Who is this selection for?

Club archive kept on a desktop computer

If you’re keeping raw footage, project files and multiple exports for the long term, plan for your total storage needs as well as a separate backup. The German Federal Office for Information Security (BSI) points out that storage media have different lifespans, which cannot be predicted precisely.

Mobile editing team

If club members hand footage between workstations, portability and power supply are important considerations. Toshiba says the Canvio Basics range is powered via USB. Also check that the capacity and file system are suitable for the computers involved.

People responsible for club footage

If footage shows identifiable people, consider who can access the files and how they will be used, as well as whether they can be recovered. The German Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information (BfDI) generally classifies this kind of footage as personal data.

What should you look for when buying?

As well as storage space, plan for an independently recoverable copy: the BSI includes recovery in its data backup recommendations. Power supply and file system can also be important when handing files over.

Desktop external HDD

A good fit if: the archive is kept mainly at a fixed workstation with a power socket nearby.

Bear in mind: you’ll need a power supply, and it’s less convenient to carry around. A single drive is still just one storage location.

Portable external HDD

A good fit if: footage is regularly moved between club members or workstations.

Weigh up: the space available for raw footage and every version of your project before choosing a specific model.

Buying consideration What to look for Who is it important for?
Space for multiple versions Add up your existing files and the project versions you expect to create, then check the capacity of the specific model. If you want to keep raw clips, projects and exports together, having enough space is the priority. Around 33% of consumers prioritise storage for different file versions in this kind of club archive.
Separate backup Decide in advance where an independent copy will be kept, who will make it and whether files can be restored from it. If you want to avoid losing irreplaceable footage due to a drive failure or accidental overwriting, give particular attention to an independent copy. Around 27% of consumers put separate backups and recoverability first.
Handing files between computers Check the ports and power supply on the computers involved, along with the file system. Back up existing files before reformatting. If you pass footage between workstations, a straightforward connection and a compatible file system are important. Around 20% of consumers prioritise transferring files between computers.
Access to footage Clarify who is authorised to access the files and how they are intended to be used. If the drive has security features, check software and computer compatibility. If you need to control access to footage showing identifiable people, consider security and intended use separately. Around 20% of consumers put controlled access first.

Common buying and usage mistakes

  • Counting multiple versions on one HDD as multiple backups

    If the only hard drive fails or files are accidentally deleted, every version stored on it could be affected too.

    Plan for version control and a separate backup as two different tasks. A separate backup kept elsewhere needs its own storage space.

  • Assuming a desktop HDD works like a USB-powered portable drive

    The Seagate One Touch Hub manual specifies a power supply, while Toshiba describes the Canvio Basics range covered here as USB-powered. This means their connections and the space they need at the point of use differ.

    Before choosing, consider how often club footage will be moved between workstations and whether there’s a power socket where the archive will be kept.

  • Assuming a USB connection guarantees file system compatibility

    Toshiba says the Canvio Basics model covered here is preformatted as NTFS and needs to be reformatted for macOS.

    Before making any changes, check which computers and files are involved, and back up existing data before reformatting.

Brands worth considering

Seagate

The One Touch Hub is a range of desktop HDDs with extra ports and password protection.

  • Seagate documents hub and backup features for the range.
  • The manual says the drive requires a power supply. Manufacturer claims about security features are not an independent assessment of data security.

Toshiba

Canvio Basics is a range of portable HDDs; the documented EMEA model is available with up to 4 TB of storage.

  • Toshiba describes the range covered here as USB-powered.
  • For the NTFS-preformatted Canvio Basics, Toshiba says reformatting is required for macOS. This information applies to Canvio Basics, not all Toshiba hard drives.

Intenso

Memory Center is a range of desktop 3.5-inch drives; Intenso lists an 8-TB model.

  • Intenso documents the available capacities and a USB interface.
  • The model specifications do not prove superior durability or make the hard drive suitable as your only backup.

Western Digital

My Book is a desktop alternative for archiving; Western Digital lists an 8-TB model on its German product page.

  • The German product page lists the specific My Book model as an 8-TB version.
  • Check the features and security functions for the specific model you’re considering.

LaCie

Seagate describes the d2 Professional as a desktop HDD range with USB-C, designed for creative workflows.

  • Seagate lists USB-C for this range and positions it for large media collections.
  • Manufacturer claims about performance and reliability are not an independent basis for comparing products.

Joybuy products for your club archive

The Joybuy products below include portable and desktop external HDDs for club footage, project files and moving files between workstations.

WD Elements Portable 5TB USB-C

WD Elements Portable 5TB USB-C

For club footage that needs to be carried between workstations.

Product name: 5 TB, USB-C.

Joybuy
WD Elements Portable 6TB USB-C

WD Elements Portable 6TB USB-C

For handing club footage between different workstations.

Product name: 6 TB, USB-C.

Joybuy
WD Elements Portable 4TB USB-C

WD Elements Portable 4TB USB-C

A portable option for club footage that moves between workstations.

Product name: 4 TB, USB-C.

Joybuy
WD Elements 2TB Portable External Hard Drive, USB-C, USB 3.2 Gen 1, 2.5-inch, exFAT, Black

WD Elements 2TB Portable, USB-C, USB 3.2 Gen 1, 2.5-inch, exFAT

For project files that need to be moved between workstations on a portable hard drive.

Product name: 2 TB, USB-C, USB 3.2 Gen 1, 2.5-inch and exFAT. Check the file system before sharing the drive between the computers involved.

Joybuy
WD Elements 8TB Desktop External Hard Drive, USB 3.0, 3.5-inch

WD Elements 8TB Desktop, USB 3.0, 3.5-inch

For a desktop club archive with a large collection of footage that stays mainly in one place.

Product name: 8 TB, USB 3.0 and 3.5-inch. This desktop model is marked as a stationary option.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is one hard drive enough if it holds several editing versions?

No, not as protection against that hard drive failing. Keep an independent copy separately and check from time to time that you can restore files from it.

Can I use a preformatted portable HDD alternately with Windows and Mac?

You can’t tell from the USB connection alone. Toshiba lists NTFS as the file system for the Canvio Basics model covered here and says it needs to be reformatted for macOS. Before making any changes, check which computers are involved and back up existing files.

Can a club store or publish footage of identifiable people indefinitely just because it has bought a hard drive?

No. Buying a hard drive does not grant permission. According to guidance from the BfDI, footage of identifiable people may be personal data. Whether, and on what basis, a club stores or publishes specific footage depends on the circumstances and the purpose. If processing is based on consent, the Data Protection Conference says that consent must, among other things, be freely given, informed and specific to the situation.