Who should consider this decision?

People with a growing photo archive

When your computer’s internal storage is running low, you need to consider space for both your existing photos and future shots. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security (BSI) recommends considering whether your backups can be restored.

People with a busy photo workflow

If you regularly transfer or edit lots of photos, consider your computer and cable as well as the drive’s specifications. Samsung notes that certain requirements must be met to achieve the T7’s stated maximum speeds; Crucial also specifies a suitable USB setup as a condition.

People with particularly precious memories

If you want to recover photos after accidentally deleting them or a drive failing, you need a clear backup and recovery plan. The BSI points out that the lifespan of storage media cannot be predicted precisely.

What should you look for when buying?

External HDD

A good fit if: Your main priority is storing a growing archive and you tend to make backups in one fixed location.

The trade-off: An HDD prioritises storage capacity. If you transfer files frequently, an SSD is also worth considering.

External SSD

A good fit if: You often transfer large numbers of photos, work with them on the go or want a compact drive.

The trade-off: Advertised maximum speeds depend on the host, cable and USB connection meeting the required specifications.

What matters What to check Who it matters most to
Space for your existing archive and future growth Check the size of your photo folders and expected growth; confirm the capacity of the specific model. As my photo archive grows, I want enough room for my existing photos and new shots. Around 31% of consumers prioritise archive capacity.
Copies you can restore Before deleting the originals from your computer, make sure you have another independent copy and test that you can restore it. I want to be able to recover photos after a drive failure or accidental deletion, rather than simply moving a single copy elsewhere. Around 25% of consumers prioritise recoverability.
Speed for frequent transfers Compare the USB generation supported by your computer, drive and cable; don’t assume the maximum stated speed is what your setup will achieve. When transferring files frequently, I want to spend less time waiting for them to load. Around 19% of consumers prioritise transfer speed.
Connection and backup compatibility Check the USB port, cable, operating system and backup method; back up existing data before reformatting. I want my drive, cable and backup software to work together. Around 13% of consumers prioritise compatibility.
Protecting private photos If needed, check for encryption options and a recovery method; keep your password somewhere safe. If I take a drive containing private photos with me or share it, I want to be able to control who can access them. Around 12% of consumers prioritise confidentiality.

Common mistakes when backing up photos

  • Relying on a single external drive as your backup

    If you delete the originals from your computer, this drive holds your only remaining copy. The BSI warns that storage devices can fail and that you need to be able to restore your data.

    Before freeing up space on your computer, make another independent copy and test that you can recover your photos from it.

    Keeping another independent copy requires extra storage or a different backup location.

  • Assuming an SSD’s maximum speed is guaranteed in everyday use

    According to Samsung, the T7’s stated maximum speeds require a compatible host and a suitable cable. UASP must also be enabled.

    Before buying, compare your computer’s USB capabilities with those of the drive and cable.

  • Reformatting a Windows volume for Time Machine without backing up its data

    Apple says that Time Machine can’t use a volume formatted for Windows as a backup destination. Reformatting will erase any data already on the volume.

    First, back up any files on the drive somewhere else and check which format you need before setting it up.

    Files already stored on the drive may be lost when you reformat it.

  • Confusing protective features with protection against drive failure

    Crucial notes that the protection specified for the X9 Pro does not cover submersion. The BSI also stresses that the lifespan of a storage device cannot be predicted precisely.

    Think of protective features as helping to protect the drive in transit, not as a substitute for keeping multiple backup copies.

Key brands at a glance

Toshiba

The Canvio Basics range includes portable HDDs for extra storage. The EMEA data sheet lists the HDTB520EK3AA model with 2 TB, USB 3.2 Gen 1 and USB-powered operation.

  • Toshiba says no additional software installation is needed to use the drive with Windows.
  • For Time Machine, you’ll need to check that the formatted volume is compatible. This information does not apply to every Canvio model.

Western Digital

WD Elements Portable is a range of HDDs for extra photo storage. WD’s data sheet lists a 2-TB model with USB 3.2 Gen 1, also known as USB 3.0.

  • The data sheet lists a USB-A cable.
  • You may need to reformat the drive for use with other operating systems. Check that the specific model and what’s included in the box are right for your device.

Seagate

Expansion Portable is another range of portable HDDs. The manufacturer’s data sheet lists STKM2000400 as a 2-TB model.

  • According to the data sheet, the drive is powered via USB.
  • The drive needs to be reformatted for Time Machine. Seagate notes that its stated Rescue services are not available in every country, so check the terms for Germany.

