If you regularly work directly from your drive, an external SSD is an obvious choice, provided your computer and cable support the connection you need. An HDD may suit large archives that you rarely edit. A single drive is no substitute for a separate backup: the Federal Office for Information Security recommends backing up regularly and checking that you can restore your files. Work out how much storage you need based on complete project folders, including the media they use, and distinguish RAW photos from raw video, which can take up considerably more space.
Which option is right for you?
Active music and media editing
If you often open projects or samples directly from external storage and regularly transfer camera files, access speed and the connection speed your devices actually support are important factors. Ableton notes that a drive’s access speed can limit Live’s performance.
Growing project archives
If you mainly keep completed music projects and original camera files, take into account the total storage required, including the media used in your projects. Ableton explains that ‘Collect All and Save’ copies the audio and video files used into the project folder.
Backing up irreplaceable work
If you want to recover music and camera files after a drive failure, you’ll need a separate copy and should check that you can restore the files from it. The Federal Office for Information Security recommends backing up data regularly.
What should you look for when buying?
First decide whether you’ll work directly from the drive regularly or mainly use it to archive files. Then plan for a separate backup and check that the drive, computer and file system suit the way you’ll use them.
| Criteria |
What to look for when buying |
Who is this especially important for? |
| Space for complete projects |
Count complete project folders, extra versions and the media used; distinguish RAW photos from raw video. |
If I want to keep projects with their media and original camera files, the total amount of data matters to me. Around 29% of consumers prioritise enough space for complete projects and original files. |
| Access while working |
Check that your computer and cable support the drive’s connection. Ableton identifies access speed as a potential performance bottleneck in Live. |
If I often work directly with external audio or camera files, access speed matters more to me than a speed my computer can’t use. Around 29% of consumers put active editing first. |
| Separate backup |
Consider a separate storage device and check that you can restore the files you need from it. The Federal Office for Information Security emphasises that you should also test the restore process. |
If I want to recover irreplaceable projects after a failure, I need a separate copy that I can restore. Around 24% of consumers prioritise protecting their data. |
| Use with multiple computers |
Check the file system, write access and required software on every device. Apple lists exFAT as a Windows-compatible format for volumes larger than 32 GB. |
If I want to use files across different computers, the drive and projects need to work on each device. Around 18% of consumers prioritise using their storage with multiple computers. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Moving your only copy to a new drive
If that drive fails, the only copy stored on it is at risk too. The Federal Office for Information Security recommends keeping a separate backup and highlights the importance of being able to restore your files.
Keep an additional copy on a separate storage device and test that you can open important files from it.
You’ll need an additional storage device, as well as time for regular backups and restore tests.
-
Keeping only the music project file
A project may refer to audio or video files stored outside its project folder. In Ableton Live, ‘Collect All and Save’ copies the audio and video files used into the project folder, but it doesn’t copy plug-ins.
Use the relevant function in your music software to collect the media you’ve used, and check which plug-ins you’ll need on another computer.
Collected audio and video files need extra storage; you may also need to install plug-ins separately on another computer.
-
Choosing an SSD for its advertised peak speed without checking the connection
Speed also depends on your computer’s connection and the cable. Samsung quotes up to 2,000 MB/s for the T9 under the stated conditions; Kingston notes that the XS2000 doesn’t reach its advertised Gen-2x2 speed on a Mac.
Check the USB protocols supported by your devices and make sure you have the right cable before factoring advertised peak speeds into your decision.
Key brands at a glance
Samsung
The Portable SSD T9 is designed for frequent transfers of large files, provided your computer and cable support the right connection.
- Samsung quotes sequential speeds of up to 2,000 MB/s for the T9 under the stated conditions.
- The manufacturer’s figure isn’t a measurement from your computer; the host, cable and other requirements all affect the speed you can achieve.
Kingston
The XS2000 is a compact external SSD for computers with a compatible USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 connection.
- Kingston describes the XS2000 as compatible with Mac.
- According to Kingston, it doesn’t reach its advertised Gen-2x2 speed on a Mac.
