Which option is right for you?

Producers with active projects

If you regularly open sessions and samples directly from an external drive, look for an SSD and make sure your computer, drive and cable are compatible. Ableton also lists external drives as a storage location for audio files and Packs you use regularly.

Musicians with irreplaceable recordings

If your main concern is being able to recover projects after a drive failure, you need a separate backup and should check that you can restore files from it. The German Federal Office for Information Security recommends ensuring that backed-up data can be restored, too.

Producers with large project archives

If you keep lots of completed sessions or large recordings, balance your storage needs against access speed. Western Digital and Seagate data sheets describe portable HDDs as storage options for larger collections.

What to consider when buying

External SSD as a working drive

A good choice if: you regularly open and edit projects, recordings or samples directly from the drive.

The trade-off: Advertised peak speeds depend on compatible ports and cables; a working drive is no substitute for a separate backup.

External HDD for archiving and backups

A good choice if: you store large projects you rarely access, or backups where speed is less important.

The trade-off: An HDD is slower than an SSD for active work; relying on a single HDD alone does not guarantee you can recover your files.

First decide whether you’ll use the drive for active work, keep it as a separate backup or use it mainly for archiving.

Consideration What to check when buying Who it matters most to
Access to active projects Choose an SSD or HDD to suit how you’ll use it; check that your computer, drive and cable support the same USB standard. If I open sessions and samples directly from the drive, I want quick access. Around 36% of consumers put active work first.
Separate backup Keep your working copy and backup separate; check that you can restore files from the backup. If my recordings are irreplaceable, I want to be able to fall back on a separate copy if something goes wrong. Around 29% of consumers prioritise keeping a separate backup.
Space for your archive Consider your existing project folders and how they might grow; check the capacity of the specific model you’re buying. If you keep lots of completed sessions, you need enough space, but not necessarily the fastest SSD available. Around 21% of consumers put archive capacity first.
Connection and file system Check your available ports and cables; make sure the file system is suitable if you’ll share the drive with Windows or use it for Time Machine. If I want to use a drive with different systems or set it up for Time Machine, the connection and format need to be compatible. Around 14% of consumers prioritise system compatibility.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Relying on your only project drive as a backup

    A drive failure or accidental deletion could wipe out the only copy of your creative work.

    Keep your working drive and backup separate, and occasionally check that you can restore files.

    Backing up may require an additional storage device and time for regular backup runs.

  • Assuming USB-C guarantees 20 Gbit/s speeds

    Actual data transfer rates depend on the drive, host and connection. To reach the up to 2,000 MB/s advertised by Samsung for the T9, both the host device and cable must support USB 3.2 Gen 2x2.

    Check the specific USB standard supported by your workstation and the cable requirements before relying on advertised MB/s figures.

    Paying extra for a faster SSD won’t automatically give you the speed boost you expect from your existing port.

  • Copying the project file but forgetting linked samples

    If media files are stored outside the project folder, their links may break when you move the project.

    Check the media linked in your DAW. In Ableton Live, you can gather the files you need in the project folder using ‘Collect All and Save’.

    Extra copies of media files take up additional storage space.

  • Judging an older SanDisk Extreme V2 drive by its model name alone

    In 2023, SanDisk reported a firmware issue that could affect certain Extreme Portable SSD V2, Extreme Pro Portable SSD V2 and WD My Passport SSD drives. The notice does not apply to all SanDisk drives or WD HDDs.

    If you own or are buying second-hand one of these specific SSD versions, check the model and serial number against the manufacturer’s information, and keep a separate backup.

Key brands at a glance

Samsung

The T7 is a portable SSD for active files; the T9 is designed for setups with USB 3.2 Gen 2x2.

  • Samsung quotes read speeds of up to 1,050 MB/s and write speeds of up to 1,000 MB/s for the T7. For the T9, Samsung quotes sequential speeds of up to 2,000 MB/s; these peak figures require the appropriate connection.
  • IP65 protection is a feature of the T7 Shield and does not apply to the T7 as a whole.

Kingston

The XS1000 is a portable Gen-2 SSD; the XS2000 is a Gen-2x2 option for compatible ports.