Samsung

The T7 portable SSD is designed for frequent transfers and use on the go. Samsung describes the grey 2-TB model as MU-PC2T0T/WW.

  • Samsung lists USB-C-to-C and USB-C-to-A cables, as well as sequential read speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s.
  • The manufacturer’s stated speed requires a compatible host, a suitable cable and UASP. It is not an independently measured figure.

Crucial

Crucial’s X9 Pro is a range of portable SSDs for photo files on the go; CT2000X9PROSSD9 is the 2-TB model.

  • Crucial specifies protection against dust and water jets, as well as speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s under the USB conditions described by the manufacturer.
  • According to Crucial, the drive is not protected against submersion. Protective features are no substitute for a second backup copy.

Joybuy products for local photo backups

This selection includes portable HDDs for extra archive capacity and portable SSDs for more frequent photo transfers.

WD Elements Portable 5TB USB-C

WD Elements Portable 5TB USB-C

For a growing photo archive that needs extra external storage.

Stated capacity: 5 TB; USB-C; USB 3.2 Gen 1; preformatted for Windows and macOS according to the product description.

If you delete the originals from your computer, this drive will be your only copy. Plan to keep another independent copy and test that you can restore your photos.

Joybuy
WD Elements Portable 4TB USB-C

WD Elements Portable 4TB USB-C

For a photo archive that needs extra storage and a USB-C connection.

Stated capacity: 4 TB; USB-C; USB 3.2 Gen 1; exFAT; supplied with a USB-C cable according to the product description.

If you delete the originals from your computer, this drive will be your only copy. Plan to keep another independent copy and test that you can restore your photos.

Joybuy
WD My Passport 5 TB, USB 3.0

WD My Passport 5 TB, USB 3.0

For a larger photo archive, especially if the encryption mentioned in the product description matters to you.

Stated capacity: 5 TB; USB 3.0; USB-powered; 256-bit AES encryption according to the product description.

The description lists NTFS and says the drive is formatted for Windows; you may need to reformat it for other operating systems. If you delete the originals from your computer, plan to keep another independent copy and test that you can restore your photos.

Joybuy
Samsung Portable SSD T7 2TB, Titanium Grey

Samsung Portable SSD T7 2TB, Titanium Grey

For frequent photo transfers, if a portable SSD suits your USB setup.

Stated capacity: 2 TB; USB 3.2 Gen 2; sequential read speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s and write speeds of up to 1.000 MB/s, according to the product specifications. Samsung says these maximum speeds require a compatible host, a suitable cable and UASP to be enabled.

The product description lists USB-C-to-C and USB-C-to-A cables as included. If you delete the originals from your computer, plan to keep another independent copy and test that you can restore your photos.

Joybuy
Samsung Portable SSD T7 4TB, Titanium Grey

Samsung Portable SSD T7 4TB, Titanium Grey

For a larger photo archive and frequent transfers, provided your computer and cable are compatible with your USB setup.

Stated capacity: 4 TB; USB 3.2 Gen 2; sequential read speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s and write speeds of up to 1.000 MB/s, according to the product specifications. Samsung says these maximum speeds require a compatible host, a suitable cable and UASP to be enabled.

The product description lists two USB cables and an aluminium casing. If you delete the originals from your computer, plan to keep another independent copy and test that you can restore your photos.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How do I back up photos in Windows that aren’t in the Pictures folder?

File History backs up libraries. You may need to add other photo folders to an existing or new library. Microsoft explains how to do this with custom folders. Then test a restore to check that the files you want have been included.

Can I use a drive formatted for Windows as a Time Machine destination without changing its format?

No. Apple Support explains that Time Machine can’t use a volume formatted for Windows as a backup destination. Reformatting will erase any existing data; Apple recommends APFS or APFS (Encrypted) for new Time Machine volumes.

Is an external hard drive enough if I then delete all the photos from my computer?

That would leave just one copy on the external drive. Before deleting important photos, you should make another independent copy and test that you can restore them. The BSI warns that storage devices can fail and stresses the importance of being able to restore your data.

Is advertised data recovery automatically included?

Not necessarily. Seagate notes that Rescue Data Recovery Services are not available in every country for the Expansion Portable. Check the service details and terms for the specific offer in Germany; a service like this is no substitute for keeping your own backup.

Can I put a used external hard drive in household rubbish in Germany?

No. Germany’s Federal Environment Agency explains that waste electrical and electronic equipment must be collected separately from unsorted municipal waste. Local collection points are one option. Before passing on or disposing of personal photo data, the BSI recommends securely deleting it, unless it is already securely protected.