SanDisk
The Extreme PRO Portable SSD is a range of SSDs for large files and mobile use; the researched 1-TB version has the model number SDSSDE81-1T00-G25.
- SanDisk quotes USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 and read and write speeds of up to 2,000 MB/s.
- These are manufacturer’s figures, not independent measurements for your computer setup.
Western Digital
My Passport is a range of portable HDDs for files you mainly want to keep in storage; the German 5-TB version is called WDBPKJ0050BBK-WESN.
- Western Digital lists this specific version with 5 TB of storage.
- Whether that’s enough depends on your complete project folders and camera files; one drive is no substitute for a separate backup.
Crucial
The X10 Pro is a range of SSDs for large media collections and frequent transfers.
- Crucial lists versions with 1, 2 and 4 TB of storage, and manufacturer peak speeds of 2,100 MB/s for reading and 2,000 MB/s for writing.
- These are manufacturer’s figures and don’t indicate the speed you can achieve with your particular device and cable combination.
Joybuy products for this topic
This selection includes external HDDs for archives you mainly leave untouched, and external SSDs for active music and media projects.
No image available
WD Elements Portable 6 TB USB-C
An option for archives you mainly leave untouched. For frequent access to active music projects, an HDD can become a performance bottleneck.
The product name lists 6 TB and USB-C. You’ll also need a separate backup copy for irreplaceable files.
View at Joybuy
No image available
WD Elements 8 TB Desktop External Hard Drive, USB 3.0
This desktop HDD is designed for large collections you mainly leave untouched. For frequent access to active music projects, an HDD can become a performance bottleneck.
The product name lists 8 TB, USB 3.0 and a 3.5-inch drive. This drive on its own isn’t a separate backup copy.
View at Joybuy
No image available
KIOXIA Exceria Plus G2 Portable SSD 2 TB
An external SSD for active music and media projects. Check that its capacity and connection suit your complete files and devices.
The product name lists 2 TB. A single SSD is no substitute for a separate backup copy.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Samsung Portable SSD T7 4 TB, Titanium Grey
An external SSD for active project files and media. Work out how much storage you need based on complete project folders, including the audio and video files they use.
The product name lists 4 TB, USB Type-C and USB 3.2 Gen 2. Irreplaceable files also need a separate backup.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Samsung Portable SSD T9 2 TB (MU-PG2T0B)
An external SSD for active projects and large transfers. Its advertised peak speed requires compatible connections and cables.
This version offers 2 TB of storage. Samsung quotes sequential speeds of up to 2,000 MB/s for this T9 model, provided that the host and cable support USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 and UASP mode is enabled, among other requirements. You’ll also need a separate backup.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Is it enough to copy just the music project file to the external drive?
Not necessarily. In Ableton Live, ‘Collect All and Save’ copies the audio and video files used into the project folder; plug-ins aren’t copied and need to be available separately on another computer. Check the equivalent collect or export process in your music software.
Which file system should I use for a storage drive shared between Mac and Windows?
Apple lists exFAT as a Windows-compatible format for volumes larger than 32 GB. Before formatting, check that you’ll have the write access you need and back up any files already on the drive. The connections and requirements of your apps also need to be compatible.
Is a longer manufacturer’s warranty the same as your statutory rights?
No. Your statutory rights cover claims against the seller if a product is faulty; a manufacturer’s warranty is subject to its own terms. The Verbraucherzentrale recommends checking the warranty terms and the relevant contact separately. An advertised warranty period doesn’t mean your data can be recovered.
Can you put a retired external hard drive in household rubbish in Germany?
No. The Federal Environment Agency recommends taking electrical and electronic waste to recycling centres or suitable retail take-back points, and advises against putting it in household rubbish. The Federal Office for Information Security recommends securely deleting personal data before passing on or disposing of a storage device.
How can I check that my backup will actually work?
Back up your own files regularly to a separate device, then check that you can restore and open the copy. The Federal Office for Information Security notes that having a storage device alone doesn’t guarantee you’ll be able to recover your files.