  • Kingston quotes read speeds of up to 1,050 MB/s and write speeds of up to 1,000 MB/s for the XS1000, and read and write speeds of up to 2,000 MB/s for the XS2000.
  • The manufacturer’s figures refer to different product ranges and are not guaranteed speeds on every home studio PC.

Western Digital

The My Passport HDD range is worth considering for large archives or as a dedicated backup drive.

  • Western Digital’s data sheet lists capacities from 1 to 6 TB, as well as password protection and hardware encryption.
  • For frequent direct access to projects, an HDD is slower than an SSD. Bundled software does not remove the need to check that you can restore your backups.

Seagate

The Expansion Portable is an HDD option for offloading and backing up larger collections that don’t need to be accessed quickly.

  • Seagate lists a capacity of 5 TB and USB 3.0 for model STKM5000400.
  • This model information comes from a US product page and does not confirm availability in Germany; check the specific version before buying. You may need to reformat it for Time Machine.

Crucial

The X9 Pro is a portable SSD for active files, provided its format and connection are compatible with your setup.

  • Crucial quotes read and write speeds of up to 1,050 MB/s for the X9 Pro, along with USB-C.
  • Crucial says compatibility can be affected by formatting, host features and the operating system; this specification does not establish that it is better than other Gen-2 SSDs.

Joybuy products for active projects

The external SSDs below are suited to use as working drives for sessions and samples you access regularly. They are no substitute for a separate backup of important projects.

KEXIN external SSD, 256 GB

KEXIN external SSD, 256 GB

This model could work as an external SSD for project files you use regularly.

The product listing specifies USB 3.1 Type-C and speeds of up to 500 MB/s.

As your only drive, it is no substitute for a separate backup of important projects.

View at Joybuy
Kexin M.2 SATA external SSD, 256 GB

Kexin M.2 SATA external SSD, 256 GB

This model could work as an external SSD for project files you use regularly.

The product listing specifies M.2 SATA, USB 3.1 and speeds of up to 500 MB/s.

As your only drive, it is no substitute for a separate backup of important projects.

View at Joybuy
KEXIN external SSD, 512 GB

KEXIN external SSD, 512 GB

This model could work as an external SSD for project files you use regularly.

The product listing specifies USB 3.1 Type-C, 512 GB and speeds of up to 500 MB/s.

As your only drive, it is no substitute for a separate backup of important projects.

View at Joybuy
Samsung Portable SSD T7, 1 TB

Samsung Portable SSD T7, 1 TB

This model could work as an external SSD for project files you use regularly.

The product listing specifies USB Type-C and USB 3.2 Gen 2.

As your only drive, it is no substitute for a separate backup of important projects.

View at Joybuy
Samsung SSD T7, 2 TB

Samsung SSD T7, 2 TB

This model could work as an external SSD for project files you use regularly.

The product listing specifies 2 TB of storage.

As your only drive, it is no substitute for a separate backup of important projects.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is a fast external SSD automatically the right choice for every music session?

No. An SSD’s faster data transfer makes it a good choice for project and sample files you access directly and often; an HDD may also suit mostly completed projects. According to Samsung, the T9’s advertised Gen-2x2 peak speed requires a compatible host and cable.

What should I bear in mind when moving an Ableton Live project?

Ableton recommends using ‘Collect All and Save’ for external media files used in the project, then copying the entire project folder. Third-party plug-ins are not copied into the project folder. Check the transferred project and allow for the extra storage needed for copied samples.

How do I format a drive for Mac and Windows, and can I use it with Time Machine?

Apple lists ExFAT as a format option for drives over 32 GB that you want to use with Windows. For Time Machine volumes, Apple prefers APFS or APFS (Encrypted). Back up any existing files before reformatting a drive.

What are my rights if a drive I bought in Germany stops working?

When you buy from a business seller, your statutory consumer rights apply. EU consumer information states that these rights last for at least two years from receipt of the goods; if a fault occurs, you are initially entitled to a free repair or replacement. A voluntary manufacturer’s warranty is separate. These EU rules do not apply to purchases from private individuals.

Can I put a retired external hard drive in household rubbish in Germany?

No. The German Environment Agency says that electrical and electronic waste must be disposed of separately from household rubbish, for example at a local collection point. Back up any music projects you still need before handing in the drive.