and backup software first. For the documented Canvio Basics variant, Toshiba specifies NTFS and says reformatting is required for the stated Mac use.

What should you look for when buying?

Start by working out the total size of all your project folders and older versions. Then check compatibility with your computers and decide whether the drive needs to be portable or can stay permanently at your workstation.

What you need What to check before buying Who should pay particular attention
Space for projects and versions Compare the total folder size, the older versions you want to keep and expected growth with the usable capacity. If you want to keep complete project folders and multiple versions, the total amount matters more than individual exports. Around 31% of consumers put storage space first.
Restorable backups Set up a backup routine, try restoring a project folder and disconnect the drive once the backup is complete. If you need to find and open older files, testing a restore should be part of your plan. Around 25% of consumers prioritise restorability.
Computer and software compatibility Check the USB connection, file system and folders included by your backup software. Back up files elsewhere before reformatting. If you use both Windows and Mac devices, you’ll need a suitable file system and the right backup settings. Around 19% of consumers prioritise compatibility.
Transport between rehearsals and your workstation Check the cable, compatible connection and power supply. For a desktop drive, also make room for the device and its power adapter. If you take recordings with you after rehearsals to work on them at another computer, choose a form factor suited to transport. Around 13% of consumers prioritise portability.
Recording privacy For recordings containing personal data, check the legal basis and appropriate safeguards. Consider setting up encryption and secure password storage where necessary. If recordings include identifiable people, consider who can access them and what could happen if the drive is lost. Around 12% of consumers prioritise protecting confidential recordings.

For a Mac backup using Time Machine, Apple recommends a backup volume with at least twice the storage capacity of your Mac. This recommendation applies to that use case; it isn’t a general minimum capacity for every choir backup.

For personal data, Germany’s Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information says that a legal basis under Article 6 of the GDPR is required. The applicable basis and safeguards depend, among other things, on the content of the recordings and how they’ll be used; a product feature doesn’t replace this assessment.

Which mistakes should you avoid?

  • Counting only individual audio exports

    Project folders and older versions need extra space. Apple’s recommendation to use twice your Mac’s capacity applies to Time Machine; it isn’t a general minimum for choir recordings.

    Work out the total size of all the folders you actually want to back up, and allow for the versions you want to keep and expected growth.

  • Assuming the USB interface speed is the backup speed

    A maximum interface speed isn’t the same as the drive’s measured write speed.

    Distinguish interface specifications from actual drive performance, and don’t choose a drive for occasional storage solely because it has the biggest USB speed figure.

  • Relying on a connected drive as your only backup

    A backup drive that stays connected is vulnerable to the same risks as your computer. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security recommends disconnecting backup media when a backup isn’t in progress and storing it separately.

    Plan to keep a separate copy, and test a restore to make sure important project files can be opened.

  • Using the file system without checking it first for Mac

    The documented Toshiba Canvio Basics variant is pre-formatted as NTFS; Toshiba says reformatting is required for the stated Mac use. Apple warns that erasing a backup volume will remove existing files.

    Decide which operating systems and backup methods you’ll use before setting up the drive. Back up any existing files to another device before reformatting a volume.

Which brands are worth considering?

Toshiba

Canvio Basics is a range of portable HDDs for storing files and making backups. Check that the capacity of the specific variant is enough for your project folders.

  • Toshiba specifies USB power and USB 3.2 Gen 1 for the documented range.
  • The documented variant is pre-formatted as NTFS; reformatting is required for the stated Mac use. Range specifications don’t automatically apply to every model generation.

Seagate

Expansion Desktop is an example of a desktop HDD for larger collections kept at a fixed workstation; the Portable range is an alternative if you need to carry your drive around.

  • A power adapter is included with the documented Expansion Desktop model.
  • You’ll need to connect the power adapter where you set up the drive. Specifications vary by model.

Verbatim

Store ’n’ Go includes a portable 4 TB HDD for file storage, as well as a separate Secure version for buyers who prioritise access protection.

  • For the documented 4 TB model, Verbatim specifies USB power and NTFS pre-formatting. For the Secure 2 TB model, the manufacturer specifies a keypad and AES-256 hardware encryption.
  • Verbatim recommends installing an available security update for the Secure model. The encryption specification is a manufacturer’s claim, not an independent assessment of its effectiveness.

WD

My Passport is another range of portable HDDs. Check the capacity and features of the specific model variant you’re considering.

  • The range offers another option for buyers looking for a portable drive.
  • Features and encryption can’t be assumed to apply to every My Passport HDD.

Joybuy products for choir recordings and project folders

This selection includes portable and desktop external HDDs for backups, from drives you can carry between rehearsals and your workstation to options for storing larger collections at a fixed computer.

WD Elements Portable 5TB USB-C

WD Elements Portable 5TB USB-C

This portable drive is designed for backups you need to carry between the rehearsal venue and your computer.

5 TB; 2.5-inch form factor; USB-C.

Joybuy
WD Elements Portable 6TB USB-C

WD Elements Portable 6TB USB-C

This portable drive is an option if you want to back up or carry large project files while you’re out and about.

6 TB; 2.5-inch form factor; USB-C.

Joybuy
WD Elements 6TB Desktop External Hard Drive

WD Elements 6TB Desktop External Hard Drive

This desktop HDD suits backups of larger project collections at a fixed workstation, provided an external power supply is available.

6 TB; 3.5-inch form factor; USB 3.0; NTFS; external power adapter required.

Joybuy
WD Elements 8TB Desktop External Hard Drive

WD Elements 8TB Desktop External Hard Drive

This desktop drive is designed for particularly large project folders at a fixed workstation; make sure you have access to a power socket.

8 TB; 3.5-inch form factor; USB 3.0; external power adapter required.

Joybuy
Western Digital My Passport 4TB Black

Western Digital My Passport 4TB Black

This portable HDD is an option if you want to carry project files with you and protect access to stored files.

4 TB; 2.5-inch form factor; AES-256 hardware encryption with password protection. Reformatting may be required for the Mac use described.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How can you keep earlier versions of choir projects?

On Windows, File History can restore earlier versions of files. If your project folders aren’t in the libraries it covers, add them to a library or create a new one, then check that you can restore a file. On a Mac, Time Machine can back up automatically.

Does a hard drive set up for Windows need reformatting for Mac?

For the documented Toshiba Canvio Basics variant, Toshiba specifies NTFS and says reformatting is required for the stated Mac use. Apple warns that erasing or reformatting a Mac backup volume will remove existing files, so back them up to another device first.

Should I choose a portable or desktop external HDD?

A portable HDD is a good choice if you need to carry backups between rehearsals and your workstation or store them separately. A desktop HDD is worth considering if you’ll mainly back up large collections at a fixed computer and are happy to use a power adapter.

Can recordings of identifiable choir members be stored on an external drive?

Choosing an external hard drive doesn’t establish whether processing the recordings is lawful in your specific case. Germany’s Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information notes that personal data requires an applicable legal basis under Article 6 of the GDPR. The relevant basis and safeguards depend, among other things, on who is responsible, the content of the recordings and how they’ll be used; this doesn’t mean that consent is required for every rehearsal.