For completed productions that are mainly archived and only accessed occasionally, an external HDD is an obvious choice. If you transport it regularly and transfer files frequently, an SSD may be more suitable as a working drive. With either option, check the capacity, file system and connectors, and plan for a separate copy and a recovery test. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security includes both data backup and recovery in a complete backup plan.
Who uses the drive?
Production archive managers
If you want to reuse completed versions and their project folders later, you’ll need enough space, a clear filing system and a way to recover files. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security considers backup and recovery to be parts of a data backup plan.
Mobile production teams
If you take working folders between rehearsal venues and computers, and copy new versions, check the connector, how it handles transfers of your files, and whether you have a separate backup.
Teams with confidential documents
If production folders also contain contact lists or other personal data, assess the level of protection needed based on the information stored and who should have access. A password printed on the drive alone doesn’t answer this question; Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security also describes software-based encryption for files, folders or storage devices.
What matters when choosing?
Match the storage capacity to your existing and planned project folders, and consider how you would restore a backup. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security describes backup and recovery as parts of a complete data backup plan.
| What you need from a drive |
What to check before buying |
Who it matters to most |
| Archive space and easy access |
Allow for storage already in use, planned productions and backup versions; consider your filing system and file formats too. |
If you want to find completed versions later and keep growing project folders, work out how much space you need based on what you already have and how quickly it’s growing. Around 37% of consumers put archive space and easy access first. |
| Copying and portability |
Check that the USB port and cable are suitable; if you transfer files often, look for tests involving lots of individual files too. |
If you regularly take working versions to rehearsals, make sure the drive and connector suit the way you work. Around 27% of consumers prioritise frequent mobile working and file transfers. |
| Confidential documents |
Check the data you’ll store, the encryption options and how access will work if you need to recover files. |
If contact lists or other confidential production documents are stored on the drive, you’ll want to make unauthorised access more difficult while still allowing authorised people to access the files. Around 18% of consumers put protecting these documents first. |
| Use with multiple computers |
Check the operating systems, file system, write access requirements and suitable cables. |
If you use the drive with different computers, you’ll want to know before filling it whether you can read and write files on each one. Around 18% of consumers prioritise compatibility with their computers. |
Common selection mistakes
-
Assuming one drive is a secure archive
Any external storage device can fail. What matters is whether you can actually recover files from a separate backup.
Keep a separate copy and test whether you can restore a project folder from it.
Keeping another separate copy takes extra storage space and time for recovery tests.
-
Assuming the maximum MB/s figure tells you how quickly lots of files will copy
A sequential speed rating and a test copying lots of individual files measure different tasks. USB-IF explains that a USB connection operates at the lowest speed supported by both devices.
Check the connector and cable with the computer you plan to use. If you transfer files often, real-world tests with lots of files are a useful addition to the manufacturer’s figures.
-
Using a pre-formatted HDD between Windows and Mac without checking first
Toshiba states that the Canvio Basics version in question is formatted as NTFS; the manufacturer says it needs to be reformatted for macOS.
Before filling the drive, check which operating systems you’ll use and whether you need to read and write files on each one.
Reformatting the drive and copying the files over again can take extra time and effort.
Relevant brands and product ranges
Toshiba
Canvio Basics is a portable, USB-powered HDD range for storage and occasional access.
- For its current EMEA version, Toshiba specifies NTFS formatting for Windows; the 2-TB version has the part number HDTB520EK3AA.
- Toshiba says the drive needs to be reformatted for macOS. Model specifications aren’t an independent durability test.
Seagate
Expansion Portable is a USB-powered HDD range that provides extra local storage.
- Seagate’s data sheet lists 2 TB for model STKM2000400 and a two-year limited warranty for EMEA.
- The data sheet says the drive needs to be reformatted for Time Machine. Check the terms for the specific model.
Kingston
XS1000 is a compact SSD for files on the move; XS2000 is designed for compatible, faster connections.
- Kingston lists maximum read speeds of up to 1,050 MB/s for XS1000 and up to 2,000 MB/s for XS2000.
- These are manufacturer figures, not test results for your project folders. The XS2000 figure requires the corresponding interface.
Samsung
The Portable SSD T7 Shield is a mobile SSD option for frequent travel.
- For the black 2-TB version MU-PE2T0S/EU, Samsung specifies USB 3.2 Gen 2 and an IP65 rating tested under controlled conditions.
- Samsung says liquid and dust damage aren’t covered by the warranty. The rating doesn’t replace a data backup.
Crucial
X9 is a compact SSD range for files on the move and backups.
- Crucial lists read speeds of up to 1,050 MB/s for X9, based on its own sequential test conditions.
- According to the manufacturer, performance and compatibility with your device depend on factors including the host and formatting.
External HDDs for large project folders
The Joybuy products shown here are external HDDs for storing large project folders; the selection includes both portable and desktop models.
No image available
WD Elements Portable 5TB USB-C
For large project folders you want to store and take to rehearsal venues when needed.
5 TB; USB-C and USB 3.2 Gen 1; portable 2.5-inch format weighing 240 g.
View at Joybuy
No image available
WD Elements Portable 6TB USB-C
A portable HDD option for taking large working folders between computers or to rehearsal venues.
6 TB; USB-C and USB 3.2 Gen 1; portable 2.5-inch format weighing 240 g.
View at Joybuy
No image available
WD Elements Portable 4TB USB-C
For project folders you want to store on a portable HDD and take with you when needed.
4 TB; USB-C and USB 3.2 Gen 1; portable 2.5-inch format weighing 240 g.
View at Joybuy
No image available
WD Elements Portable 2TB USB-C
A portable storage option if you want to use your project folders with Windows and macOS computers.
2 TB; USB-C and USB 3.2 Gen 1; exFAT; 2.5-inch format weighing 131 g, powered via USB. Windows and macOS use is specified.
View at Joybuy
No image available
WD Elements Desktop 8TB
For large, completed project folders you want to store in a fixed location.
8 TB; USB 3.0; NTFS; desktop 3.5-inch drive with external power supply. The product description says it needs to be reformatted for macOS.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
How can I back up several script versions, rather than just the current folder?
In Windows, File History can save previous versions of files to an external drive. You’ll need to add any folders outside the libraries it covers; then test whether you can restore the version you want from a file. Microsoft Support explains how this feature works and how to choose folders.
Can I write to an HDD set up for Windows on a Mac?
It depends on the specific model and file system. Toshiba says Canvio Basics is pre-formatted as NTFS and needs to be reformatted for macOS; for the Expansion Portable model in question, Seagate says it needs to be reformatted for Time Machine. Check the file system and the read and write access you need before filling the drive.
What should I plan for when backing up and restoring files?
Keep a separate copy and allow time to test restoring it. Toshiba specifies a two-year warranty for the Canvio Basics version in question; Seagate’s data sheet lists a two-year limited warranty for EMEA. Check the terms for the model you actually buy, and don’t treat a manufacturer’s warranty as a recoverable backup.
Do I need a drive with built-in encryption for confidential theatre documents?
Don’t decide based on the type of drive alone: consider what data you’ll store, who needs access and how access will work if you need to recover files. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security describes software-based encryption for individual files, folders or entire storage devices as one possible way to protect them.